In short:
The MidCoast Council is the first in NSW to gain certification for large-scale "managed retreat" in a coastal management plan.
asserted
Council → gain → plan
The council has ruled out expensive mitigation options such as beach groynes or seawalls at erosion hotspots, including Old Bar.
What's next?
asserted
What → rule → Bar
Local governments can spend a decade developing coastal management plans for individual estuaries.
asserted
governments → spend → estuaries
Greg Dickson might enjoy enviable ocean views, but he also faces the prospect of seeing his home washed away by the sea.
uncertain
home → enjoy → sea
His house, which sits atop the dunes at Old Bar South on the New South Wales Mid North Coast, has been identified by the MidCoast Council as being "at immediate risk" of coastal erosion.
asserted
which → sit → erosion
But the council's Old Bar Manning Point coastal management plan (CMP) is based on a strategy of "managed retreat".
asserted
plan → base → retreat
That means it will let the coastline erode naturally, without investing in permanent infrastructure to protect homes.
asserted
coastline → mean → homes
"It does put a stress on the people that live here, knowing council is not going to come and help if there is any sort of natural disaster," Mr Dickson said.
"
asserted
Dickson → put → disaster
I'd be right, but there's a lot of people along here who are pensioners, and that would be a disaster to them."
asserted
that → be → them
MidCoast Council is the first in the state to gain NSW government certification for the sort of large-scale coastal retreat it has planned for the Manning Point and Old Bar villages.
asserted
it → gain → villages
Its manager of natural systems, Gerard Tuckerman, said in the short term, fewer than 20 homes in the area were vulnerable, but by 2100, several hundred could be at risk.
uncertain
hundred → say → risk
He said the council's decision to opt for a coastal retreat was backed by the latest science and extensive community consultation since 2008.
asserted
decision → say → 2008
"We know sea-level rise is increasing, as that's what the data is saying," Mr Tuckerman said.
"
asserted
Tuckerman → know → what
"Managed retreat is about buying as much time as we can for our community, so residents can invest in geotextile sandbags to protect their property, which can work well for quite some time."
Several homes in Mr Dickson's street have already been lost to storms and severe erosion events.
A row of three homes was demolished in 2008, and another two in 2014 after their foundations crumbled.
asserted
foundations → manage → 2014
He said the council should invest in large-scale sand replenishment rather than providing sandbags and a licence to shift sand to the dunes.
asserted
council → say → dunes
"Let's work out a plan to put the sand back rather than just retreat beyond the streets that we live in," Mr Dickson said.
asserted
Dickson → let → that
The council said it had explored a range of protection options over the years, including taking sand from an estuary at Farquhar Inlet to pump onto Old Bar Beach in 2010.
asserted
it → say → 2010
Mr Tuckerman said that option would have cost the council $147 million at the time and involved pumping 1 million cubic metres of sand, enough to fill about 400 Olympic-size swimming pools.
asserted
option → say → pools
He said the process would have had to be repeated every decade.
asserted
process → say → ?
Mr Tuckerman said engineers also rejected building a seawall at Old Bar South, as it would damage the beach and the cost would far exceed the value of the protected properties.
asserted
cost → say → properties
"The wider community really value the beach and that's for recreation on the beach, walking the dog, going for a swim," he said.
asserted
he → value → swim
"The beach won't exist if you rock wall it or put in groynes, and as these types of engineering solutions are incredibly expensive.
asserted
types → exist → solutions
"We have found no way they can be funded.
asserted
they → find → way
A Department of Climate Change, Energy and Water spokesperson said 27 CMPs had been certified, but MidCoast was the first to adopt "managed retreat" on this scale.
asserted
MidCoast → say → scale
Each council can produce several localised plans to manage different coastal zones and individual estuaries.
asserted
council → produce → zones
Once a plan is accepted by the minister and certified, the NSW government commits to matching council spending on mitigation measures.
asserted
government → accept → measures
Councils including Byron and Port Macquarie Hastings are in the final stages of developing several location-based CMPs.
asserted
Councils → include → CMPs
Byron Shire Council's coastal and biodiversity coordinator Chloe Dowsett said there were 60 years of studies informing its plans for erosion hot spots.
asserted
coordinator → say → spots
Since 1988, no new development has been permitted within a 20-metre distance of an erosion escarpment, and existing consents cease if the escarpment reaches that distance from a building.
asserted
escarpment → permit → building
Ms Dowsett said managed retreat was already embedded in the council's planning guidelines for new developments
The dunes of the main beach at Byron Bay are reinforced by sandbags below revegetation plantings.
"We've always really tried to kind of seek for those more nature-based solutions or soft solutions as well, knowing that the coast comes and goes, we need to give it that space," Ms Dowsett said.
asserted
Dowsett → say → space
Port Macquarie-Hastings Council expects to gain CMP certification in 2027 for its plans.
asserted
Council → expect → plans
The council's coast and estuary coordinator, Ben Foster, has ruled out managed retreat in the current 10-year program, but said it could be required in the following decade.
uncertain
it → rule → decade
Mr Foster said the council would work closely with residents in at-risk locations to see "whether it is feasible to stay in place and mitigate through engineering options, or whether we have to look at a relocation and retreat strategy like MidCoast has".
asserted
MidCoast → say → strategy
Are governments moving fast enough?
asserted
governments → move → ?
A 2023 Intergovernmental Coastal Hazards Working Group report found up to 274,000 Australian homes and 8,600 commercial buildings might be affected by sea-level rise and stronger storms by the end of the century.
uncertain
homes → find → century
Griffith University research fellow Anne Leitch is the project manager for CoastAdapt, an Australian online science-based knowledge hub of the latest coastal risk data, tools and case studies.
asserted
Leitch → base → data
Her work connects her to councils grappling with coastal management planning.
asserted
work → connect → planning
"Coastal management planning is slow and climate impacts are happening faster than we were expecting," she said.
asserted
she → happen → ?
Ms Leitch said managed retreat was "a big call" for a council to make, requiring early community consultation.
asserted
council → say → consultation
"Defending and protecting is very expensive; it's a big cost up front," she said.
asserted
she → defend → front
…and 2 more, not listed.