Australia’s national security could have been endangered by a plot to sell parts of a military fighter jet between Russia and China, a court has heard, as details of how two men worked with an alleged Chinese spy were revealed for the first time.
uncertain
men → endanger → time
Facts of the case against Brisbane-based Russian émigré Alexander Cher and Gold Coast businessman Kim Bowei Lee have remained secret until this week, as a suppression order was lifted over their court cases.
asserted
order → base → cases
The pair were charged in 2022, as revealed by this masthead, after having flown to Russia in 2018, where they held meetings to sell parts of an SU-35 fighter jet.
asserted
they → charge → jet
One of the men spoke about the parts being restricted and needing Russian connections to “carry this out quietly”.
asserted
parts → speak → this
The trip was allegedly paid for by Chinese national and former Melbourne businessman Brian Chen, a member of the Chinese Communist Party.
uncertain
trip → pay → Party
An official source described Chen to this masthead in 2022 as a Chinese military intelligence operative “who travels the world as a spy”.
asserted
who → describe → spy
The prosecution said if the transaction for the jet parts had gone through, it would mean Australia had not enforced its international obligations to stop the acquisition of weapons.
asserted
Australia → say → weapons
The arrests came as part of a broader ASIO investigation into an alleged Chinese Communist Party spy network operation in Australia, with ties to a relative of Chinese President Xi Jinping.
asserted
arrests → come → Jinping
There was no suggestion Lee and Cher were involved in espionage activity.
asserted
Lee → be → activity
Australian Federal Police began investigating Chen’s activities and executed search warrants in December 2019 in Melbourne.
asserted
Police → begin → Melbourne
On Monday, Cher pleaded guilty in the Brisbane District Court to brokering involving military goods, with his barrister Mark McCarthy submitting he should receive a lesser sentence than his co-accused, of 12 to 18 months.
asserted
he → plead → months
Judge David Kent described the offending as serious, and difficult to detect, but found Lee was in a higher position to Cher, and acted as the conduit between him and Chen.
asserted
Lee → describe → him
He sentenced Cher to 18 months’ imprisonment, but to be released immediately on a recognisance order.
asserted
He → sentence → order
Kent said a letter of apology by Cher showed he accepted responsibility, and referred to his offending as an inexcusable mistake.
asserted
he → say → mistake
He sat calmly in the dock and spoke quietly with his legal team during the proceeding.
asserted
He → sit → proceeding
In an almost empty courtroom, he appeared to be accompanied by three supporters, including his wife.
asserted
he → appear → wife
Lee’s barrister, Jeffrey Hunter, KC, told the court his client first met Chen in Hong Kong, where he saw photographs of him with various foreign dignitaries.
asserted
he → tell → dignitaries
Lee assumed he had “good connections”.
asserted
he → assume → connections
“He didn’t know that Chen was in fact ... a loyal member of the [Chinese Communist] Party, and someone who was overtly working on behalf of the Chinese government,” he said.
asserted
he → know → government
The court heard Lee communicated with Chen about getting aviation parts from Russia, including jet fuel.
asserted
Lee → hear → fuel
The jet fuel was a legitimate transaction, the prosecution said, and was used as the official explanation to the Russian government during the negotiations.
asserted
prosecution → say → negotiations
Jennifer Single SC, representing the Commonwealth, said Chen in January 2018 advised Lee that the “SU-35 engine I need now is an airborne-phased array radar.
asserted
I → represent → Lee
Single said from the beginning, Lee knew the size of the transaction that was sought, and that it was about the SU-35 engine.
asserted
it → say → engine
She said from as early as February 2018, Lee knew the purchases were restricted, because Chen had advised him: “There is quite a large climate for spare parts for these.
asserted
Chen → say → these
Normal military purposes are restricted from Russia.
asserted
purposes → restrict → Russia
So those things will be sold through other channels.”
asserted
things → sell → channels
Chen also explained there was no way to buy the whole machine back for training.
asserted
Chen → explain → training
“This is restricted.
asserted
This → restrict → ?
Therefore, we need an ... intermediary to seek connections and carry this out quietly.
asserted
we → need → this
See whether connections can be made in Russia.”
asserted
connections → see → Russia
Lee messaged Chen later in the year.
asserted
Lee → message → year
“You, I and the company have all passed the Russian national security clearance.
asserted
You → pass → clearance
Now they have already given us level two.
asserted
they → give → level
We can advance corporation with their highly sensitive departments!
asserted
We → advance → departments
Remember, I said to you they would definitely do checks.”
asserted
they → remember → checks
Single said before travelling to Russia, the pair communicated about the clearances, writing: “they’re keeping an eye on us”.
asserted
they → say → us
Lee claimed upon reflecting on his offending: “I know what I did was wrong …
asserted
did → claim → what
If it had occurred, the security of Taiwan and Australia would’ve been impacted.
asserted
security → occur → Taiwan
I’m so sorry.”
asserted
I → ’m → ?
Single said these comments demonstrated that Lee knew if the transaction went ahead, the security of Taiwan and Australia would have been impacted.
asserted
security → say → Taiwan
…and 4 more, not listed.