The outgoing boss of the NSW Independent Casino Authority, Philip Crawford, effectively criticised the Minns government for its demonstrable unwillingness to introduce timely and effective harm-prevention law reforms (“Labor lacks bravery on pokies: Watchdog”, November 16).
asserted
Labor → criticise → pokies
Around 2016, his counterpart Chris Sidoti resigned because of apparent concerns with a lack of impartiality in the elected government balancing public interest with industry profits.
asserted
counterpart → resign → profits
Surely the alignment of legitimate serious common concerns from these two senior public officials responsible for overseeing the regulation of gambling and alcohol in NSW, though more than 10 years apart, is sufficient to suggest that the regulation of these harmful and powerful industries is a lost cause?
asserted
regulation → oversee → industries
Has it been effectively and systematically captured by pernicious commercial/political vested interests, aided by complicit elected lawmakers?
asserted
it → capture → lawmakers
The regulatory concept of “capture” has been recognised by the High Court (see McCloy v NSW) and the US Supreme Court as a serious form of “corruption”, and should be treated as such.
asserted
concept → recognise → corruption
Respective governments of NSW – and other states of Australia, for that matter – ought to be developing phasing-out plans of pokies from clubs.
asserted
governments → develop → clubs
Instead of cold-turkey culling, let’s just say we accept your fallible arguments about preventing disintegration of clubs (i.e. jobs) if pokies are spontaneously ripped out from underneath them.
asserted
pokies → let → them
And so if and when the phasing out with parallel programs in place is complete, and clubs can’t stand up on their own without those pokies (or a much greater regulated position therein), then “the market” has spoken.
asserted
market → stand → pokies
It means the fundamental activity of the club (food, sport, drinking, community use) must be profitable on its own; otherwise it’s essentially redundant.
asserted
it → mean → own
Governments can save their faces via this slower phasing-out by giving clubs ample time to improve their attractiveness.
asserted
Governments → save → attractiveness
It’s not sad or unfortunate that clubs might vanish.
uncertain
clubs → ’ → ?
Communities either support their clubs/pubs without pokies or accept their demise.
asserted
Communities → support → demise
Ted Bush, North Epping
Poker machine reform seems a niche where our state government could act without the whole electorate taking fright.
uncertain
electorate → seem → fright
It might actually provide some cost-of-living relief, and there would definitely be votes in it.
uncertain
It → provide → it
Instead, although it looks like paralysis, we suspect the government is in financial thrall to the gambling industry.
asserted
government → look → industry
And patience is wearing thin.
asserted
patience → wear → ?
Surely, the point of being in government is to make a real difference – not simply get re-elected.
asserted
point → make → difference
Margaret Johnston, Paddington
Truth always comes out
I have never understood why adults with children do this (“Deceit and debt behind ‘good’ divorce”, November 16).
asserted
adults → come → divorce
If one does the other over, the offspring will eventually find out.
asserted
offspring → do → other
It may be the day they are shopping for new uniforms.
uncertain
they → shop → uniforms
Or when the new partner moves into the penthouse above the food bank they are shopping in.
asserted
they → move → bank
Or even when they hear things and finally piece the puzzle together.
asserted
they → hear → puzzle
No amount of mandatory training for the accountant and lawyer, nor referrals back to the Family Court, will change this.
asserted
amount → change → this
In the end he is smiling, all the way to the bank.
asserted
he → smile → bank
For those of us who have advocated for children and protective parents for years, sustained scrutiny is welcome.
asserted
scrutiny → advocate → years
For example, why can’t we know how many parents were separated from their children by the court and why?
asserted
parents → know → court
Which recommendations from successive inquiries have been implemented?
asserted
recommendations → implement → inquiries
Who checks whether reforms actually protect families and, more particularly, children?
asserted
reforms → check → families
What happens when safeguards fail?
asserted
safeguards → happen → ?
Above all, how are children’s own accounts and wishes reflected in decisions governing their lives?
asserted
accounts → reflect → lives
Being heard must mean more than having their words recorded.
asserted
words → hear → more
The next chapter should track responsibility, action and results.
asserted
chapter → track → responsibility
Women and children need to know what has changed in practice – and who will answer for what has not.
asserted
what → need → practice
Grateful for Greenwich
I have never been in Alex Greenwich’s electorate, but I am mightily glad that he is there in the NSW lower house, fighting for reasonable and necessary matters such as VAD, compassionate abortion rights and decency towards our LGBTQ residents (“‘Distressing’: Greenwich’s office graffitied with homophobic slur”, November 16).
asserted
he → fight → slur
They attack from the gutter or, in Mark Latham’s case, even lower than that.
asserted
They → attack → that
They have set the stage for hopefully another terrific Trans-Tasman competition next month in the cricket.
asserted
They → set → cricket
Watching the men’s game in particular, one couldn’t help but be impressed at the large-scale singing of the national anthems by both the players and the crowd, accompanied by some streams of tears on the faces of those in both teams.
asserted
one → watch → teams
On reflection, this should be the norm, rather than the sometimes mumbled lip-syncing or dour looks that Australian athletes have been prone to display.
asserted
athletes → mumble → that
Our Oceanic neighbours have shown us up in this department, rightfully recognising that while their nations are not without faults, there is great honour in representing one’s country, and thus it is right to vocalise pride and actually mean it.
asserted
it → show → it
Chadd Sayers has bravely made a confident statement to confirm Usman Khawaja’s assertion (“Sayers claims whole Test side knew of sandpaper plot”, November 16).
uncertain
side → make → plot
…and 48 more, not listed.