A mother says she was turned away from her critically ill daughter's bedside at three hospitals before she died within weeks of getting a Covid jab.
asserted
she → say → jab
Sporty law student Natalie Boyce was 21 when she died on March 27, 2022 at The Alfred hospital in Melbourne, five weeks after receiving a Moderna vaccine booster.
asserted
she → die → booster
On Monday, the Coroners Court of Victoria began its inquest into her death as her mother demands answers.
asserted
mother → begin → answers
Ms Boyce, a fourth-year Bachelor of Laws and Commerce student at Deakin University, had been fit and healthy, working four days a week and on a fitness kick leading up to her death.
asserted
Boyce → work → death
She had planned a trip to Greece to celebrate her birthday in June that year.
asserted
She → plan → June
Counsel assisting the coroner Rachel Ellyard revealed details of Ms Boyce's final days, drawing on statements from Natalie's mother, Deborah Hamilton.
Ms Hamilton described her daughter as a happy, young, healthy and active girl, successful at university and a conscientious, hard worker who had already achieved much in her young life.
asserted
who → assist → life
The inquest heard that Ms Boyce had a Moderna Covid-19 booster on February 18 that year after Victoria's record-breaking Covid lockdowns.
asserted
Boyce → hear → lockdowns
At the time, Victorians had been warned the lockdowns would continue unless they received three jabs of the vaccine.
asserted
they → warn → vaccine
Sporty law student Natalie Boyce was 21 when she died on March 27, 2022 at The Alfred hospital in Melbourne, five weeks after receiving a Moderna vaccine booster
The next day Ms Boyce fainted and hit her head.
asserted
Boyce → die → head
Over the following two weeks, she visited her GP, then Angliss Hospital, then Monash Health's Clayton campus, before arriving at Mulgrave Private Hospital on March 5.
asserted
she → follow → March
An electrocardiograph at Mulgrave showed signs of possible pericarditis, a type of inflammation which affects the sac around a person's heart.
asserted
which → show → heart
Her condition worsened quickly, and she was transferred to The Alfred, where she was placed on life support within hours.
asserted
she → worsen → hours
The court heard her mother had driven her to Mulgrave after calling triple-0 and being told an ambulance would not arrive immediately.
asserted
ambulance → hear → triple-0
As Ms Boyce was loaded into the ambulance to take her to The Alfred, her mother briefly spoke with her.
asserted
mother → load → her
'Tragically, as Ms Hamilton has explained in her statement, that was the last opportunity Natalie and her mother had to speak to each other,' Ms Ellyard said.
asserted
Ellyard → explain → other
Ms Boyce spent about three weeks at The Alfred without ever speaking to her mother again.
asserted
Boyce → spend → mother
Natalie Boyce's condition worsened quickly, and she was transferred to The Alfred, where she was placed on life support within hours
She died on March 27 after going into cardiac arrest during an MRI.
Ms Hamilton, a single mother who raised Natalie and her older brother, Hayden, on her own, gave a fuller portrait to a Senate committee in May 2023.
She told the Senate she felt helpless.
'I was not allowed into the hospital because of government Covid regulations,' she said of her ordeal at Angliss.
At Monash, she said she still had texts from her daughter ‘pleading for me to come and be with her’ and claimed her daughter was ‘left sitting in a chair for eight hours’ during a stay of about 16 hours.
Mulgrave Private Hospital was different, she said.
uncertain
she → worsen → hours
It let her stay in the emergency department the whole time, but after following the ambulance to The Alfred around 2.30am, she said she was ‘not allowed in to be with Natalie and was told to go home’.
asserted
she → let → Natalie
During Ms Boyce's three weeks in intensive care, she told senators visits were limited at first to one hour on three days a week, and later to one hour a day.
asserted
visits → tell → hour
Deborah Hamilton drove her daughter Natalie (pictured) to Mulgrave after calling triple-0 and being told an ambulance would not arrive immediately
Coroner Catherine Fitzgerald will examine whether Ms Boyce had myocarditis – inflammation of the heart muscle - and what caused it.
asserted
what → drive → it
She will also look at whether antiphospholipid syndrome, an autoimmune condition Ms Boyce was diagnosed with in 2016, played a role.
asserted
Boyce → look → role
Two further questions are when her condition could first reasonably have been diagnosed as cardiac, and whether her death could have been prevented with different or additional care before March 6.
uncertain
death → diagnose → March
A forensic pathologist has proposed that Ms Boyce's death was caused by a heart attack in the setting of myocarditis, likely from a vaccine reaction in someone with her immune condition.
asserted
death → propose → condition
A cardiologist engaged by Moderna, which is represented at the inquest, has disputed that diagnosis.
asserted
which → engage → diagnosis
The American pharmaceutical giant believes myocarditis was not the main reason for her death and is expected to strongly contest the matter.
asserted
myocarditis → believe → matter
The inquest heard the Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA)'s expert panel agreed Ms Boyce's myocarditis was likely related to the vaccination, while acknowledging other factors may have contributed.
uncertain
factors → hear → vaccination
The TGA has since recommended strengthening the myocarditis warning in the product information for the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines.
asserted
TGA → recommend → vaccines
Deborah Hamilton condemned former Premier Dan Andrews for allegedly getting special treatment special treatment while he was in hospital for his injured back
At Angliss Hospital, tests for heart damage were done and read as normal, though the inquest will consider whether the ECG showed signs of a cardiac problem.
uncertain
ECG → condemn → problem
At Monash Health, where Ms Boyce spent about 15 hours on March 3, no ECG or troponin test was done.
asserted
test → spend → March
The court heard a Monash review panel 'didn’t come to a consensus view' on whether those tests were warranted.
asserted
tests → hear → view
The court heard The Alfred's care is not being examined, because Ms Boyce's condition on arrival meant her death could not have been prevented by different treatment.
uncertain
death → hear → treatment
The inquest was told it must avoid hindsight and that 'it's not part of the coroner's role to find fault or apportion blame'.
The aim is to understand what happened and prevent future deaths.
asserted
what → tell → deaths
'It is not about the pros and cons of vaccination,' Ms Ellyard said.
asserted
Ellyard → say → vaccination
Ms Hamilton claimed an Alfred nurse told her that Daniel Andrews was allowed visitors whenever he wanted, with no time limits, while he was in hospital during Covid
-
asserted
he → claim → Covid
Everything you need to know about the Daily Download
-
asserted
you → need → Download
Mail launches brand-new weekly global news podcast
asserted
Mail → launch → podcast
Inside HMP Grendon: New Mail podcast gains access to unique prison
- The Fentanyl Murders: The Mail launches new true-crime podcast
asserted
Mail → gain → podcast
Ms Hamilton lashed out when she addressed the Senate over her daughter's death.
asserted
she → lash → death
'Victoria was one of the most locked down places, and that is partly why Natalie had these vaccines,' she said then.
asserted
she → lock → vaccines
Ms Hamilton condemned former Premier Dan Andrews for allegedly getting special treatment while he was in hospital for his injured back during Covid.
uncertain
he → condemn → Covid
…and 3 more, not listed.