Canada’s youth jobs problem is usually told through one number.
asserted
problem → tell → number
Last week, Statistics Canada reported that the unemployment rate for Canadians aged 15 to 24 rose 0.7 percentage points to 13.7 percent in October, while the national rate climbed to 6.7 percent.
asserted
rate → report → percent
A new C.D. Howe Institute report argues the more troubling story is not how many young people are out of work, but how long they stay there.
asserted
they → argue → work
The report, by Tammy Schirle and Parisa Mahboubi, found that in early 2026, 30 percent of unemployed university graduates aged 20 to 24 had been looking for work for six months or more, a record high.
asserted
percent → find → months
As the Globe and Mail reported, 27 percent of unemployed men in that age group have been searching that long, the highest share since 1983.
asserted
percent → report → 1983
That is happening even though the unemployment rate for 20-to-24-year-olds was 9.9 percent in September, well below past peaks of roughly 18 percent.
asserted
rate → happen → percent
Most of these job seekers are not coming off a layoff.
asserted
Most → come → layoff
In 2025, 65 percent of unemployed men and 74 percent of unemployed women aged 20 to 24 were entering or re-entering the job market, the report found.
asserted
report → age → market
A degree still pays, but not right away necessarily
“A degree still pays off.
asserted
degree → pay → ?
Graduates have higher employment rates.
asserted
Graduates → have → rates
What it no longer does is shorten the job search,” Mahboubi, associate director of research at the C.D. Howe Institute, told The Hub in an email interview regarding her research.
asserted
Mahboubi → shorten → research
“University grads are now in the same position as those with only a high school diploma, and that’s a big change from the past.”
asserted
that → ’ → past
Degrees are more common and set people apart less, she said, but the main driver of the recent increase appears to be fewer entry-level openings and more graduates competing for them.
asserted
driver → set → them
Schirle, a professor of economics at Wilfrid Laurier University and a C.D. Howe research fellow, cautioned that the finding applies only to graduates who are already unemployed.
asserted
who → caution → graduates
“We know that university graduates are much less likely to find themselves unemployed in the first place,” she explained to The Hub, adding that they also clearly earn more than people with less education.
asserted
they → know → education
She said college diplomas and trades certificates are “also quite valuable.”
asserted
diplomas → say → ?
Unemployed young people with those credentials are facing longer searches but “have avoided that recent spike.”
A ‘low-hire, low-fire’ market
Mahboubi said the causes are “both cyclical and structural, and demographics add a third layer.”
asserted
demographics → face → layer
Job vacancies fell by nearly 40 percent between early 2023 and early 2026, and tariff and trade uncertainty has pushed employers to slow hiring rather than lay people off.
asserted
uncertainty → fall → people
In that mode, she said, they keep experienced staff and hire fewer new entrants.
asserted
they → say → entrants
The cuts were not evenly spread.
asserted
cuts → spread → ?
Vacancies requiring less than a year of experience fell by about half, according to the report, while Mahboubi said openings requiring eight or more years actually grew.
uncertain
openings → require → years
Most of the entry-level decline reflects fewer jobs overall, she said, but about a quarter reflects employers asking for more experience, a shift that appears across nearly every occupation.
asserted
that → reflect → occupation
“So the cycle explains the timing, but there’s a structural layer that may not unwind on its own.”
uncertain
that → explain → own
Schirle called the employer side “a bit of a puzzle.”
asserted
Schirle → call → puzzle
She said she would need more data to confirm where firms are finding experienced workers, but high participation rates among older Canadians are “worth considering.”
asserted
rates → say → Canadians
On immigration, Mahboubi said the post-pandemic surge could have added competition for entry-level jobs as hiring cooled, but the data make it hard to isolate the effect on young adults.
uncertain
it → say → adults
“But immigration doesn’t explain everything,” she said.
asserted
she → explain → everything
The report cites research showing the number of young bachelor’s graduates working in retail and food services rose by more than half between early 2023 and mid-2026.
asserted
number → cite → 2023
“Many are stuck in an experience trap: they need experience to get hired but can’t gain it without a job,” Mahboubi said.
asserted
Mahboubi → stick → job
The evidence doesn’t point to AI, yet
Both economists pushed back on the idea that artificial intelligence is wiping out junior jobs.
asserted
intelligence → point → jobs
“The Canadian evidence doesn’t point to AI,” Mahboubi said.
asserted
Mahboubi → point → AI
Research shows that once the shift to remote and hybrid work is accounted for, AI has no effect on junior hiring in Canada, she said.
asserted
she → show → Canada
Schirle was even more critical of the supposed link.
asserted
Schirle → suppose → link
“Most questions I receive about AI and youth unemployment are driven by anecdotes and imagination,” she said.
asserted
she → receive → anecdotes
“There’s no solid evidence to back up the notion that AI is taking anyone’s jobs.
asserted
AI → ’ → jobs
The report does acknowledge one U.S. study that found a 16 percent relative decline in employment for early-career workers in the occupations most exposed to generative AI.
asserted
that → acknowledge → AI
It calls the overall evidence “far from conclusive.”
asserted
It → call → evidence
What policymakers and graduates can do
Mahboubi said governments should focus on measures that help regardless of the cause.
asserted
that → say → cause
That means job-search support built for first-time job seekers, and more co-ops, internships, apprenticeships, and summer jobs.
asserted
That → mean → seekers
“These measures can’t fix a weak hiring market on their own, but they can help break the experience trap,” she said.
asserted
she → fix → trap
…and 10 more, not listed.