The City of Toronto’s emergency management division has racked up tens of thousands of dollars in expenses just this calendar year on categories of spending that include catering and “miscellaneous materials.”
asserted
that → rack → catering
The Toronto Sun acquired a list of spending by the division on purchases worth $250 or more via a freedom-of-information request.
asserted
Sun → acquire → request
The expenses aren’t itemized, so the Sun only knows the totals spent by category, such as $51,591.54 for computer software.
asserted
Sun → itemize → software
That’s despite the fact the Sun specifically requested invoices and receipts for the division’s large expenditures.
asserted
Sun → ’ → expenditures
Some of the totals appear large for a city hall outfit that numbers only 40 or so people.
asserted
that → appear → people
Emergency management spent $14,217.89 on catering services, $1,159.88 on kitchen supplies and $829.48 on food and beverage, the list shows.
asserted
list → spend → food
Another $15,823.65 went toward “miscellaneous materials and supplies” and $5,578 on “other office material,” while $2,964 was spent on books and magazines.
asserted
2,964 → go → books
Despite the division’s relatively low profile in the city, it spent $8,941.82 on advertising and promotions.
asserted
it → spend → advertising
The figures only cover spending between Jan. 1 and Sept. 14, when the numbers were requested by the Sun.
asserted
numbers → cover → Sun
That period notably covers the World Cup, which was a high-profile moment for city hall, and emergency management in particular.
asserted
which → cover → hall
In an emailed statement, the city defended its spending practices but provided no details on what had been bought or why.
asserted
what → email → details
These figures are being made public just weeks after an election campaign that saw Mayor Olivia Chow repeatedly insist that city hall doesn’t need a line-by-line audit.
asserted
hall → make → audit
They also come as city hall began a hiring freeze at the start of this month.
asserted
hall → come → month
The city confirmed in a statement it is “pausing most recruitments,” with notable exceptions including front-line paramedic and firefighter roles.
asserted
it → confirm → roles
Chow’s office ignored a request for comment from the Sun about the spending.
asserted
office → ignore → spending
The revelation also follows a handful of headline-making controversies for Joanna Beaven-Desjardins, the executive director of the city’s emergency management division.
asserted
revelation → follow → division
As the Sun has reported, Beaven-Desjardins was in the Rogers Centre for work only six times between 2024 and 2025: the dates of four Taylor Swift concerts and games 6 and 7 of the 2025 World Series.
asserted
Desjardins → report → Series
She has also been accused of communicating with subordinates on the messaging app Signal in violation of city policy.
asserted
She → accuse → policy
The Sun is seeking records that could confirm if Beaven-Desjardins used Signal or other messaging apps not sanctioned by city hall.
uncertain
Desjardins → seek → hall
The City of Toronto has refused to provide those records, and the Sun is pursuing an appeal of that decision.
asserted
Sun → refuse → decision
Many of the biggest totals come in categories associated with office tech, such as computer hardware and software, telecom services, network equipment, computer and printer supplies and contracted services for office equipment.
asserted
Many → come → equipment
While most of those categories involve five-figure outlays, city hall emphasized that for the emergency management division, which co-ordinates communication during the city’s major events and crisis responses, spending on technology can be equivalent to spending on safety.
asserted
spending → involve → safety
Eats ‘quite extravagant’: Source
“These expenses support the City of Toronto’s emergency management planning and response activities, including when the Toronto emergency operations centre is activated to co-ordinate incident response across city divisions, agencies and corporations,” Trevor Hyland, a director for the division, said in a brief emailed statement.
asserted
Hyland → support → statement
“All expenses are funded through Toronto city council-approved operating budgets and comply with the city’s expense policies and procedures.”
asserted
expenses → fund → policies
Despite questions from the Sun — including what “miscellaneous material” would cover, and whether or not the division even does advertising — the city provided nothing further.
asserted
city → include → nothing
A source at city hall, who the Sun has agreed to not identify to protect him from reprisals by top bureaucrats, said the catering outlay by emergency management was apparently “quite extravagant.”
asserted
outlay → agree → management
However, a leading company in Toronto’s catering industry told the Sun that $14,000 for a 40-people division is not necessarily excessive.
asserted
14,000 → lead → division
It could indicate city hall was regularly buying lunch for division staff, or that emergency management hosted a few events with people outside of the division invited.
uncertain
people → indicate → division
Still, the city hall source insisted the spending was unusual, saying the division’s staff typically bring lunch or dinner from home.
That source did agree with the city’s point on the importance of tech to the division.
asserted
source → insist → division
However, he also said he believed that TVs and video boards had been bought for emergency management specifically for World Cup operations, and those expenses perhaps weren’t necessary.
asserted
expenses → say → operations
“There’s a difference between having what you need to do the job and buying things because they look impressive,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → things
The city was also asked about the allegation, but its response did not directly address the matter.
asserted
response → ask → matter
Another $15,148.88 was spent on external training and development, and $6,606.64 on registration for conferences or seminars.
asserted
15,148.88 → spend → conferences