A New South Wales government bill to increase coal production at a Hunter Valley coalmine creates a “serious corruption risk” for the state due to a clause that would give the resources minister “king-like” powers, the barrister and anti-corruption campaigner Geoffrey Watson says.
asserted
that → increase → powers
The state parliament will this week debate legislation to allow MACH Energy to increase coal production at the Mount Pleasant mine in Muswellbrook by 32% to 16.5m tonnes per year.
asserted
Energy → debate → year
The Minns government announced the bill last month after the high court ruled that an expansion of the mine was invalidly approved.
asserted
expansion → announce → mine
The government has said the legislation is necessary to prevent 400 job losses at the site before Christmas.
asserted
legislation → say → Christmas
Watson, the Greens and some members of the crossbench have raised concerns that a clause in the bill would give the resources minister of the day “unusually broad” powers to override other state laws.
asserted
clause → raise → laws
Known as a Henry VIII clause, it would allow the minister to make regulations that could modify laws of the state as they apply to the Mount Pleasant development.
uncertain
they → know → development
Henry VIII provisions are sometimes used by parliaments and draw their name from King Henry VIII and his style of governing by royal proclamation.
asserted
provisions → use → proclamation
Watson is a director of the Centre for Public Integrity and Grata Fund and a former counsel assisting the NSW Independent Commission Against Corruption (Icac).
asserted
Watson → assist → Corruption
In a legal analysis of the bill, he raised concerns that Clause 17 “explicitly places” wide powers to “make new laws (or to repeal or modify existing laws) in the hands of one person – the mining minister – and for a single coal mine owner”.
asserted
Clause → raise → owner
“There are real problems with this as it is known that the concentration of this kind of power in the hands of one person creates a serious corruption risk,” he wrote.
asserted
he → be → risk
He said the risk was “heightened” because the Mount Pleasant bill had been created for a single private company.
asserted
bill → say → company
He wrote that while he imputed “no bad faith at all to the current mining minister”, past experience in the state “has shown that not all ministers have acted in a manner free from improper motives”.
asserted
ministers → write → motives
“Historically, we’ve seen this concentration of power into the hands of a single decision maker as posing a serious risk of corruption,” Watson told Guardian Australia.
asserted
Watson → see → Australia
“Now, corruption in that sense may not mean money passing hands.
uncertain
money → mean → hands
It also includes undue influence, decisions made in [circumstances] other than the public interest.”
asserted
It → include → interest
Elaine Johnson is the director of Johnson Legal, which represented the Denman Aberdeen Muswellbrook Scone Healthy Environment Group (Dams Heg) in the high court proceedings.
asserted
which → represent → proceedings
In a separate legal opinion, she raised similar concerns there was “a very obvious corruption risk arising from Clause 17”.
asserted
she → raise → Clause
She wrote that the clause gave the resources minister of the day “unfettered power to make regulations to change the application of any law of the state” to the mine, and said it could potentially affect many laws that applied to the mine, such as those that regulate noise and dust or worker safety.
uncertain
that → write → noise
The lower house is expected to debate the legislation on Tuesday, followed by the upper house later this week.
asserted
house → expect → house
The Minns government is hoping to pass the bill in what is likely to be the final sitting week before the March 2027 election.
asserted
what → hop → election
Both Labor and Coalition lower house seats are under pressure from One Nation in the Hunter, where the mine is located.
asserted
mine → locate → Hunter
One Nation’s NSW leader and candidate for Cessnock, Mike Newman, has described the Minns government’s bill to increase production limits at Mount Pleasant as a “Band-Aid on a bullet-wound”.
asserted
leader → describe → wound
The Coalition resources spokesperson and Nationals MP for Upper Hunter, Dave Layzell, said the opposition would not oppose Labor’s legislation “in any way”.
asserted
opposition → say → way
Asked about the Henry VIII clause, he said the Coalition would follow advice on the bill from the parliament’s legislation review committee which is expected on Tuesday.
asserted
which → ask → Tuesday
“We recognise [Labor’s] argument about the need to protect the number of jobs they are quoting.
asserted
they → recognise → jobs
“We agree that it is important that we fix the situation with the Mount Pleasant Mine extension.
asserted
we → agree → extension
“We cannot allow green environmental lawfare to continue to delay projects that have the support of the majority of the community, and are approved on a technical basis by the planning system.”
asserted
that → allow → system
The Greens climate spokesperson Sue Higginson said it was “the broadest” Henry VIII clause she had seen during the current parliament and the party would seek to remove it from the bill or limit its scope.
asserted
party → say → scope
“Placing that much power in the hands of a single minister is a corruption risk the Labor government should know well,” she said.
asserted
she → place → minister
“A tightly limited Henry VIII provision can be necessary to give effect to parliament’s decision over time, as with the recent Great Koala National Park bill, where it allowed more land to be permanently protected in the public interest as it becomes available.”
asserted
it → limit → interest
A spokesperson for the resources minister, Courtney Houssos, said the government had been clear that the purpose of its bill was to protect all permanent workers at Mount Pleasant.
asserted
purpose → say → Pleasant
They said the bill had been presented transparently to parliament.
asserted
bill → say → parliament
“We welcome constructive engagement on the Bill from crossbenchers and will engage with good-faith amendments as we always do,” they said.
asserted
they → welcome → amendments
“Any proposed regulation would be submitted to the Executive Council for approval and published transparently in the usual manner, and also subject to disallowance in the usual manner.”
asserted
regulation → propose → manner
They added that Henry VIII provisions had been “routinely” used in legislation for decades, including in bills the Greens had supported in this term of parliament.
asserted
Greens → add → parliament
The independent MP Alex Greenwich, who intends to oppose the bill as a whole, said the provision was “dangerously broad and quite unprecedented”.
asserted
provision → intend → whole
“It’s especially concerning, given parliament won’t sit for six months, meaning regulations issued during that time won’t be able to be disallowed,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → time