The Department of Justice (DOJ) has warned Democratic Senator Elizabeth Warren of Massachusetts that she could face "significant legal consequences" if she fails to preserve records related to potential Congressional investigations involving allies of President Donald Trump.
uncertain
she → warn → Trump
The warning came in a letter from Aaron Reitz, the U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, who accused Warren, the likely incoming chair of the Senate Banking Committee, of appearing "eager to wield your future gavel like a tomahawk, hunting for the scalps of President Trump's private associates."
The letter, shared by Reitz on social media Sunday and later reposted by Trump on Truth Social, is the latest warning directed at Congressional Democrats over their plans to launch a blitz of investigations into the Trump Administration and its allies, after the party’s sweeping midterm victories gave the party control of the House and Senate.
asserted
victories → come → House
“Democrats cannot use their Congressional investigations powers to punish Americans for exercising their First Amendment rights,” a White House official tells TIME.
asserted
official → use → TIME
Reitz called on Warren to preserve materials related to potential investigations involving Trump's allies, accusing her of seeking to target private individuals associated with the President.
asserted
Reitz → call → President
“I am writing to give you formal notice of your obligation to preserve all documents, communications, and other electronically stored information relevant to your intent to weaponize congressional investigations,” he wrote.
asserted
he → write → investigations
Reitz's letter cited Warren's Nov. 8 interview on CBS News's Face the Nation, in which she discussed investigating corporate leaders who may have broken the law.
uncertain
who → cite → law
Reitz argued that her remarks "sends a strong smoke signal" that she intends to target individuals close to Trump.
asserted
she → argue → Trump
He also pointed to an op-ed Warren wrote for TIME, after the Democrats' midterm results, in which the Senator argued that delivering accountability was one of the reasons behind the party's sweeping midterm victories.
asserted
delivering → point → victories
“Congress has the power to hold Donald Trump and his cronies accountable for ripping off the American people to make themselves richer.
asserted
themselves → have → people
Big Tech CEOs, Wall Street executives, and giant corporations should prepare to answer tough questions and face meaningful consequences if they have broken the law,” she wrote.
asserted
she → prepare → law
TIME has reached out to Warren's office for comment.
asserted
TIME → reach → comment
What could the DOJ do?
uncertain
DOJ → do → What
Legal experts tell TIME that Congress has broad powers to investigate the executive branch and other matters connected to its legislative responsibilities, authority granted implicitly by the Constitution.
asserted
Congress → tell → Constitution
“It's not explicit in the Constitution, but it's inherent in the legislative branch, and that's what the Supreme Court has stated numerous times,” Dave Rapallo, an associate professor of law at Georgetown Law, tells TIME.
asserted
Rapallo → state → TIME
“Congress has a constitutional power to conduct investigations for valid legislative branch purposes, and those could be to inform legislation prior to making appropriations, to monitor how taxpayer funds are being spent, to root out waste, fraud, [or] abuse.”
uncertain
funds → have → waste
Rapallo explains that these powers can also extend to potential wrongdoing involving private individuals and businesses, provided the investigations serve a legitimate legislative purpose.
asserted
investigations → explain → purpose
For example, if donors are contributing millions of dollars to the upgrade of a U.S. facility like the White House, Congress has the right and authority to oversee those donations,” he says.
asserted
he → contribute → donations
“If there are allegations that there is some sort of pay-to-play scheme or other type of abuse, Congress has authority to run down those allegations.”
asserted
Congress → be → allegations
Experts explain that the warning sent to Warren is a document preservation letter, a notice requesting that potentially relevant records and communications be retained.
asserted
records → explain → Warren
Such letters can precede legal proceedings or investigations, but the notice itself does not amount to a criminal charge or a court order halting Congressional oversight.
asserted
notice → precede → oversight
“They're not unusual if a criminal investigation has been authorized, whether it's by the Justice Department or another law enforcement agency,” says Rapallo, adding that normally such a request might be followed by a subpoena.
uncertain
request → authorize → subpoena
In Warren's case, however, “there has been no explanation of any criminal wrongdoing, and so it's unclear what the basis is to send a document preservation letter.”
uncertain
basis → send → letter
Although Reitz cited federal criminal civil-rights statutes in his letter, alleging that congressional investigations could be used to violate the rights of people associated with Trump, he did not identify specific criminal conduct by Warren or announce any charges against her.
Jenny Carroll, a professor of law at Texas A&M University, says the letter appears to be more of a warning about a potential investigation than evidence of an established criminal case.
uncertain
letter → cite → case
She describes the DOJ as “investigating that possibility, and asking to preserve any of the evidence that would allow [them] to make a determination of whether or not [Warren] violated the laws of the United States.”
asserted
Warren → describe → States
While Reitz invokes federal criminal civil-rights statutes, Carroll argues that “none of that is stated with any specificity.”
asserted
none → invoke → specificity
“What are the elements of these U.S. code sections that you actually think are violated?
asserted
you → think → sections
What facts support your claim that this violation has occurred, and what exactly are the sanctions or the penalties?
uncertain
sanctions → support → claim
There's no criminal charge against the Senator at this point,” she says.
asserted
she → be → point
Rapallo similarly says that although the DOJ appears to “suggest that there could be criminal exposure,” the letter does not make clear what conduct would constitute a crime.
uncertain
constitute → say → crime
Experts also point to the Constitutional protections available to lawmakers conducting legitimate Congressional investigations.
asserted
Experts → point → investigations
The Constitution's Speech or Debate Clause protects members of Congress from being questioned "in any other place" for legislative acts undertaken as part of their official duties.
asserted
Clause → protect → duties
“The letter blurs two separate questions: whether a congressional investigative act serves a valid legislative purpose, which courts resolve if and when a recipient refuses to comply, and that, at most, ends with the subpoena going unenforced, and whether the inquiry itself constitutes a crime,” Molly Nixon, a senior fellow in Executive Power at the Cato Institute, tells TIME.
asserted
Nixon → blur → TIME
“The criminal statutes the letter cites require proving a specific intent to deprive someone of a federal right, but the Constitution’s Speech or Debate clause bars prosecutors from probing the motivations underlying a legislative act," she says.
asserted
she → cite → act
Against that legal backdrop, some experts argue that the warning may be intended to discourage Warren from pursuing investigations once Democrats regain control of Congress.
uncertain
Democrats → argue → Congress
“It does feel like it's an effort to chill or to discourage her activity,” says Carroll, adding that Warren has so far largely discussed her plans publicly rather than taken actions that would constitute grounds for a criminal investigation.
asserted
that → feel → investigation
Carroll says there isn't “any activity that would really warrant any sort of investigation, so it feels like it's designed to make her stop.”
asserted
her → say → investigation
Other Democrats face similar DOJ warnings
Warren is not the only congressional Democrat to face warnings from the Trump Administration over plans to investigate the President and his allies.
asserted
Warren → face → President
Last week, Trump ordered the DOJ to look into Democratic lawmakers whom he accused of "threatening" people, while Attorney General Todd Blanche subsequently indicated that his department was prepared to challenge congressional Democrats over their use of oversight powers.
asserted
department → order → powers
“What we are going to do to defend the Administration, defend President Trump, and defend anybody who works in the Executive is make sure that Congress stays within their very specific, very narrow world that they're allowed to operate, which is to do oversight,” Blanche said in an interview with Fox News on Sunday.
asserted
Blanche → go → Sunday
Reitz has also issued similar warnings to other Democratic lawmakers who are preparing to take on influential Congressional oversight roles.
asserted
who → issue → roles
…and 13 more, not listed.