Warning: This article contains graphic images that may be disturbing.
uncertain
that → contain → images
Across the political spectrum, a large chunk of Americans believe, despite a lack of evidence, that
did not die by suicide.
asserted
chunk → believe → suicide
Now one forensics expert, working with photos and files provided by Epstein's brother, is weighing in to contend that this suspicion might be right.
uncertain
suspicion → work → brother
Dr.
, who is editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine, spent months reviewing never-before-published autopsy records provided to him and CBS News by Epstein's brother.
asserted
who → spend → brother
The 2019 ruling by the the New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner was that Epstein died by suicide.
asserted
Epstein → die → suicide
But Freeman has concluded that Epstein's death was more likely a homicide.
asserted
death → conclude → ?
Freeman — who worked with Anders Eriksson, a professor of forensic medicine at Umea University in Sweden, and Itiel Dror, a researcher specializing in identifying bias in forensic decision making — presented their findings Monday in London.
asserted
who → work → London
Freeman said he believes that in August 2019 the world's most notorious sex abuser was likely attacked and killed by another person.
asserted
abuser → say → person
"The injuries that were documented by the medical examiner were not consistent with the suicidal hanging.
asserted
that → document → hanging
And the injuries that were attributed to something other than potentially a physical struggle or assault were just overlooked," Freeman told CBS News, based on his review of the autopsy records, photos and a biomedical reconstruction he produced.
asserted
he → attribute → records
The report is the second by an outside forensic expert to question the official findings of suicide.
asserted
report → question → suicide
In 2020, Epstein's brother hired forensic pathologist Dr. Michael Baden to look into the death,
asserted
brother → hire → death
At the time, Baden said injuries to Epstein's neck raised doubts about the official ruling.
asserted
injuries → say → ruling
He the evidence he saw pointed more to murder than suicide.
asserted
he → see → suicide
Freeman's report was rejected for publication from an academic journal, he acknowledged.
asserted
he → reject → journal
He said reviewers for the journal thought it wasn't appropriate to criticize a medical examiner's findings in a peer-reviewed publication.
asserted
it → say → publication
Freeman plans to resubmit, he said.
asserted
he → plan → ?
Freeman, a professor of forensic medicine, said he was struck by the first image he examined, depicting the right side of Epstein's upper body and face, with ligature wounds visible on his neck.
asserted
he → say → neck
"When I saw this photograph, my first reaction was that that is a very unusual looking injury for a hanging on the neck," Freeman said.
asserted
Freeman → see → neck
Freeman has testified as a forensic expert in high-profile court cases and was a member of the Maryland Attorney General's audit team that reviewed dozens of in-custody deaths last year.
asserted
that → testify → deaths
Credible experts often interpret the same evidence very differently.
asserted
experts → interpret → evidence
And Epstein's death investigation was marked by added uncertainty because of a cascade of in the hours, days and weeks after his body was discovered in his Manhattan federal .
asserted
body → mark → federal
The New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner — which conducted the autopsy on Aug. 11, 2019, the day after Epstein was found dead — declined an interview request, and did not reply directly to Freeman's findings when pressed by CBS News.
asserted
Epstein → conduct → News
"Our office stands by its determination," a spokesperson for the medical examiner said.
asserted
spokesperson → stand → examiner
In June, The New York Times conducted an investigation that it said relied on tens of thousands of pages of newly released documents, as well as handwritten in jail.
asserted
it → conduct → jail
That report said there were indications Epstein was his own life.
asserted
Epstein → say → ?
And the newspaper reported that, of the forensics experts they interviewed, "almost none of them believed that his manner of death — suicide or homicide — could be conclusively settled based on the medical evidence alone.
uncertain
manner → report → evidence
"
"That's not what suicidal hangings do"
Freeman believes the official investigation missed key details.
asserted
investigation → do → details
"The injury pattern was described as a sloped or as a peaked injury that was a perfect description for a hanging.
asserted
that → describe → hanging
But that's not what we saw when we saw the photos," Freeman said.
asserted
Freeman → see → photos
While one mark fit that description, he noticed a second mark in the ligature wounds on Epstein's neck, beneath and angled differently than the mark above it.
asserted
he → fit → it
"There is no mechanism to produce a second mark that would be lower.
asserted
that → be → mark
Even if the ligature was tied with two loops, both loops would go up to the point where it was tied because that's the anchor point," Freeman said.
asserted
Freeman → tie → point
Asked if the two markings, present on each side of Epstein's neck, could have been indicative of him stopping and starting — trying twice to kill himself — Freeman said available research into suicidal hanging indicates that's unlikely.
uncertain
that → ask → hanging
Epstein would have had to make "a false start that was strong enough to break his hyoid bone and thyroid cartilage and give him a deep abrasion and then maintain consciousness," Freeman said.
asserted
Freeman → have → consciousness
It's an explanation that doesn't make sense, he said.
asserted
he → make → sense
"That's not what suicidal hangings do," Freeman said.
asserted
Freeman → do → what
"The body becomes unconscious and then it is the weight of the body that produces the abrasion, not any kind of running jump at it.
asserted
that → become → it
That's not a realistic scenario for any hanging described in any of the literature throughout the world.
asserted
That → describe → world
None of the prison guards on duty when Epstein died spoke to medical examiner investigators, according to Justice Department records.
uncertain
Epstein → die → records
…and 46 more, not listed.