An equipment upgrade appears to have brought airline departures across the U.S. to a standstill Friday, raising questions about how the nation’s air traffic control network is being modernized — and whether safeguards should have prevented the disruption.
asserted
safeguards → appear → disruption
The nationwide ground stop — the longest since the September 11 attacks — led to 14,000 flights cancellations Friday and Saturday as the disruption and its aftermath spread through airline schedules.
asserted
disruption → lead → schedules
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy initially blamed an “incredibly old air traffic control system,” saying communications equipment became “overloaded with data” and “went down.”
asserted
equipment → blame → data
By Saturday, he pointed more specifically to routine work replacing copper telecommunications wiring with fiber.
asserted
he → point → fiber
Aviation experts said precautions should have prevented an equipment change from overwhelming the network, leading to scrutiny over installation procedures and preparations for recovering when an upgrade goes wrong.
asserted
upgrade → say → procedures
The disruption has also intensified a funding debate, with Duffy seeking another $50 billion after Congress approved $12.5 billion last year.
asserted
Congress → intensify → billion
But experts caution that new equipment alone cannot eliminate failures in a sprawling system that must remain operational throughout its overhaul.
asserted
that → caution → overhaul
“A large-scale modernization, no matter how warranted and well-intended, cannot solve all these problems.
asserted
modernization → intend → problems
This is a system that runs 24/7, 365 days a year.
asserted
that → run → days
We cannot turn it off while we build a new one and then start a new one from scratch,” David Lovell, a professor of civil and environmental engineering at the University of Maryland, told The Independent.
asserted
Lovell → turn → Independent
“Any modernization will, by necessity, be done piecemeal.
asserted
modernization → do → necessity
That will mean integrating new subsystems with old subsystems, with the consequent interfaces at the boundaries that are often points of vulnerability,” he added.
asserted
he → mean → vulnerability
What happened?
asserted
What → happen → ?
Air traffic controllers began seeing inconsistencies in radar data and aircraft communications at 3:36 p.m. Friday, Duffy said.
asserted
Duffy → begin → 3:36
Eighteen minutes later, the FAA ordered a nationwide ground stop, barring departures as officials sought to identify the problem.
asserted
officials → order → problem
The order was lifted at 8:15 p.m., but airlines continued struggling to restore their schedules.
asserted
airlines → lift → schedules
More than 7,000 flights were canceled Friday, with thousands more canceled or delayed Saturday, leaving thousands of passengers stranded at airports across the U.S.
Duffy said Saturday that contractor L3Harris may have installed a faulty router — a device that directs information through a network — at a site in Arkansas.
uncertain
that → cancel → Arkansas
The work involved replacing copper wires, which carry electrical signals, with fiber optic cables, which can transmit more data over longer distances.
asserted
which → involve → distances
L3Harris has partnered with the federal government for a decade and is replacing the Federal Aviation Administration’s copper wires with fiber-optic cables.
asserted
L3Harris → partner → cables
FAA and company officials are working in L3Harris’ Florida lab to analyze the router at the center of the stop.
asserted
officials → work → stop
“L3Harris takes the nationwide ground stop and its impact on travelers, airlines and air traffic operations seriously,” the company said in a statement.
asserted
company → take → statement
The company’s work comes the nation has long sought to upgrade its decade-old air traffic control system.
asserted
nation → come → system
Edward Booth, an aviation attorney and pilot based in Jacksonville, Florida, told Time Magazine that billions of dollars have already been sunk into the process.
asserted
billions → base → process
“It's a very highly technical, robust system,” Booth says of the National Airspace System (NAS), “but it seems the weak spot was discovered yesterday afternoon.”
asserted
spot → say → System
An overload can affect facilities around the country that exchange radar information and voice communications, said Hassan Shahidi, president and CEO of the Flight Safety Foundation.
asserted
Shahidi → affect → Foundation
“It appears to have been a system overload caused by this new router,” he told The Independent.
asserted
he → appear → Independent
Lance Sherry, a professor of systems engineering at George Mason University, said air traffic control comprises three interacting networks: communications, navigation and surveillance.
asserted
control → say → networks
Their connections help explain how a local problem can spread to a nationwide shutdown.
asserted
problem → help → shutdown
“For this reason we consider [air traffic control] to be a network-of-networks,” Sherry said.
asserted
Sherry → consider → networks
“A perturbation in one location of the network can, under the right circumstances, propagate through the network.”
asserted
perturbation → propagate → network
Independent industry analyst Bob Mann noted that the FAA had recently expanded its SMART traffic-management platform nationwide.
asserted
FAA → note → platform
The AI-assisted tool, which helps FAA staff plan traffic flows, was rolled out nationally three days before the ground stop.
asserted
staff → assist → stop
Federal officials, however, have said this new tool was not responsible for the outage.
asserted
tool → say → outage
Lovell said the disruption should not obscure the safety response.
asserted
disruption → say → response
“The safety aspects of the system performed admirably,” he told The Independent.
asserted
he → perform → Independent
“The procedures to get aircraft out of the air safely worked perfectly, and there was no loss of life or bodily injury.
asserted
procedures → get → life
The FAA and its telecommunications provider should have safeguards to prevent an equipment change from overwhelming the network, Shahidi said.
asserted
Shahidi → have → network
Preliminary findings pointed to a router setting that apparently allowed it to send excessive information.
asserted
it → point → information
“This particular router has a feature that has a broader broadcast capability.
asserted
that → have → capability
That feature apparently was not disabled,” he said.
asserted
he → disable → ?
…and 18 more, not listed.