A change to the current age of consent of 16 will be considered in the wake of the Russell Brand case if ‘evidence-based proposals’ are brought forward, Scotland’s Justice Secretary has said.
asserted
Secretary → consider → case
Neil Gray said that, while there are no current plans to change the law, he is willing to give thought to any further steps following the conviction of the comedian.
asserted
he → say → comedian
At the weekend, Mia Latter, who alleges she was raped by Brand when she was 16, waived her right to anonymity to campaign for a staggered age of consent.
asserted
she → allege → consent
Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden pledged that the change will be considered by the UK Government but the issue is devolved to Holyrood and it would be up to the Scottish Government to decide whether to act.
asserted
it → pledge → Government
SNP ministers previously opted against changing the legal age of consent to sexual activity when they published a consultation last year to raise the legal age for getting married from 16 to 18.
asserted
they → opt → 18
Mr Gray yesterday told BBC Radio Scotland Breakfast: ‘In terms of the general policy principles, we will of course consider carefully any evidence-based proposals intended to strengthen protections for young people.
asserted
we → tell → people
Mia Latter alleges she was raped by Russell Brand, pictured, when she was 16
Justice Secretary Neil Gray said that he is willing to give thought to change to the current age of consent following the conviction of Brand
‘
asserted
he → allege → Brand
The age of consent in Scotland is 16, there are no current plans to change that general position, though I recognise that that high-profile case and others do require thought on what steps we could consider.’
uncertain
we → be → steps
The Justice Secretary said it is “complex issue” and the law does already criminalise certain sexual activity involving 16 and 17-year-olds where there are ‘unsafe power dynamics’, and went on: ‘It is already an offence under the Sexual Offences (Scotland) Act for anyone aged 18 or over to engage in sexual activity with someone aged 16 or 17 if the older person is in a position of trust.
asserted
person → say → trust
‘But this is something that we would consider any evidence-based proposals around to ensure that we could provide protections for young people.’
uncertain
we → consider → people
He said for any changes there would need to be evidence to show they provided safety and that there is still clarity in the law, and added: ‘At the moment the law is clear, we’ve got very clear rules against anyone in a position of trust engaging in sexual activity with a 16 or 17-year-old and abusing that position.
asserted
we → say → position
‘Where there is a staggered position, we would need to consider carefully whether that would provide additional complexity to the law that could provide confusion.
uncertain
that → be → confusion
‘But these are areas that, of course, we would consider given what has come forward here and the very clear interest that there is in ensuring that we are providing safety to young women and girls.’
asserted
we → consider → women
Scottish Liberal Democrat justice spokesman Yi-pei Chou Turvey said: ‘If we’re serious about treating violence against women and girls as an emergency, we have to directly address the power imbalance between older men and teenage girls.
asserted
we → say → men
‘The sickening scandals that keep emerging demand that government find ways to help protect teenagers from those who take advantage of their vulnerability.
asserted
who → emerge → vulnerability
‘Examining the possibility of a staggered age of consent is an important step toward finally tackling this sort of abuse.’
asserted
Examining → examine → abuse
First Minister John Swinney has previously promised ‘personal leadership’ to protect women and girls from violence.
asserted
Swinney → promise → violence
Meghan Gallacher, equalities spokesman for the Scottish Conservatives, said: ‘Too many young people have been horrifically abused by those in positions of power for too long and then found it impossible to get justice.
asserted
it → say → justice
It shouldn’t take high-profile scandals for discussions like these to begin.
asserted
discussions → take → these
‘While arguments around any changes to the law of consent would have to be carefully considered, they cannot be the only discussion that is now had.
asserted
that → have → consent
‘In SNP-run Scotland, we have seen a spate of violence against young women and girls by dangerous offenders who were often known to them, and who know they will not be properly punished.
asserted
they → run → them
‘John Swinney must back up his warm words on this subject that not only educates people, but also properly punishes those responsible and puts victims needs first.’
asserted
Swinney → back → needs