In 1945, with Nazi Germany in its death throes, the leaders of the world’s three most powerful nations gathered in the seaside resort of Yalta.
asserted
leaders → gather → Yalta
There, on the Black Sea’s pebbled shore, the Soviet Union, Great Britain, and the U.S. held negotiations that would eventually split the planet into competing spheres of influence.
asserted
that → hold → influence
Little wonder Kremlin propagandists are clamoring to portray the proposed meeting between Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping, and Donald Trump on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Shenzhen on Thursday as Yalta 2.0.
asserted
propagandists → clamor → Yalta
At first blush, there are parallels: Putin is a more than adequate stand-in for Joseph Stalin, while the fact the original summit took place in Soviet-administered Crimea carries obvious symbolism for Ukrainian sovereignty.
asserted
summit → be → sovereignty
Yet the comparison falters well before we get into the knotty territory of substituting Trump for Franklin D. Roosevelt and Xi Jinping for Winston Churchill (a resurgent China having long ago relegated Britain to middle power status).
asserted
China → falter → status
While the original Yalta brought two democracies together with a totalitarian ally, a Shenzhen confab would seat two entrenched autocrats alongside an American President increasingly willing to challenge diplomatic conventions.
asserted
confab → bring → conventions
And while Putin may want a soapbox for his revanchist designs, today’s middle powers have vastly greater capability and agency, as the resistance mounted by war-ravaged Ukraine and Iran underscores.
uncertain
resistance → want → Ukraine
Confirming the meeting on Monday, China's Foreign Ministry hailed its "groundbreaking significance" with the leaders set to “exchange views in depth on safeguarding world peace and promoting strategic stability in major-power relations.”
asserted
leaders → confirm → relations
For Putin, the benefits of pushing for a historic trilateral are clear.
asserted
benefits → push → trilateral
At best, he could negotiate favorable terms for an exit from his Ukrainian quagmire.
uncertain
he → negotiate → quagmire
At worst, he flaunts himself on a level pegging with the world’s undisputed superpowers and takes a tentative step out of Western diplomatic isolation.
asserted
he → flaunt → isolation
For Trump, it’s an opportunity for demonstrate his influence on the world stage following chastening midterms and mounting troubles: a floundering Iran war, calls for the impeachment of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, and the unfolding Nvidia scandal that forced the resignation of his close ally Jensen Huang as CEO.
asserted
that → ’ → CEO
“[Trump’s] trying to dig himself out of this political hole,” says Susan Shirk, a professor at UC San Diego and former U.S. deputy assistant secretary of state.
asserted
Shirk → try → state
At a more elemental level, “this sort of stuff appeals to Trump’s basic instincts about how statecraft is done,” says Nick Bisley, a professor of international relations at Australia’s La Trobe University.
asserted
Bisley → appeal → University
“The ‘great men’ get in a room and sort things out.”
asserted
men → get → things
Still, the agenda remains sketchy.
asserted
agenda → remain → ?
Despite Putin’s original rationale regarding peace talks, Trump said on Oct. 19 that the meeting would be “not so much for Ukraine.”
asserted
meeting → regard → Ukraine
Instead, he said he wanted to focus on denuclearization, though China objects to being lumped into talks when its own nuclear arsenal remains much smaller than the others’.
asserted
arsenal → say → others
“It is neither fair, reasonable, nor realistic to ask China to join the so-called trilateral nuclear disarmament negotiations,” a Foreign Ministry spokesperson said Oct. 16.
asserted
spokesperson → ask → negotiations
Of course, cultivating a reputation as a nuclear arms control crusader would be politically expedient for Trump, given his specious justification for attacking Tehran was to prevent it developing atomic weapons.
asserted
it → cultivate → weapons
On Nov. 8, Trump told reporters that trilateral topics would include “trying to end the war in Iran,” though China’s Foreign Ministry declined to confirm that intent.
asserted
Ministry → tell → intent
Instead, the focus has since reportedly shifted toward limiting the use of AI in nuclear command-and-control systems, despite this already having been agreed by Joe Biden and Xi in 2024.
uncertain
this → shift → 2024
Refocusing on AI “looks like a potential diplomatic face-saving exercise,” says Bisley.
asserted
Bisley → refocus → exercise
Still, getting Putin to agree to keep AI out of nuclear launch protocols would be “significant,” says Shirk.
asserted
Shirk → get → protocols
The leaders could also jointly reaffirm that “a nuclear war cannot be won and must never be fought”—a position all three nations have previously endorsed.
uncertain
nations → reaffirm → ?
That would be low-hanging fruit albeit with fresh significance in light of Putin’s recent threats against Ukraine.
asserted
That → hang → Ukraine
“Getting Putin to go along with that statement would be a positive development from the standpoint of peace-loving people everywhere and Americans in particular,” says Shirk.
asserted
Shirk → get → people
But it’s Xi’s position that is most intriguing.
asserted
that → ’ → ?
His top prize would be American concessions on the status of Taiwan, though nobody has publicly broached the self-ruling island as a topic.
asserted
nobody → broach → topic
A trilateral would also be a curious forum given Russia isn’t a stakeholder of consequence.
asserted
Russia → give → consequence
Xi likely sees value domestically in China sharing top billing given he seeks a historic fourth leadership term at next year’s Communist Party Congress.
asserted
he → see → Congress
“Xi wants to demonstrate that he's a great statesman and brought China up to an equal level with the other Great Powers,” says Shirk.
asserted
Shirk → want → Powers
China is also preparing for blowback in the Nvidia scandal, which erupted after Huang admitted to an affair with a woman accused of illicitly funneling semiconductors to China and whom U.S. intelligence reportedly suspects is a Chinese spy.
uncertain
intelligence → prepare → China
China denies the espionage allegation.
asserted
China → deny → allegation
Huang has agreed to testify before Congress about the allegations, which have galvanized bipartisan support for tougher export controls on bleeding-edge chips bound for China, and perhaps also new restrictions on Chinese firms’ access to Nvidia-powered overseas data centers.
asserted
which → agree → centers
By handing Trump a historic photo op that undercuts perceptions of his lame-duck status, Xi could help ease domestic political pressure, potentially buying Beijing some breathing room.
uncertain
Xi → hand → room
Yet Beijing has arguably the least to gain and most to lose from a trilateral.
asserted
Beijing → have → trilateral
Despite Trump’s efforts to play down discussions of Ukraine, it would be surprising if the war didn’t crop up, given Putin’s presence and the fact that talks between U.S., Russian, and Ukrainian officials in Abu Dhabi concluded on Nov. 11 with further negotiations mooted.
asserted
negotiations → play → Nov.
“Of course they will talk about Ukraine,” says Alexander Korolev, an expert in China-Russia relations at the University of New South Wales.
asserted
Korolev → talk → Wales
Shirk is less sure, noting how the agenda for such tightly scheduled, high-level meetings is “worked out ahead of time” and “pretty highly scripted.”
asserted
agenda → note → time
…and 18 more, not listed.