David Jones’ fate rests on two tests: who can martial the highest number of creditors, and the largest dollar value of debts, to support their bid for what remains of the chain.
asserted
what → rest → chain
On Tuesday, it became clear who will be the kingmaker, if not the king, under the rules that govern votes on the future of failed companies.
asserted
that → become → companies
Outside of disparate gift card holders, figures revealed by the administrators running the sale process for David Jones on Tuesday suggest most creditors will be staff.
asserted
creditors → reveal → Tuesday
They are largely not unionised, and difficult to organise.
asserted
They → organise → ?
But distressed business lender Hilco and David Jones’ former owner Anchorage Capital speak for about half the money the retailer owes.
asserted
retailer → speak → money
That gives the pair the whip hand.
asserted
That → give → hand
It could result in Anchorage having a second go at running the department stores it put into administration just weeks ago – potentially with Hilco remaining a major lender.
uncertain
Hilco → result → administration
To Australians with a nostalgic affinity for David Jones, that would be a remarkable trajectory: Anchorage declares it cannot keep David Jones going, at least 19 stores shut, likely thousands of staff lose their jobs, and then the same company continues to have a role in the chain.
Already, administrators at McGrathNicol are putting into motion the plans that Anchorage had drawn up to close sub-par stores before surrendering control.
asserted
Anchorage → declare → control
Of course, unlike Anchorage, the administrators have the legal power to get David Jones out of long-term store leases without eye-watering financial penalties.
asserted
administrators → have → penalties
That was a major reason the chain went under in the first place.
asserted
chain → go → place
Anchorage, which has claimed an $80 million secured debt from David Jones, has already made clear it is interested in being involved in the business again, whether alone or, more likely, with a consortium.
asserted
is → claim → consortium
It has good reason to do so.
asserted
It → have → reason
A slimmer David Jones should be profitable, and could keep Anchorage from losing whatever cash it has put into the business so far.
uncertain
it → keep → business
As this masthead’s CBD column has reported, Anchorage recently engaged former treasurer, turned lobbyist Joe Hockey, and its people met with McGrathNicol personnel multiple times before the business went under.
asserted
business → report → personnel
Hockey will be handy should the fate of David Jones become a public relations storm.
asserted
fate → become → Jones
Hilco, for its part, is so good at getting money out of failing companies that London newspaper the Times once branded it the “vulture getting fat on high street woes”.
asserted
Times → get → woes
Its loans are secured by stock, which its staff are pros at valuing.
asserted
staff → secure → stock
But should an offer come along that would keep David Jones operating and borrowing from Hilco, that would be far more attractive than presiding over a Boxing Day sale to end all sales.
asserted
that → come → sales
None of that is to say David Jones’ future is certain.
asserted
future → say → that
McGrathNicol’s administrators will act in all creditors’ interests, as is their legal duty.
asserted
duty → act → interests
That can yield unpredictable results.
asserted
That → yield → results
In 2017, media moguls Lachlan Murdoch and Bruce Gordon (now a major shareholder in Nine, the owner of this masthead) refused to guarantee more money to Network Ten, effectively forcing the television station into administration.
asserted
moguls → refuse → administration
The men hoped to take control of the media company after that, but were thwarted by the station’s largest creditor, US broadcaster CBS, which bought it from under them.
asserted
which → hop → them
Anchorage’s debt claim too is coming under scrutiny.
uncertain
claim → come → scrutiny
The administrators told creditors on Monday that they were investigating whether “Anchorage’s security or priority position was enhanced and whether the changes affected assets potentially available to unsecured creditors” as part of a financial restructuring before the administration.
asserted
changes → tell → administration
No shortage of big names in retail are being floated publicly as potential buyers of David Jones, but many will just turn out to be having a stickybeak.
asserted
many → float → stickybeak
David Jones’ upmarket clientele would seem a poor fit next to Larry Kestleman’s stable of thoroughly mid- to downmarket brands such as Volley tennis shoes, or Brett Blundy’s ultra-cheap chains like Lovisa jewellery.
asserted
clientele → seem → jewellery
Neither man has commented.
asserted
man → comment → ?
Still, someone could come out of the woodwork.
uncertain
someone → come → woodwork
The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion.
asserted
newsletter → deliver → stories