A mother is now free from a six-year legal battle over the death of her baby girl after she was accused of pushing her face down into a mattress and killing her.
asserted
she → accuse → her
Former Coast Guard petty officer Katie Richard, 30, was the primary suspect in the tragic death of her five-month-old daughter, Scarlett, after the infant was found dead in her crib in April 2020.
asserted
infant → find → April
Prosecutors alleged during the non-commissioned officer's initial trial that she had suffocated the baby by pushing her face into the crib's mattress.
asserted
she → allege → mattress
Her defense lawyers, meanwhile, contend that Scarlett may have succumbed to sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).
uncertain
Scarlett → contend → syndrome
After two trials, two years in a military prison and an acquittal earlier this year, Richard, who was stationed in Alaska's Kodiak, is now free.
asserted
who → station → Kodiak
She told The Washington Post that she found her infant child dead in her crib after going out to buy coffee while her then-husband Gustavo 'Gus' Flores Guerra remained at home.
asserted
Guerra → tell → home
She said: 'My heart dropped.
asserted
heart → say → ?
I couldn’t move, I couldn’t speak.
asserted
I → move → ?
I was just looking at her, and then I started getting closer, and I was just screaming: "Why does she look like that?
asserted
she → look → that
Why does she look like that?"
asserted
she → look → that
Richard said she and her husband raced to the nearest emergency room, but that by the time they got there Scarlett was already blue and there was nothing medical staff could do.
uncertain
staff → say → time
She said: '[There was] this primal pain that I’ve never felt in my entire life.
asserted
I → say → life
It literally feels like a piece of my heart was ripped out of my chest and thrown away.'
asserted
piece → feel → chest
Katie Richard, 30, was the primary suspect in the tragic death of her five-month-old daughter, Scarlett
Scarlett died in April 2020 with no warning.
asserted
Scarlett → die → warning
Her parents rushed her to a nearby hospital, but medical staff were unable to save her
asserted
staff → rush → her
In the weeks and months that followed Scarlett's death, military investigators began looking into the case and spoke to the mother for what she said was up to 18 hours.
asserted
she → follow → mother
The questioning culminated in an hour-long interrogation two months after Scarlett's death.
asserted
questioning → culminate → death
According to Richard, she told investigators she 'might have' pushed her baby's face into the mattress as she put her down to sleep.
uncertain
she → accord → sleep
This recording was then played during her initial trial, which resulted in her incarceration.
asserted
which → play → incarceration
Following her 2022 sentencing, she was taken to the Navy brig in Chesapeake, Virginia.
asserted
she → follow → Chesapeake
She spent her first month in a cell on her own, inconsolable and eating and drinking very little.
asserted
She → spend → little
She was later relocated to a Navy brig in Miramar, California, where she began trying to live something of a normal life behind bars by volunteering and taking Bible studies.
But she was deeply upset by the idea that others in the prison saw her as guilty of killing her own child: 'It literally felt like a loss of my own identity because I knew the truth.
asserted
I → relocate → truth
I knew myself.
asserted
I → know → myself
I knew I didn’t do that, but everybody around me, 24/7, was looking at me like I did.'
During the first trial, Richard's defense lawyers accused the military of failing to keep track of Scarlett's clothes and bib which could have provided evidence that she died by SIDS.
uncertain
she → know → SIDS
The Washington Post reported that a medical analysis from the hospital she died in also suggested SIDS, with a doctor writing: 'I have no suspicion of abuse.
uncertain
I → report → abuse
Mother and father were understandably devastated.'
asserted
Mother → devastate → ?
In 2024, two years after she began her six-year sentence, a military appeals court threw out her conviction.
asserted
court → begin → conviction
The appeals court found the manslaughter charge, added on top of charges of first-degree murder and obstruction of justice, was not justifiable.
asserted
charge → find → justice
It claimed that Richard committed manslaughter by asphyxia but did not specify what she had allegedly done physically.
uncertain
she → claim → what
Two months after the appellate decision in 2024, Richard was released from prison and worked to secure back pay for her time in prison, as well as avoid another trial.
But these efforts failed, and in 2025 the Coast Guard charged her again on one count of involuntary manslaughter.
asserted
Guard → release → manslaughter
She appealed, claiming the new charge was a violation of the double jeopardy clause of the Constitution's Fifth Amendment.
asserted
charge → appeal → Amendment
The court, however, denied her petition and said her constitutional claim was without merit.
So her second trial, held at Coast Guard Base Portsmouth, in Virginia, went ahead and lasted two months.
uncertain
trial → deny → Virginia
In April, the former Coast Guard petty officer was found not guilty of manslaughter.
asserted
officer → find → manslaughter
And in September, she was given $168,000, minus taxes, in back pay for her time spent in prison.
asserted
she → give → prison
Now divorced from her former husband and living in Hawaii, Richard wants to forget about the ordeal she went through.
asserted
she → divorce → ordeal
She was accepted to a master's degree program in public administration.
asserted
She → accept → administration
She is also using her experience in the Coast Guard in a new job as a crew member and safety diver on a tour boat.
asserted
She → use → boat
Still to this day, she suffers recurring nightmares about driving her child to the hospital, or being in prison.
asserted
she → suffer → prison
'I’ve been dealing with this for six years, just about half of my entire time in the Coast Guard.
asserted
I → deal → Guard
So it’s been very long, very unnecessary, and now I’m trying to finally catch up — to be able to grieve properly now.
asserted
I → try → ?
…and 11 more, not listed.