A Florida man allegedly sent a peanut butter-slathered envelope to an unsuspecting allergic woman that triggered a near-deadly medical emergency and caused her anguish for hours.
uncertain
that → send → hours
Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, was arrested on November 13 in Plantation, about 30 miles north of Miami, after allegedly sending a woman with a 'severe' allergy a card that was 'smeared' with peanut butter.
uncertain
that → arrest → butter
A probable cause affidavit filed on November 13 in Broward County viewed by the Daily Mail said that the woman returned home from work on August 14, 2025, and noticed a blue envelope 'that appeared greasy with handwriting she did not recognize' after emptying her mail box.
asserted
she → file → box
The mysterious envelope was addressed to the woman, whose name was redacted throughout the affidavit, from an address in Springs, the filing said.
asserted
filing → address → Springs
When she opened the envelope, she allegedly discovered peanut butter 'spread across the inside of the card.
uncertain
she → open → card
She immediately identified what it was, dropped the envelope and frantically ran inside to wash her hands, per the filing.
asserted
it → identify → filing
The woman allegedly broke out in hives on both arms and had a tingling sensation in both limbs that lasted for six hours, per the affidavit.
uncertain
that → break → affidavit
Cancellare 'knew' that peanut butter 'could be deadly' to the victim, according to the legal filing.
uncertain
butter → know → filing
He has been charged with aggravated battery and culpable negligence.
asserted
He → charge → battery
Joseph Gerard Cancellare, 68, was arrested on November 13 and charged with aggravated battery and culpable negligence
A probable cause affidavit filed on November 13 viewed by the Daily Mail said
asserted
affidavit → arrest → Mail
Cancellare bought two 'Forever' stamps placed on the envelope at the Davie Post Office (pictured)
asserted
Cancellare → buy → pictured
The affidavit said the victim's allergy was 'severe and widely known amongst her friends and family.'
asserted
allergy → say → friends
She contacted Plantation authorities the same day, and the police department contacted a United States postal inspector since Cancellare allegedly used the US Postal Service to send the card.
uncertain
Cancellare → contact → card
Cancellare was allegedly identified after authorities determined that two 'Forever' stamps on the upper right hand corner of the envelope had been purchased at a United States Postal Service (USPS) self-service kiosk at the Davie Post Office, which took a photograph of him as the purchase was made.
uncertain
purchase → identify → him
The VISA card used to buy the stamps was also confirmed to belong to Cancellare, according to the affidavit.
uncertain
card → use → affidavit
Investigators met with a woman who said she knows Cancellare and the victim personally, the affidavit said.
asserted
affidavit → meet → Cancellare
Though chunks of the legal document were redacted across its seven pages, the woman indicated that Cancellare was 'contentious' about a divorce, per the affidavit.
asserted
Cancellare → redact → affidavit
The woman told authorities that Cancellare 'would absolutely know' about the victim's allergy 'as the couples went to dinner countless times.
asserted
couples → tell → dinner
'
The victim 'had to be mindful of accidentally coming into contact with peanuts,' the woman told investigators, per the affidavit.
asserted
woman → have → affidavit
Cancellare allegedly used the US Postal Service to send out the peanut butter-smothered envelope (File photo of USPS vehicles)
uncertain
Cancellare → use → vehicles
The victim allegedly told investigators that she could not come into contact with peanuts or 'she could die' without medical intervention (File photo of peanut butter being spread)
On September 15 of this year, the victim allegedly told police about 'how careful she had to be about being exposed to peanuts.
uncertain
she → tell → peanuts
She allegedly explained that she could not come into contact with peanuts, peanut oil or cross-contaminated items, the document added.
uncertain
document → explain → peanuts
She said her allergic reaction was so severe that 'without immediate medical intervention she could die,' per the affidavit.
uncertain
she → say → affidavit
The envelope experience allegedly caused her 'extreme distress that was still visible when she provided the statement over a year later' and told authorities that she wished to press charges.
uncertain
she → cause → charges
The affidavit added that Cancellare exposed 'countless other people to peanut butter,' noting that approximately 22 million Americans have food allergies in the US, according to the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America.
uncertain
Americans → add → America
Cancellare's bond was set at $20,000 total, or $10,000 for each charge, after his arrest in the 1000 block of NW 86th Avenue.
asserted
bond → set → Avenue
He posted bond on Monday, according to Broward County court records viewed by the Daily Mail.
uncertain
He → post → Mail
A next court date for Cancellare has not been set as of Tuesday afternoon.
asserted
date → set → afternoon
The Daily Mail has reached out to the Plantation Police Department and the USPS for further comment.
asserted
Mail → reach → comment
Broward County court documents viewed by the Daily Mail did not list any attorneys for Cancellare.
asserted
documents → view → Cancellare