Gov. Kathy Hochul vowed Thursday to make more than 2.7 million New York public, parochial and private school students eligible for “freedom scholarships” despite opposition from the powerful teachers union.
asserted
students → vow → union
The Education Freedom Tax Credit approved by Congress and President Trump last year provides a 100% federal tax credit for donations of up to $1,700 annually to approved scholarship-granting organizations.
asserted
Credit → approve → organizations
The nonprofit groups would then offer scholarships, which families from all schools could use to defray tuition costs.
uncertain
families → offer → costs
She also claimed families with incomes up to $500,000 could benefit from the program.
uncertain
families → claim → program
Public school students are also eligible for scholarships to cover tutoring, after-school programs or transportation costs.
asserted
students → cover → school
“Governor Hochul’s priority is making sure every student receives an education that best meets their needs, which is why she wants the federal scholarship tax credit to benefit all New York students,” Hochul spokesman Johan Allon said.
asserted
Allon → make → students
“These credits have the potential to expand academic opportunity for public and private school students across our state without diverting resources from public schools or state and local budgets.
asserted
credits → have → schools
All stakeholders should work together to ensure this program can be implemented to maximize benefits for all New York schools, including our public schools.
asserted
program → work → schools
But leaders of the teachers unions and other public school advocates — including the NAACP and the NYCLU — claimed the program is a back-door privatization scheme aimed at siphoning taxpayers dollars from public schools.
asserted
program → include → schools
“It’s a bad thing for all the children in our state that go to public schools,” said United Federation of Teachers President Mike Mulgrew during a Wednesday press conference at union headquarters in Manhattan.
asserted
Mulgrew → ’ → Manhattan
“It’s a bad thing when we’re going to take taxpayer dollars and give it to folks with no accountabilty.
asserted
we → ’ → accountabilty
Under the law, the governor of each state has to decide whether to opt-in or opt out of the program.
asserted
governor → have → program
Mulgrew then led a chant, “Public Schools Schools Shout, Hochul Opt-Out!”
asserted
Schools → lead → chant
American Federation of Teachers president Randi Weingarten claimed the program is meant to “take money out of public schools.”
asserted
program → claim → schools
But Democrat Hochul, who is seeking re-election to a second term and is backed by the teachers unions, said she disagrees with organized labor on the scholarship program.
asserted
she → seek → program
Hochul said she will opt New York into the program because it benefits all students — public and private.
asserted
it → say → students
She earlier told top advocates for Catholic and Jewish schools that she backed the program.
asserted
she → tell → program
The governor’s office also said the unions are factually incorrect.
asserted
unions → say → ?
The tax credit is funded by private donations and is not a voucher program.
asserted
credit → fund → donations
Taxpayer-funded vouchers can typically only be used toward tuition at non-public schools whereas the federal tax-credit scholarship can be used by eligible students in public schools.
asserted
scholarship → fund → schools
Hochul’s office said the program will not divert public funds away from public schools.
asserted
program → say → schools
It is funded by donations from private individuals, not state or federal funding, so no funds are diverted from public schools.
asserted
funds → fund → schools
Donors to a scholarship granting organization will receive a federal tax credit equal to their contribution, an incentive to give.
asserted
Donors → grant → contribution
The only cost is measured in foregone lost federal tax revenue via the credit, the governor’s office said
asserted
office → measure → credit
Children from low-income families will be eligible for funds to pay for educational support they would not otherwise have access to, Hochul’s office said.
asserted
office → pay → access
Backers of the program said the union opposition shows its members don’t care about kids.
“Teachers unions are supposed to put students first.
asserted
unions → say → students
Today’s press conference is further proof they are not – and that they’re not telling New Yorkers the truth about this program, said Sydney Altfield, CEO of the Teach Coalition representing Jewish and Catholic schools.
asserted
Altfield → tell → schools
“More than two million New York students could benefit without taking a dollar from the state budget.
uncertain
students → benefit → budget
Claims that this would drain public schools are flat-out false — and those repeating them know it.
uncertain
those → drain → it
“Ask any parent: sending a child to school isn’t free.
asserted
sending → ask → school
Supplies, transportation, technology, tutoring and after-school care add up – especially during an affordability crisis,” she added.
asserted
she → add → crisis
“This program could put money back in the pockets of families struggling with those costs.
uncertain
program → put → costs
If the unions get their way, New York won’t just leave federal aid on the table — hardworking families will be left footing the bill yet again.”
asserted
families → get → bill
The Aporia
