In short:
A senate committee has recommended a Defence report into the 2023 Taipan army helicopter crash be reviewed after claims of corruption and fabricated evidence.
uncertain
report → recommend → corruption
The committee heard explosive claims that an independent Defence Flight Safety Bureau (DFSB) report had been corrupted by an "obvious" conflict of interest.
uncertain
report → hear → interest
The senate has also recommended the Department of Defence reconsider eligibility for the Roll of Honour at the Australian War Memorial.
asserted
Department → recommend → Memorial
A senate committee has recommended a Defence report into a 2023 army helicopter crash that killed four men be reviewed, after claims of corruption and fabricated evidence.
uncertain
that → recommend → corruption
The senate probe into the MRH-90 crash, which claimed the lives of Captain Danniel Lyon, Lieutenant Max Nugent, Warrant Officer Class Joseph "Phil" Laycock and Corporal Alexander Naggs, began its inquiry in June.
asserted
which → claim → June
Two public hearings were held, with former test pilots turned whistleblowers and family members of the four fallen men among those who gave evidence.
asserted
who → hold → evidence
It heard explosive claims an independent Defence Flight Safety Bureau (DFSB) report had been corrupted by an "obvious" conflict of interest and contained "manipulated" and "fabricated" evidence.
uncertain
report → hear → evidence
Those claims came from retired MRH-90 test pilots Major Ian Wilson and Major David Lamb, who spoke at the first public hearing.
uncertain
who → come → hearing
Both had previously given evidence at a separate Inspector-General of the Australian Defence Force (IGADF) inquiry, which is yet to hand down its findings, and raised concerns about technology used in the helmets the two pilots were wearing the night they died.
asserted
they → give → helmets
The IGADF inquiry had heard the TopOwl 5.10 software, which displayed readings on night vision goggles, had a tendency to give incorrect readings when pilots turned their heads.
asserted
pilots → hear → heads
Major Wilson said he had flagged issues with the technology with Defence before it was pushed into service, fearing someone would die if it was rolled out.
asserted
it → say → service
Some evidence before the IGADF has suggested it was released despite concerns, as it had already been paid for.
uncertain
it → suggest → concerns
"Was this [crash] the exact incident you feared, because of the problems you saw in testing?" Senator David Shoebridge asked Major Wilson at the first hearing in June.
asserted
Shoebridge → fear → June
"It's almost to the word," he replied.
asserted
he → reply → word
The DFSB investigation into the downing of the MRH-90 found it was unlikely the TopOwl technology contributed to the crash.
asserted
technology → find → crash
But Major Wilson told the senate one of the experts who provided evidence to DFSB investigators, was the same person who signed off on a memo downgrading the risks of the TopOwl technology.
asserted
who → tell → technology
DFSB director Group Captain David Smith was questioned about the alleged conflict of interest at the senate hearing but said any perceived conflict of interest was not the subject of the report.
asserted
conflict → question → report
Independent review recommended
The senate has now released a raft of recommendations following its probe, including that the Australian government independently review the DFSB report "to ensure the investigation and its findings were not improperly influenced and conclusions are sound".
asserted
conclusions → recommend → report
It also recommended the government put the DFSB's independence under a microscope and that it establish a conflict of interest disclosure log.
asserted
it → recommend → log
"The conflict of interest concerns … brought into question the DFSB's conclusions," the senate report said.
asserted
report → bring → conclusions
The senate also called for the Auditor-General to investigate whether Army Aviation was complying with workplace health and safety regulations, particularly around fatigue and safety culture.
asserted
Aviation → call → culture
Fatigue was a key part of the senate and the IGADF's inquiries, which heard evidence the four airmen were so tired, it would have been akin to driving over the legal alcohol limit, and would have impaired their flying capabilities.
asserted
it → hear → capabilities
The ABC has previously reported the workplace safety investigative and compliance body, Comcare, identified two alleged breaches of the law relating to fatigue and the TopOwl technology.
asserted
body → report → fatigue
The Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP) last year declined to lay charges against Defence, deeming there was insufficient evidence and no reasonable possibility of securing a conviction.
asserted
Director → decline → conviction
Major Wilson told the senate the "corrupt" DFSC report had been used by Comcare and the CDPP, "and may have affected [its] decision … not to prosecute".
uncertain
report → tell → decision
The senate has also recommended the Department of Defence reconsider eligibility for the Roll of Honour at the Australian War Memorial.
asserted
Department → recommend → Memorial
The families of the four men were told their loved one's names could not be added to the roll, because they died during a peacetime training exercise.
uncertain
they → tell → exercise
"Should they be ineligible, the committee recommends a dedicated memorial be created along ANZAC Parade to honour training deaths," the senate report said.
asserted
report → recommend → deaths
The Aporia
