Nirmeen Noufl, who killed and dismembered her husband, Mamdouh Noufl, has been handed a minimum jail term of three years.
asserted
who → kill → years
She told psychiatrists an argument became physical one night in 2023 and she stabbed him "believing that her life was in danger".
asserted
life → tell → danger
Mamdouh Noufl's body has not been found.
asserted
body → find → ?
A woman who killed and dismembered her husband before disposing of his remains in bins around south-west Sydney has been handed a minimum jail term of three years, and will be eligible for parole next October.
asserted
who → kill → parole
WARNING: This story contains graphic content that some readers may find upsetting.
uncertain
readers → contain → content
Nirmeen Noufl, 55, pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of manslaughter just as her Supreme Court murder trial was due to begin last month.
asserted
trial → plead → manslaughter
The plea was accepted by prosecutors on the basis that it was a case of excessive self-defence.
asserted
it → accept → defence
Her husband, 62-year-old Mamdouh Noufl, was reported missing in July 2023 and she was arrested in October the following year, when police searched their Greenacre home.
asserted
police → report → home
Mr Noufl's body has not been found.
asserted
body → find → ?
According to the agreed facts in the case, Noufl told psychiatrists an argument became physical one night in May 2023, during which she was assaulted and attempted to get away.
uncertain
she → accord → which
She said she was pinned to the kitchen floor and choked before reaching for a nearby renovation tool and stabbing him, "believing that her life was in danger".
asserted
life → say → danger
Noufl then dismembered his body, with a witness who was at the house in subsequent days observing "pieces of a large round saw" that had been dismantled and pieces of plastic, some of which had blood on them.
asserted
some → dismember → them
Mr Noufl's remains were placed in garbage bags and dumped in rubbish bins with the help of the witness, who cannot be identified for legal reasons.
asserted
who → place → reasons
Justice Peter Hamill today handed Noufl a sentence of six years and three months, with a non-parole period of three years.
asserted
Hamill → hand → years
The judge said the minimum term would ensure Noufl had a period of supervision, if released, to re-integrate.
asserted
Noufl → say → supervision
Marriage marred by domestic violence
Justice Hamill said he was not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the offender intended to kill the victim, but that her conduct in disposing of her husband's remains was a "disturbing" feature of the case.
asserted
conduct → mar → case
"The disposal of the body in this case was as thorough as it was brutal,"he said.
asserted
it → say → case
According to the facts, the couple's marriage had been marred by issues including infidelity and domestic violence, much of which went unreported.
uncertain
much → accord → which
Her husband is described in those documents as strict, controlling and holding conservative Islamic views.
asserted
husband → describe → views
The court documents say Mr Noufl had met another woman during a 2022 trip to Egypt, where they owned property, and had told his wife he planned to marry the other woman.
asserted
he → say → woman
He denied Nirmeen Noufl's request for a divorce, the facts say.
asserted
facts → deny → divorce
Noufl is recorded as once telling another witness, after the death, that her husband "treated me like shit" and that she'd "had enough".
asserted
she → record → enough
There was evidence before the court from the couple's children that the relationship was "gravely abusive", Justice Hamill said, featuring violence, manipulation and coercive control.
asserted
Hamill → be → violence
Husband's family speak out
asserted
family → speak → ?
Mr Noufl's relatives, including his siblings, niece and nephew, spoke of his positive qualities in statements before the court.
asserted
relatives → include → court
His brother described him as kind, respectable, friendly and compassionate.
asserted
brother → describe → him
The relatives described carrying the pain of their loss for the rest of their lives, and one said the dismemberment represented "horrific cruelty".
asserted
dismemberment → describe → cruelty
It meant there was no resting place to visit and remember him, his nephew said.
asserted
nephew → mean → him
Outside court, one of Mr Noufl's nephews angrily expressed disapproval at the outcome.
asserted
one → express → outcome
"She should have got f***ing 25 years to life," he said.
asserted
he → get → life
"Look what she did to him, if it was an accident, if she was not meant to kill him, why did you f***ing dismember his body?"
asserted
you → look → body
Nirmeen Noufl's defence lawyer, Mohamed Bejjaoui, said the case represented "a tragic set of circumstances" and was "difficult on everybody, especially the family".
asserted
case → say → everybody
"She plans on being released, residing with her kids, and hopefully they can move on from this to the best of their ability," he said.
asserted
he → plan → ability
He added his client was "still distressed, very emotional".
asserted
client → add → ?
Asked whether his client was remorseful, Mr Bejjaoui replied: "She is, she is.
asserted
she → ask → ?
The Aporia
