In 1973, California homeowner Frank Clarke paid $5,000 for a backyard swimming pool after getting the required city permits.
asserted
Clarke → pay → permits
More than five decades later, the pool is part of a legal dispute over a sewer easement in Huntington Beach, LA Times reported.
asserted
Times → report → Beach
The Orange County Sanitation District (OC San) says it needs access to the area, while homeowners say they built their backyard structures with city approval.
asserted
they → say → approval
The dispute involves 29 properties on Rhone Lane, where a 30-foot-wide sewer easement runs through the backyards.
asserted
easement → involve → backyards
The easement contains a 69-inch wastewater pipeline installed in 1959, when much of Huntington Beach was farmland.
asserted
much → contain → Beach
The pipeline carries roughly 10 million gallons of wastewater daily and is part of the regional sewer system.
asserted
pipeline → carry → system
The dispute has now reached court.
asserted
dispute → reach → court
In May 2026, an Orange County Superior Court judge denied OC San’s motion, allowing the homeowners’ case over the easement to proceed to trial.
uncertain
case → deny → trial
Judge Deborah Servino said OC San had arguably shown that the full 30 feet could be needed for equipment during an emergency flow bypass.
uncertain
feet → say → bypass
However, she said the district had not shown that the structures and other objects on the properties were interfering with its full use of the easement as a matter of law.
asserted
structures → say → law
The court decision came after OC San started the Miller-Holder Rhone Lane Sewer Easement Cleanup Project in March 2026.
asserted
San → come → March
The district says the work is needed to keep the pipeline accessible for maintenance, inspections and future repairs.
asserted
work → say → maintenance
In July, OC San said the cleanup was about 50% complete.
asserted
cleanup → say → July
Why homeowners are fighting the easement
The sewer easement was recorded with the County of Orange in the early 1960s.
asserted
easement → fight → 1960s
The homes on the affected section of Rhone Lane were built during the 1960s and 1970s.
asserted
homes → build → 1960s
Clarke, who has lived at his home since the early 1970s, installed his swimming pool a few years after buying the property.
asserted
who → live → property
He said he obtained the necessary city permits and did not realise there was a problem until OC San contacted him.
asserted
San → say → him
A December 2023 letter from OC San listed structures and other items that homeowners needed to remove from the easement.
asserted
homeowners → list → easement
In Clarke’s backyard, these included the swimming pool, pool equipment, decking, a block wall, wood fencing and landscaping.
asserted
these → include → pool
“To me, somebody should have flagged the construction and said, ‘No, you can’t do it, because you’re on an easement,’” Clarke said.
asserted
Clarke → flag → easement
OC San says pipeline access is necessary
OC San says the easement needs to remain clear so its workers can safely reach the pipeline.
asserted
workers → say → pipeline
The district says encroachments currently limit its ability to carry out routine and preventive maintenance.
asserted
encroachments → say → maintenance
The pipeline is almost six feet wide and carries about 10 million gallons of wastewater each day.
asserted
pipeline → carry → wastewater
OC San says the sewer line serves tens of thousands of people and carries wastewater to its reclamation plants for treatment and recycling.
asserted
line → say → treatment
The district has also said that the pipeline, installed in 1959, remains an important part of the regional sewer system.
asserted
pipeline → say → system
“The sewer pipeline within the Miller-Holder Rhone Lane easement serves thousands of residents and plays an essential role in preventing sewage spills and system failures,” OC San said in a statement.
asserted
San → serve → statement
“Maintaining clear and safe access to this infrastructure is necessary for worker safety, regulatory compliance and long-term system reliability.”
asserted
Maintaining → maintain → safety
Residents question removal
asserted
Residents → question → removal
Several homeowners have said they obtained permits for their backyard structures and believed they were following the rules.
asserted
they → say → rules
Andrea and Phillip Rizzo are among those affected.
asserted
Rizzo → affect → those
backyard has an above-ground pool, a swing and a fire pit.
asserted
backyard → have → pool
The pool has a ramp for their 19-year-old son, A.J., who has cerebral palsy and uses a wheelchair.
asserted
who → have → wheelchair
Andrea Rizzo said the family had not been told exactly where the sewer pipe was located.
asserted
pipe → say → ?
“If you judge it according to the manhole, the pipe is somewhere between where the ramp is and the fence is,” she said.
uncertain
she → judge → is
“They haven’t told us where the pipe is.”
asserted
pipe → tell → us
Phillip Rizzo said he would be willing to move the pool while OC San accessed the easement.
asserted
San → say → easement
However, he said the reduced backyard space would make it impossible to put the pool back.
asserted
it → say → pool
“If the pipe’s at the end of its life, then let’s discuss it when the pipe’s scheduled to be replaced,” he said.
asserted
he → ’ → it
“If it’s replaced in 2025, then give us until 2025 to remove the alleged encroachments.”
Some homeowners have settled
OC San said agreements were in place with owners of 13 of the 29 properties.
asserted
agreements → replace → properties
The district has continued work at properties where homeowners signed settlement agreements, while other residents remain involved in the litigation.
asserted
residents → continue → litigation
…and 10 more, not listed.
The Aporia
