Over the past 18 months, tens of millions of Russians have been forced to install a new app on their phones – a violet-blue button designed for messaging and payments, called Max.
asserted
millions → force → messaging
Authorities have touted it as a patriotic alternative to Telegram and WhatsApp; Russian glitterati have promoted it in rap videos and comic routines.
asserted
glitterati → tout → videos
This summer, it became the country’s most-used messaging app.
asserted
it → become → ?
It is a product of VKontakte, the Russian social media company, which is deeply entangled with the Russian state.
asserted
which → entangle → state
The Russian president, Vladimir Putin, reportedly owns an indirect stake in Max.
uncertain
president → own → Max
Max is Russia’s version of a “super-app,” combining an ecosystem of services into a single platform.
asserted
Max → combine → platform
It is a container for a number of “mini-apps” that now facilitate everyday life in Russia – banking apps, a messaging service that aims to replace Telegram, and apps for essential government services.
asserted
that → facilitate → services
The best-known super-app in the world is WeChat, China’s everything platform which facilitates the state’s social controls.
asserted
which → know → controls
But while WeChat was developed over decades, in step with China’s other internet controls, Max has been imposed on a population that once had mostly-free internet access.
asserted
that → develop → access
Now, forensic research has revealed a fuller picture of Max’s powerful surveillance capabilities.
asserted
research → reveal → capabilities
These amount to a “backdoor” into its entire mini-app ecosystem on every user’s device, said Roya Ensafi, an associate professor of computer science at the University of Michigan.
asserted
Ensafi → amount → Michigan
“We have studied Russia’s escalation of internet control for the past decade,” said Ensafi.
asserted
Ensafi → study → decade
“What Max provides is the cleverest and also the scariest tactic by authoritarian governments” to surveil their citizens.
asserted
provides → provide → citizens
Max is “a blueprint any government can follow” towards digital authoritarianism, said Ensafi.
asserted
Ensafi → follow → authoritarianism
It represents the cutting edge of what governments such as Iran, Kazakhstan and India may soon try to achieve.
uncertain
governments → represent → Iran
Ensafi’s team were able to download the version of the app used in Russia.
asserted
team → download → Russia
They found that Max can screenshot users’ devices – and the contents of its mini-apps – without their knowledge.
asserted
Max → find → knowledge
It can access all the information stored in these mini-apps, their messages and payments.
asserted
It → access → apps
It can impersonate its users without them knowing.
asserted
them → impersonate → users
It can even inject code into mini-apps – which would mean, said Ensafi, that the Russian government could use Max to launch cyberattacks.
uncertain
government → inject → cyberattacks
Their research adds new clarity into an ongoing debate on Max’s surveillance capabilities.
asserted
research → add → capabilities
Crucially, said Ensafi, it cannot break into apps like Telegram and WhatsApp, if users have these installed.
asserted
these → say → Telegram
However, Russia has banned both.
asserted
Russia → ban → both
Many Russians working in or around state institutions have in effect been forced to use Max.
asserted
Russians → work → Max
Officials and public-sector employees, university students, teachers and even schoolchildren have all faced pressure to move their communications on to the platform.
asserted
Officials → face → platform
One schoolteacher in Moscow said staff at their school were ordered to switch to Max after instructions from the city authorities.
asserted
staff → say → authorities
“The school director called us in last March and told us directly: from now on, everything is on Max.
asserted
everything → call → Max
That included chats with parents, sending out homework and other school communication,” the teacher said.
asserted
teacher → include → homework
“There isn’t really an option to say no, so in the end you just use the app,” they added.
asserted
they → be → app
Daniil, a university student in St Petersburg, said he reluctantly downloaded Max shortly before the start of the academic year after being told students would be denied access to university buildings or dormitories without a QR code generated through the app.
asserted
students → say → app
He said he had concerns about the app’s security and privacy, but felt he had little choice if he wanted to continue accessing campus.
asserted
he → say → campus
Among Russia’s elite, use of Max often appears to be largely performative, with Telegram and Signal still widely used for day-to-day communication, according to several well-connected figures and prominent businesspeople.
uncertain
Telegram → appear → figures
One person in the Kremlin’s inner circle said he and several friends had bought second phones solely to install Max, while continuing to use their main devices and preferred messaging apps as before.
“It’s all for show.
asserted
It → say → show
No one in politics really uses it,” the person said, speaking on condition of anonymity.
asserted
person → use → anonymity
Max has yet to replace Telegram as a major source of news for Russians.
asserted
Max → have → Russians
Public channels – used by media outlets, bloggers and officials to broadcast news and commentary to large audiences – remain far less developed on Max, where only a small number have built audiences comparable to the biggest channels on Telegram.
asserted
number → use → Telegram
Several Max users contacted by the Guardian said the app closely resembles Telegram, long Russia’s most popular messaging platform, in its design and functionality, but concerns about privacy and surveillance were widespread.
asserted
concerns → contact → privacy
“Using Max feels like you never quite know who else might be watching,” said Nikolai, a 34-year-old consultant in Moscow.
uncertain
Nikolai → use → Moscow
While the app looked modern and slick, Nikolai said there was always something slightly sinister about using it.
asserted
Nikolai → look → it
“You end up using it more and more because the alternatives are becoming harder to access.
asserted
alternatives → end → it
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
