- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
More than 300 women have been harmed by the cancer care they received at an NHS Trust, including at least 20 undergoing unnecessary mastectomies.
Patients have described the shock they felt when they were told the removal of their breast could have been avoided, leaving them with both psychological and physical pain.
uncertain
removal → see → pain
Out of 514 cases reviewed by the County Durham and Darlington Foundation Trust (CDDFT), 315 have been found to have suffered harm, with 77 of them significantly harmed.
asserted
77 → review → them
One patient is known to have died.
asserted
patient → know → ?
Steve Russell, who has recently taken over as CDDFT's chief executive, has told the BBC he apologises 'unreservedly' for the harm caused by the trust.
'There are no words I could use to convey how personally distressed I am and my colleagues are for those outcomes and the harm that those women have experienced,' he said.
uncertain
he → take → that
'What happened was utterly unacceptable.
asserted
happened → happen → ?
'
The trust has also identified missed or delayed cancer diagnoses that led to some of the patients subsequently seeing their cancer spread, said Mr Russell.
asserted
Russell → identify → patients
Denise Howarth, 51, from Consett, County Durham, is one of several women who have been notified by the NHS that their mastectomy was unnecessary.
asserted
mastectomy → notify → NHS
Denise Howarth, 51, from Consett, County Durham, who was told by the NHS that their mastectomy was unnecessary, said she was left in 'shock' after being notified
She said: 'I was just in shock, then ended up in tears on the phone.
asserted
I → tell → phone
I can’t believe what you’re saying.
asserted
you → believe → what
It’s all good and well an apology.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
It can't give me my breast back'.
asserted
It → give → breast
After discovering a lump in her breast, Ms Howarth was diagnosed with grade 1 cancer in 2023.
asserted
Howarth → discover → 2023
She underwent a lumpectomy, then a mastectomy, as well as eight rounds of chemotherapy and radiotherapy.
asserted
She → undergo → chemotherapy
However, in September 2025, she received a call from the NHS, which was quickly followed by a letter from CDDFT, to tell her she could have been offered a second lumpectomy rather than full breast removal.
uncertain
she → receive → lumpectomy
Another woman, who wished to remain anonymous, contacted the trust's helpline about a mastectomy she had undergone in 2021 after being told earlier this year that the procedure could have been avoided.
uncertain
procedure → wish → 2021
The former NHS worker said she had trusted the people she considered colleagues to make the best decisions for her.
asserted
she → say → her
'You go to work to do your best, don't you?,' she said.
asserted
she → go → best
'So why would I think that anybody else wouldn't?'
asserted
anybody → think → ?
She added that she now feels 'mutilated' by the operation and says the mistakes made are 'absolutely unforgivable'.
asserted
mistakes → add → operation
The consultant overseeing the pair's cancer was Amir Bhatti, the CDDFT's clinical lead for breast services between 2013 and 2024.
asserted
consultant → oversee → 2013
Mr Bhatti has now been suspended from carrying out clinical practice but is still employed by the trust on full pay.
asserted
Bhatti → suspend → pay
CDDFT is carrying out an internal review of breast cancer cases between January 2023 and February 2025, alongside the cases of 640 former patients who contacted a dedicated helpline.
asserted
who → carry → helpline
It is understood that a decision on whether to extend the scope of the review to look at cases dating back to 2015 is imminent.
asserted
decision → understand → 2015
This means that up to 10,000 medical records could be reopened.
uncertain
records → mean → ?
The National Crime Agency says it is now working with Durham Police to investigate the allegations by former patients to determine if criminal offences have taken place.
asserted
offences → say → place
Last year, the BBC reported that the trust had been paid almost £6million to breast cancer diagnostic clinics and surgery companies run privately by Mr Bhatti.
asserted
trust → report → Bhatti
Amir Bhatti, the CDDFT's clinical lead for breast services between 2013 and 2024, has now been suspended from carrying out clinical practice but is still employed by the trust on full pay
However, concerns were raised in a 2025 review, in which governance specialist Mary Aubrey said outsourcing patient appointments had created financial incentives which were potentially 'a risk to clinical standards'.
asserted
which → suspend → standards
Mr Russell argued that payment per service is not uncommon in healthcare but said that the trust has ended this arrangement for breast cancer services.
asserted
trust → argue → services
The review also suggested patients were potentially treated by locum consultants who were not competent.
uncertain
who → suggest → consultants
It noted that Mr Bhatti had repeatedly voiced his concerns about trust delays in obtaining vital diagnostic equipment.
asserted
Bhatti → note → equipment
When approached, Mr Bhatti said: 'I am grateful for the opportunity to respond, but I remain committed to the ongoing trust investigation, and it would be inappropriate for me to discuss this whilst proceedings are ongoing.'
asserted
proceedings → approach → this
Concerns were also raised by the Royal College of Surgeons in a report last year, which claimed that breast cancer cases had not been discussed properly in multi-disciplinary team meetings.
asserted
cases → raise → meetings
The trust said it is fully cooperating with the investigation by Durham Police and the National Crime Agency.
asserted
it → say → Police
A support group where women can share their experiences is meeting at Beamish Football Centre in the town of Stanley, with the group now putting its focus on calling for a public inquiry.
asserted
group → share → inquiry
One of the group's organisers, Lynn, says she has been told by the trust that her breast removal was unnecessary.
asserted
removal → say → trust
'I didn't realise how many ladies lived so near me that had been affected,' said Lynn.
asserted
Lynn → realise → me
The Department of Health and Social Care said their thoughts are with the women and families affected by these unacceptable failings in care.
asserted
thoughts → say → care
It said the trust was working urgently with NHS England, the Care Quality Commission and independent experts to address what had happened and to ensure that all future patients receive safe care.
asserted
patients → say → care
- Breast Cancer Scandal: Exposing the Harm will be available on BBC iPlayer and broadcast on BBC One in the North East & Cumbria at 7:30pm on Friday September 18
asserted
Scandal → expose → Friday
The Aporia
