Among many wild claims made by disgraced property developer Jean Nassif in his audiovisual appearance at the Independent Commission Against Corruption’s Operation Rosny inquiry this week, he blamed the deep state and corrupt politicians for his downfall.
uncertain
he → make → downfall
The self-described Godfather grabbed the headlines in an action-packed week at the inquiry that began with a blackmail claim aired by a former mayor of Strathfield, took a sharp turn into Nassif’s Lebanese bedroom, then back to Strathfield where a key figure in the inquiry – former councillor Sharangan Maheswaran – made his first appearance.
uncertain
figure → describe → appearance
Here are five things we learnt in week eight.
asserted
we → learn → week
“I am a man of honour,” Nassif thundered over the video link, wagging his finger at counsel assisting Dr Peggy Dwyer, SC, and insisting that any acts of corruption were committed against him by politicians and regulators who sought to scrutinise his crumbling real estate developments.
asserted
who → thunder → developments
Nassif accused the commission of not wanting to hear the truth as Dwyer pressed him on payments he had made to “the boys”, a reference to Liberal operatives Jeremy Greenwood and Christian Ellis, whose lobby firm, Beckington, was contracted to do work for Nassif.
asserted
firm → accuse → Nassif
His woes were all the fault of former police minister David Elliott and former building commissioner David Chandler, he said.
asserted
he → say → Elliott
He warmed to the theme so much that he had to pause transmission to get up and switch on the air-conditioning in his bedroom at one point.
asserted
he → warm → point
Behind the belligerence and finger pointing, it’s worth noting that Nassif didn’t dispute a core assertion the inquiry is examining – that he paid Liberal Party operatives to use their influence to, as he put it, “unblock my development”.
asserted
he → ’ → development
The accidental creditor
It emerged on Wednesday that two Liberal Party operatives accused of washing illegal political donations through their companies are listed as creditors wanting to claw back more than $2 million from Nassif, whose company, Toplace, collapsed in 2023 with debts of at least $1 billion.
asserted
company → emerge → billion
Counsel assisting Dr Peggy Dwyer, SC, told the commission that Beckington, which ex-Liberal powerbroker Christian Ellis and his business partner Jeremy Greenwood co-founded, and JPG Advisory, Greenwood’s firm, appear as creditors in publicly available documents.
asserted
Ellis → assist → documents
Dwyer said Ellis had claimed that Beckington was owed $1,433,000 by Toplace, and Greenwood’s company JPG Advisory appears as a creditor owed $721,700.
asserted
company → say → 721,700
“Yeah, I definitely haven’t put in a form, sorry, it might be those outstanding invoices, but I’ve never submitted anything,” Greenwood said.
uncertain
Greenwood → put → anything
Computer says no
Real estate agent Mohammad Abedin rocked up to give evidence on Thursday in a natty three-piece suit and hot-pink tie, but his credibility began to look a little threadbare under questioning.
Abedin denied that former Strathfield councillor Sharangan Maheswaran had written his evidence statement for the ICAC for him, but was unable to explain why a document titled “Mohammad Abedin statement.docx” was sent by Maheswaran to the lawyer who witnessed it.
asserted
who → say → it
After earlier telling the corruption inquiry he never shared the contents of his ICAC statement with anyone, Abedin suggested he might have shown Maheswaran an earlier “funny” version, and he had used artificial intelligence tool ChatGPT to prepare his final statement.
uncertain
he → tell → statement
When counsel assisting Juliet Curtin pointed out that Abedin did not have ChatGPT, the Homebush real estate agent suggested he had used a different phone that included the app while he was overseas in Bangladesh.
uncertain
he → assist → Bangladesh
He blamed ChatGPT for inconsistencies with his written statement and evidence given in the public hearing.
asserted
He → blame → hearing
‘He surveillanced me’
asserted
He → surveillance → me
An ex-mayor of Strathfield, Matthew Blackmore, told the inquiry he received blackmail threats from a fellow ex-councillor, Sharangan Maheswaran, who also happened to be an executive with Nassif’s Toplace.
asserted
who → tell → Toplace
“He had surveillanced [sic] me for five months, and he was going to use that against me,” Blackmore said.
asserted
Blackmore → surveillance → me
Blackmore was later replaced as mayor by Labor councillor Karen Pensabene, who had been scheduled to appear at the inquiry as a witness but has been excused due to ill health.
asserted
who → replace → health
It also emerged that Maheswaran did not declare his close association with property developer Nassif when nominating for council in 2021.
asserted
Maheswaran → emerge → 2021
Counsel assisting Peggy Dwyer, SC, told Maheswaran the commission had records suggesting he was paid $926,177 from Nassif’s company, Toplace, between July 2020 and March 2023, but Maheswaran disagreed.
asserted
Maheswaran → assist → July
“I thought it was higher than that,” he said.
asserted
he → think → that
Meet the new boss
Maheswaran said he raised concerns with Nassif about the contract with Beckington – the firm run by Jeremy Greenwood and Christian Ellis – but Nassif had said he was only keeping the contract to be closer to their “boss”.
asserted
he → meet → boss
Maheswaran said he understood the term “boss” to be a reference to Charles Perrottet, an ex-Liberal Party powerbroker, brother of the former premier Dominic and an executive at BP.
asserted
term → say → BP
The ICAC is investigating allegations Perrottet shared in $2 million promised by Nassif in exchange for the promise of certain political outcomes.
asserted
Perrottet → investigate → outcomes
Maheswaran described a meeting he had at a CBD restaurant with Greenwood, Perrottet and Ellis when the men discussed going into a hospitality business venture using the money Beckington was paid from Toplace.
asserted
Beckington → describe → Toplace
He said he had an assumption that Perrottet had an expectation of being paid, and there may have been a mention of a referral fee, but he couldn’t recall exactly how he believed this.
uncertain
he → say → this
Paul Keating’s famous parliamentary put-down – “I want to do you slowly” – might well be applied to the inquiry’s approach to cross-examination if next week’s witness list is anything to go by.
uncertain
list → want → examination
Maheswaran is set to challenge current titleholder Jeremy Greenwood for most appearances as an Operation Rosny witness, with the former Strathfield councillor and Toplace executive slated for another full day’s appearance on Monday, followed by further stints in the witness box on Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.
asserted
councillor → set → Wednesday
The only other witness listed for next week is private investigator Shane De Kauwe, who was allegedly engaged by Maheswaran to undertake surveillance work with mixed results.
uncertain
who → list → results
He is to appear at the inquiry on Tuesday.
asserted
He → appear → Tuesday
Sydney’s best coverage of the ICAC inquiry
- ‘You want the country to be ruled by crooks ... I am a man of honour’: Jean Nassif’s explosive ICAC tirade
-
asserted
I → want → honour
ICAC hears double-crosses, blackmail and broken promises
- ‘Is that news to you?’
asserted
that → hear → you
Liberal apparatchiks listed as Toplace creditors
-
asserted
apparatchiks → list → creditors
The eyebrows have it: ICAC witness stretches credulity and patience
Start the day with a summary of the day’s most important and interesting stories, analysis and insights.
asserted
witness → have → stories
The Aporia
