A proposed new European security forum would include Canada, Britain and Ukraine as partners — but defence experts here say it’s not clear what the council, or Ottawa’s involvement, ultimately would look like.
asserted
council → propose → what
European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen laid out a sales pitch for a new European Security Council in a speech to the European Parliament in Strasbourg, France, on Wednesday.
asserted
Leyen → lay → Wednesday
“For a long time, we have discussed a leaders’ format focused on the security of our continent, with partners like Canada, Norway, Ukraine, the United Kingdom and others involved,” she said.
asserted
she → discuss → Canada
“This is even more urgent now, given the nature and scale of the risks at play.
asserted
This → give → play
This is why we will set out our ideas to make a European Security Council a reality.”
asserted
Council → set → ideas
Prime Minister Mark Carney, who had a front-row seat for the speech, has been seeking alternate ways for Ottawa to manage security and trade that don’t involve the United States.
asserted
that → have → States
Stephen Saideman, a professor at Carleton University’s Norman Paterson School of International Affairs, said it’s not clear if such a council would be largely symbolic or focused on co-ordinating policy.
asserted
council → say → policy
But it appears to be a “perfectly reasonable way” to manage dealing with the United States under the chaotic and unpredictable administration of President Donald Trump, he said.
asserted
he → appear → Trump
“The Europeans are starting to think about Canada as being in this world without a reliable United States.
asserted
Europeans → start → States
Even if this is just a symbolic thing, the symbolism is still important,” he said.
asserted
he → say → ?
Saideman said it also could be a way to develop “legal structures and political co-ordination to figure out how to respond to these creative ways in which (Russian President Vladimir) Putin and others are trying to annoy and harm us and divide us.”
uncertain
Putin → say → us
Von der Leyen said Europe needs a new mechanism to “flank” NATO’s collective defence provisions to counter emerging hybrid threats that fall below the legal threshold of armed military attacks.
asserted
that → say → attacks
The EU’s top bureaucrat pointed to a few recent examples, including a drone attack on an airport in Leipzig last month.
asserted
bureaucrat → point → Leipzig
The Germans have blamed Russia for that attack.
asserted
Germans → blame → attack
Russia has been testing Europe for a few years now through actions like cutting undersea cables and sending drones across borders — incidents that don’t qualify as traditional attacks.
asserted
that → test → attacks
The idea for the new security body also comes as many in Europe question whether Trump would come to the continent’s aid in a security crisis.
asserted
Trump → come → crisis
The Pentagon ordered a troop drawdown from Germany earlier this year and reportedly wants European states to take over most of NATO’s conventional continental defence by 2027.
uncertain
states → order → 2027
Kerry Buck, Canada’s former ambassador to NATO, said that in the absence of public details of the proposal, it’s not clear how such a council would work in practice.
asserted
council → say → practice
The European Union already has a mutual defence clause which says that if a member state is attacked, the other members must come to its aid, consistent with their commitments under NATO.
asserted
members → have → NATO
But there’s a clear division in how Europe’s collective defence is organized.
asserted
defence → ’ → ?
NATO has a command structure that organizes kinetic military responses and deterrence, while the EU mostly takes care of things like aligning procurement initiatives.
asserted
EU → have → initiatives
Buck gave the example of tank purchases — instead of allied militaries buying 21 different makes, the union would help them co-ordinate on acquiring a smaller number of interoperable tanks.
asserted
them → give → tanks
She said there could be space for a security council if it focuses not on military response but on issues that fall under the threshold of an armed attack — things such as cyber attacks or disinformation aimed at polarizing electorates.
uncertain
that → say → electorates
“It could be a useful contribution to security architecture in Europe if that’s what the EU Security Council focuses on,” Buck said.
uncertain
Buck → ’ → what
“If it’s about duplicating NATO and situating that inside the EU architecture, from my perspective, without knowing the details, that seems to me to be less credible and a less useful contribution.”
asserted
that → ’ → me
The French newspaper Le Monde quoted EU Defence Commissioner Andrius Kubilius saying that “key details of new defence architecture” would be sketched out in a forthcoming security strategy document.
asserted
details → quote → document
Kubilius published a paper earlier this year suggesting that such a council could work like the UN Security Council, with a core group of permanent members, such as Germany, France and Poland, and other members rotating in and out.
uncertain
council → publish → Germany
It’s been kicked around for decades in various forms.
asserted
It → kick → forms
French President Emmanuel Macron and then-German Chancellor Angela Merkel put a continental security council on the political agenda nearly ten years ago, with an eye to maintaining security relations with the United Kingdom after Brexit.
But the idea remained vaguely defined and never gained any traction.
asserted
idea → put → traction
Luigi Scazzieri, a senior policy analyst at the European Union Institute for Security Studies, noted in an article published in February that the core appeal of the idea is that it could lead to faster decision-making and better coordination.
uncertain
it → note → making
But debate over the proposal, he wrote, has “long been shaped by a lack of clarity over what such a body would actually look like” and could run up against “political and practical constraints” from member states, depending on the proposed design.
uncertain
body → write → design
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 18, 2026.
asserted
report → publish → Press
The Aporia
