The Supreme Court is once again under attack from those calling for packing, or even eliminating, the institution as hopelessly ideological and divided.
asserted
Court → call → institution
The Philadelphia Inquirer recently proclaimed that “The Supreme Court’s conservative majority keeps choosing ideology over impartiality.”
asserted
majority → proclaim → impartiality
Other media outlets reported “devastating” polling showing the Court as unpopular and losing institutional respect.
asserted
outlets → report → respect
Looking at the actual rulings disproves the argument of a “biased” court.
asserted
Looking → look → court
The Court ruled unanimously in more than 44% of cases, slightly up from the prior year.
asserted
Court → rule → cases
When you add the roughly 11% of opinions that were 8-1 and 6% that were 7-1 or 7-2, the rate of unanimous or nearly unanimous jumps to 62%.
asserted
rate → add → %
While slightly up, the ideological split emphasized in the coverage is found in less than a quarter of the cases.
asserted
split → emphasize → cases
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson had the lowest percentage in the majority in the last term.
However, she was still in the majority in 72% of cases.
asserted
she → have → cases
Crossing the prez
Jackson even agreed with Justice Samuel Alito in 49% of the cases and with Justice Clarence Thomas in half of the cases.
asserted
Jackson → cross → cases
The narrative also ignores major losses by the Trump administration in cases dealing with birthright citizenship, mail-in ballots, tariffs, the Federal Reserve Board members and even Trump’s personal defamation case.
asserted
narrative → ignore → citizenship
Just this week, the court issued a ruling that President Trump called “a big loss for Republicans” in rejecting a mail-in ballot change for the next election.
asserted
Trump → issue → election
Those cases saw conservatives voting with their liberal colleagues.
asserted
conservatives → see → colleagues
Indeed, Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Amy Coney Barrett, Justice Brett Kavanaugh, and Justice Neil Gorsuch are generally viewed as “in play” in a variety of cases in creating mixed majorities.
asserted
Roberts → view → majorities
Critics aren’t just wrong that the court is biased, it’s incorrect that the Supremes are particularly unpopular.
asserted
Supremes → bias → ?
A recent Marquette Law School poll shows that the court remains slightly underwater in popularity — with 47% favor, 53% disfavor.
asserted
% → show → favor
The unpopularity of Congress hit a whopping 86% this year.
asserted
unpopularity → hit → %
Gallup found that only 10% of the American people hold a favorable view of Congress.
asserted
% → find → Congress
Trump’s popularity stands at around 40%.
asserted
popularity → stand → %
So the Supreme Court has the highest approval rate and is massively more popular than Congress.
asserted
Court → have → Congress
Yet, these members want to trash the most popular institution among the three branches.
asserted
members → want → branches
Plenty of unanimity
This term is shaping up as another blockbuster, with major cases on gun rights, parental rights, immigration, climate change and other issues.
asserted
term → shape → rights
Some cases will break along a 6-3 ideological divide, but many more will be decided by unanimity or mixed majorities, as in past years.
asserted
more → break → years
That problem is that many in the media and politics will continue to demonize the court for those cases upon which they disagree and ignore the many cases upon which most of the justices agree.
asserted
most → continue → justices
That includes exaggerated claims of the court “killing democracy.”
uncertain
court → include → democracy
The move to pack the court is based on a long-standing radical agenda to change the constitutional system on the left.
asserted
move → pack → left
The court is standing in the way and these figures know that it is not easy to get a free people to give up on protections for those freedoms.
asserted
people → stand → freedoms
They have to be very angry or very afraid.
asserted
They → have → ?
As a result, the court will resume hearing cases in an atmosphere of rage directed at its institution.
asserted
court → resume → institution
This court continues to function as designed as a principled, independent institution.
asserted
court → continue → institution
On our 250th anniversary, we should celebrate, not demonize, our highest court.
asserted
we → celebrate → court
Jonathan Turley is a law professor and the best-selling author of “Rage and the Republic: The Unfinished Story of the American Revolution.”
asserted
Turley → sell → Revolution
The Aporia
