Based on the way American attitudes have shifted toward a certain country in the Middle East, Robert Kraft likely lost a lot of fans with a recent decision.
asserted
Kraft → base → decision
But that doesn't mean it was the wrong decision.
asserted
it → mean → ?
The Patriots' owner said Monday that Macklemore will be removed from two of Ed Sheeran's shows later this month at Gillette Stadium (which Kraft also owns) for what he deemed "hate speech" toward the Jewish community.
asserted
he → say → community
Macklemore has made no secret of how he feels about Israel, regularly using his platform to decry a "genocide" he falsely says is taking place in Gaza.
asserted
he → make → Gaza
His protest song "Hind's Hall" — in which he says former President Joe Biden has blood on his hands and that the music industry is "complicit" with its "silence" — is hardly subtle.
asserted
industry → say → silence
It celebrates the violent and illegal actions by students, faculty and outside activists on the campus of Columbia University.
asserted
It → celebrate → University
And though some may accuse Kraft of launching an attack on free speech, I think he was saying something else: enough.
uncertain
he → accuse → something
That takes a lot of spine when it's clear there will be backlash.
asserted
it → take → spine
All of the other opening acts for Sheeran (not to mention his own band) quit the tour in solidarity with Macklemore, while Congresswoman Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez denounced Kraft's choice as "censorship" against "the genocide in Gaza."
Kraft has since pledged $2 million toward humanitarian aid in the Israel-Gaza region but he's held firm on his Macklemore ban.
asserted
he → mention → ban
The genocide talk has to stop — because it has real consequences.
asserted
it → have → consequences
"Real Time" host Bill Maher expressed a similar sentiment during his "New Rule" segment last Friday.
asserted
Maher → express → segment
It was a long way from an Israel hagiography, but he pushed back against the genocide lie that so many have adopted as fact.
asserted
many → push → fact
Genocides, Maher said, are attempts to wipe out entire populations.
asserted
Maher → say → populations
The attacker won't stop until all of its human targets are exterminated.
asserted
all → stop → targets
That isn't what's happening in Gaza — just as it wasn't what was happening when the U.S. dropped two atomic bombs on Japan, leading to the end of World War II.
asserted
U.S. → happen → II
A stat that Maher used to bolster his point was that about 73,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli counter attacks since October 7, 2023,(according to Hamas, while not distinguishing how many were part of Hamas) which comprises roughly three percent of their population.
uncertain
which → use → population
He then pointed out how nearly 99 percent of the three million Jews in Poland were killed during World War II.
asserted
percent → point → II
The first reflects the tragedy of war.
asserted
first → reflect → war
Still, polling has shown that Americans are more likely to believe that a genocide is taking place in Gaza than not.
asserted
genocide → show → Gaza
And it coincides with a Gallup poll showing that more Americans are sympathetic toward Palestine than it is Israel.
asserted
it → coincide → Palestine
Another study found that almost half the country has difficulty distinguishing American Jews from the Israeli government.
asserted
country → find → government
Might that be why the Anti-Defamation League reported a 360% increase in antisemitic incidents since Hamas' attack on Israel three Octobers ago?
uncertain
League → report → Israel
Or why a 2025 American Jewish Committee poll found that 91 percent of American Jews felt less safe as a Jewish person due to violent attacks in the U.S?
asserted
percent → find → U.S
Or why 55 percent said they have changed their behavior (such as hiding Jewish identity) over a one-year span for fear of antisemitism?
asserted
they → say → antisemitism
If you watch this video of Pro-Palestine supporters blocking a Jewish student from going to class, you'll see a clear case of young minds being poisoned by rhetoric.
asserted
minds → watch → rhetoric
Kraft, who's Jewish, knows the effect that type of rhetoric can have.
asserted
type → know → rhetoric
So, he did something about it.
asserted
he → do → it
This, of course, is much different than preventing someone from speaking their minds in a public space.
asserted
This → prevent → space
Free speech in that respect must be preserved at all costs.
asserted
speech → preserve → costs
But the First Amendment doesn't stop words from having consequences.
asserted
Amendment → stop → consequences
Sometimes they get you fired, sometimes they tarnish your reputation, and sometimes they make it so you can't perform in privately-owned stadiums.
asserted
you → get → stadiums
This isn't the first time Macklemore has been muted for what's come out of his mouth.
asserted
what → mute → mouth
After he said "F--- America" at a show in Seattle two years ago, the Mariners stopped playing his song "Can't Hold Us" during the seventh-inning stretch.
asserted
Mariners → say → stretch
No doubt the rapper has the right to say what he wants.
asserted
he → have → what
But Kraft and other owners have the right — or perhaps in this case, duty — to say "not on our turf."
asserted
Kraft → have → turf
I'm generally not a big fan of end-zone messaging like "End Racism."
asserted
I → end → Racism
It just feels performative.
asserted
It → feel → ?
But Yom Kippur — the holiest of Jewish holidays — starts at sundown Sunday.
asserted
Kippur → start → sundown
If the NFL insists on those end-zone slogans, maybe "End Antisemitism" should get a turn
asserted
NFL → insist → turn
The Aporia
