The Trump administration is attempting to reconcile two irreconcilable forces: a dynamic private market and an aggressive, interventionist state.
asserted
administration → attempt → forces
The Trump administration has had no qualms about creating a “venture capitalist state,” taking ownership stakes in over 30 companies during President Donald Trump’s second term.
asserted
administration → have → term
Over time, this creeping state capitalism will produce the exact opposite of economic dynamism: distorted capital markets, entrenched cronyism, and long-term stagnation.
asserted
capitalism → creep → dynamism
The promise that state-directed capital allocation can accelerate private-sector growth is a mirage.
asserted
allocation → direct → growth
Government intervention in markets unleashes perverse incentives that will reduce competition and produce stagnation in the long run.
asserted
that → unleash → run
Two recent high-profile initiatives illustrate the hazards of this model: the state-brokered Venezuelan oil venture and the launch of the Trump Accounts program.
asserted
initiatives → illustrate → program
The recent agreement granting North American Blue Energy Partners access to develop an estimated 65 billion barrels of proven Venezuelan oil reserves has been widely celebrated on the Right as a strategic triumph.
asserted
agreement → grant → triumph
Under the arrangement, the Department of War has secured a 35% equity stake in NABEP, while the State Department holds an option to purchase 20% of output at cost.
asserted
Department → secure → cost
Impressive oil reserves do not automatically translate into cheaper gasoline because of the high cost of extracting and processing Venezuelan oil.
asserted
reserves → translate → oil
On the extraction front, tens of billions of dollars must be invested just to get the oil out of the ground.
asserted
billions → invest → ground
This investment carries significant risk because of the historical instability and hostility of the Venezuelan government.
asserted
investment → carry → government
While that appears to be less of an issue at the moment, who can say what the U.S. and Venezuelan governments will be like in five-10 years?
asserted
governments → appear → years
But putting aside the hefty initial investment, it’s also more expensive to process Venezuelan oil.
asserted
it → put → oil
It is heavy crude oil requiring more processing than lighter crude oil.
asserted
It → require → oil
This all means that these oil fields only make sense to develop and work when the price of a barrel of oil is higher than Trump or any consumers want it to be.
asserted
it → mean → oil
When a deal only “works” because the state has agreed to guarantee a buyer, that’s not a market allocating capital efficiently, it’s politics allocating capital.
asserted
politics → work → capital
Ideal free markets have a strict firewall between political authority and private commerce.
asserted
markets → have → authority
Without that barrier, regulatory capture, central planning, and compromised consumer choice inevitably seep into markets.
asserted
capture → compromise → markets
A vivid display of this boundary eroding occurred on the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.
asserted
display → occur → Independence
Flanked by Sen. Ted Cruz (R-TX) as well as Michael and Susan Dell, Trump rang the stock exchange opening bell from the White House to announce “Trump Accounts” for young Americans.
asserted
Trump → flank → Americans
And the Dells’ pledge to distribute over $6.25 billion of their own wealth to millions of children is laudable.
asserted
pledge → distribute → children
But Trump’s exhortation to Americans to buy Dell computers to boost the stock price, increase Michael Dell’s net worth, and lay the groundwork for another big donation in the future
asserted
exhortation → buy → future
exposes how little the president really knows about wealth.
asserted
president → expose → wealth
It also reveals the implicit (and sometimes explicit) pressure politicians can exert on business people.
asserted
politicians → reveal → people
Wealth is not created by high stock prices or high crypto prices or big investment deals.
asserted
Wealth → create → prices
Instead, high prices often represent wealth.
asserted
prices → represent → wealth
But high prices can also be transitory if there is imperfect information or temporary exuberance in demand.
asserted
prices → be → demand
The infamous “pump and dump” strategies of fly-by-night crypto token issuers burned many gullible investors.
asserted
strategies → pump → investors
Unfortunately, the president’s remarks, and his own track record issuing a meme coin, follow the same pattern.
asserted
remarks → issue → pattern
Similarly, big investment commitments may or may not come to fruition.
When state ownership replaces consumer sovereignty, bureaucrats and politicians pick winners and losers based on political connections rather than economic value.
uncertain
bureaucrats → come → value
Subsidies, fast-tracked approvals, and direct government equity tilt the playing field toward connected incumbents and discourage emergent competitors.
asserted
Subsidies → track → competitors
Furthermore, the complexity of government programs also skews their benefits: While ordinary families receive few deductions under the Trump Accounts program, wealthy donors and corporations can gain special tax advantages.
asserted
donors → skew → advantages
The system rewards connections over value creation.
asserted
system → reward → creation
The costs in those industries have outpaced inflation for decades, even as people complain about their shortcomings.
asserted
people → outpace → shortcomings
The Trump administration may talk a good game about ownership, wealth, productivity, and economic growth, but its carefree wheeling and dealing in the economy and in markets has much more in common with progressivism and socialism than with the free markets that characterized the United States for most of its history.
uncertain
that → talk → history
On paper, the Department of War and the Department of State’s stakes in this Venezuelan oil deal may look savvy.
uncertain
stakes → look → deal
The same can be said of
asserted
same → say → ?
Intel is instructive: After the federal government converted CHIPS Act grants into a roughly 10% equity stake in the company, the firm’s fortunes became partly a function of political favor rather than market success with customers alone.
asserted
fortunes → convert → customers
It creates uncertainty about whether Intel’s turnaround is real or simply subsidized.
asserted
turnaround → create → uncertainty
Because government officials don’t have much skin in the game, they fall prey to knowledge and incentive problems identified by Austrian economists a century ago.
asserted
they → have → economists
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
