Pennsylvania lawmakers are warning that proposed changes to the state’s public health rules could usher in "COVID 2.0," giving health officials sweeping "police power" over residents during future disease outbreaks.
uncertain
changes → warn → outbreaks
Lawmakers opposing Pennsylvania's planned 502-page rewrite of state health code rules are urging the public to submit comments before the deadline, warning the proposal could serve as a roadmap to unfettered and intrusive restrictions and surveillance efforts, including the reported ability for agency representatives to enter private homes.
"
uncertain
representatives → oppose → homes
This absolutely is COVID 2.0, but it's even worse because [Governor] Josh Shapiro is trying to circumnavigate or skirt the constitutional provision that we the people in Pennsylvania voted to take that kind of power away from the governor
asserted
we → try → governor
," said State Rep. Russ Diamond, R-Lebanon, who is leading the charge against the policy changes.
asserted
who → say → changes
"We were the only state in the nation to reduce our governor's powers by a constitutional amendment after COVID," Diamond said, adding that "surveillance, segregation and quarantine" are areas being assessed.
asserted
surveillance → reduce → COVID
Pennsylvania voters approved a constitutional amendment in 2021 limiting the duration of a governor’s disaster declaration to 21 days unless extended by the General Assembly.
asserted
voters → approve → Assembly
Those emergency powers played a central role in then-Gov. Tom Wolf’s statewide mitigation orders.
asserted
powers → play → orders
In the 502-page proposed Regulation 10-242, Communicable and Noncommunicable Diseases, the Pennsylvania Department of Health proposes expanding the list of reportable diseases, infections and conditions and updating the rules to reflect changing expert standards.
asserted
Department → propose → standards
"The Department proposes to add language in this subsection, indicating that the Department or a local health authority may enter an apartment, a building, a health care facility, a school, college or university, or other location as necessary to conduct its investigation under 208 this chapter," one provision highlighted by critics reads.
uncertain
provision → propose → critics
"I don't think that we want a very left-leaning governor with his Department of Health and their henchmen having this kind of police power in Pennsylvania," Diamond said.
asserted
Diamond → think → Pennsylvania
A spokesperson for Health Secretary Dr. Debra Bogen — who led the Pittsburgh area’s COVID mitigation response — said Shapiro "did not personally propose" the updates and rejected critics’ characterizations.
asserted
Shapiro → lead → characterizations
"Any misconstruing of these proposed changes designed to scare Pennsylvanians is inaccurate and disingenuous," Neil Ruhland told Fox News Digital.
asserted
Ruhland → propose → Digital
A Shapiro spokesperson also responded to criticism Wednesday, saying the governor’s philosophy is that "public health depends on trust" and emphasizing that the proposed health regulations are part of a larger effort to update about 200 regulatory areas across state agencies.
asserted
regulations → respond → agencies
Lapowsky told Fox News Digital that the public, stakeholders, independent regulators and the legislature can review and respond to the proposed changes.
asserted
public → tell → changes
"Once public comment concludes later this month, [Shapiro] will weigh in, and the regulations will be revised accordingly," she said.
asserted
she → conclude → ?
Lapowsky said Shapiro’s emphasis on public trust includes respecting parental rights.
asserted
emphasis → say → rights
Critics say the proposed regulations could give health officials greater authority over certain disease-control measures involving children, including masking.
uncertain
regulations → say → masking
Lapowsky added that the governor believes "government should work closely with the people it serves."
asserted
it → add → people
Ruhland said the Pennsylvania Department of Health began analyzing and proposing regulatory updates several years ago and that the regulations in question are 25 years old and need modernization to "better support evolving public health needs and manage dangerous disease."
asserted
regulations → say → disease
While the proposed regulations do not themselves enact a new mask mandate, they would broaden disease-control language beyond "surveillance," a term central to litigation over Pennsylvania’s statewide school masking order during the pandemic.
asserted
they → propose → pandemic
Pennsylvania House Minority Leader Jesse Topper told Fox News Digital that although the proposed regulations directly affect Pennsylvania, Americans elsewhere should also pay attention.
asserted
Americans → tell → attention
"Everybody in the United States was impacted by COVID one way or another," said Topper, R-McConnellsburg.
asserted
Topper → impact → COVID
"We were one of the worst locked-down states in the entire nation.
asserted
We → lock → nation
And we had one of the worst death rates from COVID…
asserted
we → have → COVID
We don't want unelected bureaucrats making those decisions.
asserted
bureaucrats → want → decisions
We need to follow the [Commonwealth] Constitution, which says, ‘Hey, you can declare a public health disaster emergency if you want.
asserted
you → need → emergency
But after 21 days, the legislature gets to say whether you can continue that or not’."
State Sen. Doug Mastriano, R-Gettysburg, who along with Diamond led demonstrations against lockdown policies during COVID, told Fox News Digital that the proposed regulations are an "end-round" around voters.
"Pennsylvania endured enough government overreach during COVID.
asserted
Pennsylvania → get → COVID
We will not go back," said Mastriano, whom President Donald Trump nominated to serve as U.S. ambassador to Slovakia.
asserted
Trump → go → Slovakia
Jason Richey, an attorney and the Republican nominee for lieutenant governor, also dubbed the changes "COVID 2.0."
asserted
Richey → dub → changes
[DOH] can look at your medical records.
asserted
DOH → look → records
They can enter any building and go in without a warrant to do an investigation.
asserted
They → enter → investigation
They can even take your kid from school and talk to him privately without your consent," Richey said in a video recorded outside a Pennsylvania Department of Health office in Lehigh County last week.
asserted
Richey → take → County
Beyond the public health implications, Topper said he is concerned that the proposed regulations would expand government authority.
asserted
regulations → say → authority
Topper and Ruhland both encouraged Pennsylvanians to submit feedback on the proposed regulations before Monday’s public-comment deadline.
asserted
Topper → encourage → deadline
The Aporia
