Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski sat for an interview with me at Poland’s Embassy in Kyiv this week.
asserted
Sikorski → sit → Kyiv
Sikorski had arrived in Ukraine as Russia was pushing the war closer to his country.
asserted
Russia → arrive → country
Russia has intensified strikes on the Ukrainian side of the Polish border, increasingly targeting the railways, roads, and crossings connecting Ukraine to the rest of Europe.
asserted
Russia → intensify → Europe
Last Sunday, a Russian drone struck a Kyiv-Warsaw passenger train at a station roughly 1.5 miles from Poland.
asserted
drone → strike → Poland
A diplomatic train carrying former British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, former Swedish Prime Minister Carl Bildt, and European security officials had passed through shortly before the attack, and former CIA Director David Petraeus was still at the station aboard another train.
asserted
Petraeus → carry → train
By Friday, Polish officials said Russia had attacked four Ukrainian border crossings in a week.
asserted
Russia → say → week
But Ukraine, Sikorski argues, remains one of the most cost-effective barriers against further Russian aggression.
asserted
Sikorski → argue → aggression
But the war with Iran has further depleted U.S. stocks of Patriot air defense interceptors, which Europe cannot yet produce, and Ukraine urgently needs to protect its cities, leading to an increasing free fall of Russia’s ballistic missiles onto the country.
asserted
Ukraine → deplete → country
“Ideally, Ukraine, a victim of aggression, should be given [increased] military assistance.
asserted
Ukraine → give → assistance
Every time a Ukrainian [Patriot system] shoots down a Russian ballistic missile, the algorithm of the Patriot system is improved,” he said.
asserted
he → shoot → system
“It’s improving America’s future capacity to defend itself.
asserted
It → improve → itself
And Ukraine is a very cost-efficient way of deterring Putin from further aggression.”
asserted
Ukraine → deter → aggression
Europe’s response has grown, but Warsaw does not share France’s view that European military power should be increasingly independent of America.
asserted
power → grow → America
Referencing French President Emmanuel Macron’s “strategic autonomy” narrative, Sikorski observed, “I don’t like that term, strategic autonomy, because that suggests some kind of decoupling.
uncertain
that → reference → decoupling
I prefer the term strategic harmony, with the U.S. having global responsibilities and Europe catching up after too long a period of consuming the peace dividend.”
asserted
Europe → prefer → dividend
Sikorski’s preferred division of labor would require Europe to provide most of the conventional forces needed to defend the continent, while the United States provided the other capabilities European militaries cannot quickly reproduce.
asserted
militaries → require → capabilities
Those include the American nuclear umbrella, aerial refueling, intelligence, and targeting.
asserted
Those → include → umbrella
“It would be less American presence in the conventional field, but still maintaining key enablers, not just the nuclear umbrella, but also midair refueling and targeting,” Sikorski said.
asserted
Sikorski → maintain → enablers
“Europe would provide conventional defense, the U.S. would provide what Europe doesn’t have, and together we can successfully deter.”
asserted
we → provide → what
Poland certainly cannot be accused of freeloading in NATO.
asserted
Poland → accuse → NATO
The country plans to spend about 4.8% of its gross domestic product on defense in 2026, the highest share among major NATO members.
asserted
country → plan → members
Poland has also provided immense support to Ukraine.
asserted
Poland → provide → Ukraine
Along with solidarity, however, Warsaw’s support rests in strategic calculation: If Ukraine falls, Poland may be next.
uncertain
Poland → rest → calculation
“The closer you are to Russia, the bigger the defense budgets,” Sikorski said when asked whether Western Europe had fundamentally changed its view of Moscow.
asserted
Europe → say → Moscow
He acknowledged that it had taken Germany time to overcome its “pacifist instincts,” but said it had since become one of Ukraine’s largest supporters.
asserted
it → acknowledge → supporters
“[Russian president Vladimir] Putin makes a mistake when he attacks Germany, Britain, and others, because he proves that it’s not an East European problem,” Sikorski said.
asserted
Sikorski → make → Germany
“It’s an all-of-Europe problem.”
asserted
It → ’ → Europe
The shared threat has not erased tensions between Warsaw and Kyiv.
asserted
threat → share → Warsaw
Relations deteriorated after President Volodymyr Zelenskyy named a Ukrainian military unit after the Ukrainian Insurgent Army, which Poland holds responsible for massacring Polish civilians during the Second World War.
asserted
Poland → deteriorate → War
Prime Minister Donald Tusk warned that allowing the historical dispute to divide two countries threatened by Russia would serve Moscow’s interests.
asserted
dispute → warn → interests
Geography, however, leaves Warsaw and Kyiv little room for a lasting rupture.
asserted
Geography → leave → rupture
This week, Tusk has warned that Russia may send drones or missiles into countries supporting Ukraine and present the strikes as accidents to test whether NATO members agree on what constitutes an attack and how they should respond.
uncertain
they → warn → attack
The same uncertainty hangs over future security guarantees for Ukraine.
asserted
uncertainty → hang → Ukraine
Washington’s envoys continue talks with Putin, but a settlement remains distant.
asserted
settlement → continue → Putin
Moreover, Ukraine’s Western partners have yet to agree on what meaningful security guarantees would look like or how they would be enforced if Russia attacked again.
asserted
Russia → have → what
Ideas have ranged from deploying European troops after a ceasefire to offering Ukraine an Article 5-style commitment without NATO membership.
asserted
Ideas → range → membership
But a secure Ukraine capable of deterring another invasion runs against the Kremlin’s objectives, while Washington has yet to reach a consensus on how far it is prepared to go.
asserted
it → deter → consensus
“What the American role could be in providing such guarantees, you tell me,” Sikorski noted.
uncertain
Sikorski → provide → me
The Aporia
