Claims extracted
18
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
22%
4 of 18 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
Leans left
of the writing, not the subject · beta estimate
Publisher signals
69/100
Daily Mail's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
2
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
The head of MI5 should be held in contempt of court after spies lied to judges about a violent neo-Nazi agent, a court has heard.
asserted
court → see → agent
Sir Ken McCallum faces the prospect of contempt proceedings after MI5 accepted it had provided false evidence to three courts about a neo-Nazi informant who exploited his role with the agency to violently threaten his girlfriend.
asserted
who → face → girlfriend
The woman, known only as Beth, claims that she was abused by the agent who attacked her with a machete and used his status to terrorise her into silence.
uncertain
who → know → silence
She complained to the watchdog overseeing MI5 about the spy, known as X, who was being used by MI5 to infiltrate the far-Right.
asserted
who → complain → Right
In July, Deputy Investigatory Powers Commissioner Sir John Goldring found 'serious and systemic failings' by MI5 in the case, concluding that one senior officer lied repeatedly while another misled his colleagues and lied about what he was told about the case.
asserted
he → find → case
When the BBC sought to expose the abuse, MI5 initially confirmed that agent X was an informant in order to dissuade a journalist from running the story as they feared X's life could be in danger.
But later in court proceedings with Beth and the BBC, the agency would only say in public that it could 'neither confirm nor deny' its relationship with him, in line with standard policy.
uncertain
it → seek → policy
In an unprecedented move, MI5 has since paid compensation and issued a public apology to settle the case.
asserted
MI5 → pay → case
Lawyers representing a victim known as 'Beth' are urging the High Court to hold MI5 Director-General Sir Ken McCallum (pictured) and individual security officers in contempt of court
The intelligence agency repeatedly provided false evidence to conceal the actions of a violent neo-Nazi informant
The identity of agent X, a foreign national involved in neo-Nazi movements, remains unknown and he is understood to have left the UK.
asserted
he → represent → UK
Now lawyers for Beth want the director-general of MI5 and the individual officers concerned to face contempt of court proceedings.
asserted
general → want → proceedings
Anyone found to be in contempt can receive a prison sentence of up to two years, or a fine.
asserted
Anyone → find → years
Charlotte Kilroy, KC, representing Beth, said in written submissions in the High Court that the false evidence did not emanate from one individual or a 'bad apple' but was 'sustained and long-lasting'.
'
asserted
evidence → represent → individual
There have been repeated efforts to prevent the truth emerging.
asserted
truth → repeat → ?
The reality of the dishonesty and false evidence that has taken place has only emerged because MI5 was faced with incontrovertible proof of its wrongdoing.
asserted
MI5 → take → wrongdoing
Ms Kilroy claimed that an MI5 officer 'knew that his dishonesty was likely to result in an interference with the administration of justice', and others who knew
of the false evidence 'either did not take steps to ensure correct evidence was given, or when they did tell their superiors the truth, the information they provided was ignored'.
asserted
they → claim → truth
She said there was 'strong and cogent evidence' that MI5 officers may have committed contempt, and that the service 'benefited from the dishonesty of its officers'.
uncertain
service → say → officers
But Tim Otty, KC, representing MI5, said there was 'no basis' to hold Sir Ken vicariously liable, adding that there was no 'strong case' that MI5 could be corporately liable in criminal contempt proceedings.
uncertain
MI5 → represent → proceedings
He said the spy agency was fully committed to making changes, but that it was 'not now necessary or appropriate to proceed with contempt proceedings'.
asserted
it → say → proceedings
The three High Court judges said they would hand down their judgment on the case at a later date.
asserted
they → say → date
The Aporia
