Biological males who identify as women can access BreastCheck after taking feminising hormones for more than five years, a response to a parliamentary question has revealed.
asserted
response → identify → question
In response to a question from Independent TD Carol Nolan, the head of the breast cancer screening service said that ‘people who are transgender, non-binary or intersex can take part in screening if they were registered male at birth and have been taking feminising hormones for more than five years and have breasts or female breast tissue’.
asserted
they → say → breasts
Fiona Murphy, chief of the National Screening Service, said it was committed to ‘ensuring that BreastCheck is accessible to everyone who needs it’.
asserted
who → say → it
She said the service had carried out a comprehensive review of breast cancer risk and screening recommendations for transgender, non-binary and intersex people, including a review of clinical evidence and international guidelines.
asserted
service → say → evidence
Ms Murphy said BreastCheck teams had received transgender, non-binary and intersex awareness training and the service had consulted LGBTQI+ organisations and community members.
asserted
service → say → organisations
On gender recognition certificates, she said the register was compiled using information supplied periodically by the Department of Social Protection.
asserted
register → say → Protection
Ms Murphy said: ‘If someone has a gender recognition certificate and we have not received their details from the Department of Social Protection yet, they will not automatically be invited for screening.
‘
asserted
they → say → screening
In this case they can contact us, and we can add them to the register or update their details.’
asserted
we → contact → details
In the NHS in Britain, transgender women and non-binary people assigned male at birth are invited for breast screening every three years from the age of 50.
asserted
women → assign → 50
The American College of Radiology noted last year that while transgender women have a smaller chance of getting breast cancer than biological females, their risk is higher than men.
asserted
risk → note → men
They recommended that trans women who have been using feminising hormones for at least five years and are over 40 may benefit from an annual mammogram.
uncertain
who → recommend → mammogram
However, Ms Nolan said the HSE’s policy represents a ‘pattern of systemic erasure of biological reality within women’s health services’.
asserted
policy → say → services
She said: ‘BreastCheck has confirmed to me that it does not differentiate participants on the basis of gender identity and that its register does not identify whether someone has obtained a gender recognition certificate.
‘
asserted
someone → say → certificate
In other words, the programme has been redesigned to treat biological sex as irrelevant even though breast cancer risk is overwhelmingly sex-based.’
asserted
risk → redesign → sex
Ms Nolan said the latest information showed BreastCheck was operating under guidance that ‘blurs biological categories’ and allows biological males into a screening programme designed for women aged 50 to 69.
asserted
that → say → women
She said: ‘This is institutional capture.
asserted
This → say → ?
Women’s healthcare is being reshaped around gender ideology rather than biological fact and the consequences are becoming impossible to ignore.’
asserted
consequences → reshape → ideology
BreastCheck is the national screening programme and screens women aged 50 to 69 who have no symptoms of breast cancer with the aim of detecting and treating the disease at the earliest possible stage.
asserted
who → screen → stage
BreastCheck is the national screening programme and screens women aged 50 to 69 who have no symptoms of breast cancer with the aim of detecting and treating the disease at the earliest possible stage
The service covers 54 local areas using 24 mobile screening units and four permanent clinics.
asserted
service → screen → units
However, concerns have grown over BreastCheck’s ability to meet its screening targets.
asserted
concerns → grow → targets
A parliamentary question from Peadar Tóibín indicated that in 2024 the service fell significantly short of its target of 195,000 people screened, carrying out 137,134 checks.
asserted
service → indicate → checks
In 2023, the target was 185,000 – 166,532 checks were carried out.
asserted
checks → carry → 2023
Ms Murphy previously told RTÉ Radio One’s Today show that a global shortage of radiographers and radiologists was one factor behind the shortfall, with recruitment ‘particularly difficult’ in Europe.
asserted
recruitment → tell → Europe
Acknowledging the pressures facing the service, Ms Nolan said this made it all the more important that BreastCheck remained focused on its core purpose.
asserted
BreastCheck → acknowledge → purpose
She said: ‘Yes, workforce shortages are a global issue and I accept what BreastCheck’s own CEO has acknowledged regarding the difficulty in recruiting radiographers and radiologists.
asserted
CEO → say → radiographers
‘But to my mind that makes it even more important that the programme stays tightly focused.
asserted
programme → make → mind
‘BreastCheck was created with a clear mission to deliver timely, high-quality screening for biological women.
asserted
BreastCheck → create → women
So, when a service is struggling to meet its core targets, the last thing it needs is policy drift or ideological expansion that distracts from that original purpose.
asserted
that → struggle → purpose
'If BreastCheck cannot meet its basic screening commitments, then every decision that complicates or broadens eligibility has to be questioned.
asserted
that → meet → eligibility
‘The priority must be restoring capacity, not reshaping the programme around contested ideological frameworks.’
asserted
priority → restore → frameworks
Ms Nolan said the policy was all the more alarming given recent reporting about males being aided to lactate.
asserted
policy → say → males
Ms Nolan said the policy was all the more alarming given recent reporting about males being aided to lactate
She said: ‘This policy cannot be divorced from the wider controversy surrounding so‑called “male lactation” and the recent Association of Lactation Consultants in Ireland (ALCI) issue.’
asserted
policy → say → Ireland
Ms Nolan was referring to the revelation that figures within the ALCI, an organisation with links to the HSE, had platformed a speaker promoting male lactation.
asserted
figures → refer → lactation
She said: ‘This has provoked widespread public outrage and serious safeguarding concerns.’
asserted
This → say → outrage
Responding to a request for comment the HSE denied there were any waiting lists for BreastCheck.
asserted
HSE → respond → BreastCheck
A spokesman said: ‘Women are not on a waiting list.
asserted
Women → say → list
The timing of this appointment relates to when the mobile unit is next due in the area.
asserted
unit → relate → area
Most women (seven in ten) are screened within the target time of two years of their last appointment, or from when they become eligible.
asserted
they → screen → appointment
‘BreastCheck is accessible to everyone who needs it.
asserted
who → need → it
We record the number of eligible people and the number we screen.
asserted
we → record → people
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
