In New York, the United Nations General Assembly is gearing up for its big annual session, starting on Tuesday.
asserted
Assembly → gear → Tuesday
Which foreign leader will the United States prevent from attending (last time it was Mahmoud Abbas of the Palestinian Authority) along with the judges it has blacklisted from the UN’s International Criminal Court?
asserted
it → prevent → Court
Benjamin Netanyahu is always made welcome, but this year might he be arrested by order of the city’s new Muslim mayor, Zohran Mamdani?
uncertain
he → make → mayor
Will Vladimir Putin, the truly evil emperor responsible for over half a million deaths, have the effrontery to attend an organisation with a UN Charter purpose to “end the scourge of war”?
asserted
Putin → have → war
At a Chatham House seminar last week on the subject “what is the UN good for?”, the most agreed answer was to run the Universal Postal Union.
asserted
answer → agree → Union
In this regard, it is an abject failure as its Security Council watches passively while hundreds of thousands of civilians are killed by bombs, drones and bullets in the 56 armed conflicts (involving fighting by 92 UN member states) currently being waged across the world.
asserted
hundreds → watch → world
The design of the international order, which dates back to 1945, leaves the General Assembly as not much more than a talking shop with actual power reserved to the Security Council and, in reality, to its five permanent members which can veto any action that it should take.
asserted
it → date → that
The council is now, and for the foreseeable future, pole-axed: Russia vetoes any resolution for a ceasefire in Ukraine, just as China will veto any attempt to stop a possible invasion of Taiwan; and the US, on behalf of Israel, has vetoed various actions in relation to Gaza (although, at Trump’s insistence, it has rubber-stamped his “Board of Peace”, notwithstanding the unlikelihood of it ever living up to its name).
asserted
it → ax → name
For other deadly conflicts where the identity of the aggressor is clear – Myanmar, Sudan, the Congo and so on – the Security Council does nothing.
asserted
Council → do → nothing
Scholars and diplomats have for years urged reform: limiting or abolishing the veto, expanding the number of non-permanent members, strengthening the role of the General Assembly – but to no avail.
asserted
Scholars → urge → avail
The “Big Five” – Russia, the US, China, the United Kingdom and France – will never surrender their veto power voluntarily and will use it to stop any reform that might undermine it.
uncertain
that → surrender → it
Many nations favour at least one change – to stop the veto being used to prevent action in relation to atrocities – but this has been rejected by the “Big Three”, the US China and Russia.
asserted
this → favour → Three
The other blind spot is that the UN, and the international law that it supports, does nothing to protect democracy.
asserted
it → support → democracy
The very word is not mentioned in its charter and the two authoritarian permanent members will keep it that way, so the UN can do nothing when democratic governments are invaded or overthrown.
asserted
governments → mention → nothing
There has been talk, ever since former US secretary of state Madeleine Albright started it, of a “coalition of democracies” – 40 European countries plus 56 from the Commonwealth and Brazil, Japan and others.
asserted
Albright → start → Commonwealth
But the weak link is the Commonwealth, which has had no effective presence in the world since it led the fight against apartheid in the 1960s.
asserted
it → have → 1960s
The agenda for the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting, in Antigua this November, is full of happy-clappy talk about the virtues of cricket and “investment for a prosperous Commonwealth”, but not for taking any political action for peace.
asserted
agenda → take → peace
So the UN remains the best we can do for this purpose.
asserted
we → remain → purpose
It will need a new leader.
asserted
It → need → leader
The dogged but defeated Antonio Guterres retires in December.
asserted
Guterres → defeat → December
The UN lacks any proper system for appointing its leader, who is decided in secret by the Security Council and rubber-stamped by the General Assembly.
asserted
who → lack → Assembly
If an inspirational leader was sought, most nations would probably vote to bring back Barack Obama, but he is excluded on many grounds, not least because of the general agreement that the next secretary-general should at long last be a woman.
asserted
general → seek → agreement
The likelihood is that it will come down to a lowest-common-denominator choice of a diplomat from that continent unlikely to ruffle the feathers of any of the Big Three.
asserted
it → come → Three
There is a looming practical difficulty caused by the Trump administration’s tendency to deny visas to leaders they do not like, such as Abbas, and judges and lawyers of the ICC who need to enter America to report to the UN.
asserted
who → be → UN
The organisation cannot function properly if its officials are banned from access to its iconic building beside the Hudson River on land donated to it by Nelson Rockefeller (which the UN could sell – perhaps to Trump himself – for more than its unpaid US contributions).
uncertain
UN → function → contributions
Many countries are asking whether now is the time for it to find a new headquarters.
asserted
it → ask → headquarters
Emmanuel Macron will make his swansong at the General Assembly this year, and may well offer a palace in Paris, where the UN began and had its most memorable moments (such as on December 10, 1948, when Eleanor Roosevelt presented the Universal Declaration of Human Rights to the president of the General Assembly, Dr H V Evatt, who would become Australia’s Labor opposition leader).
uncertain
who → make → Assembly
Nations in favour of moving the UN headquarters away from New York have been clear that its new location should be in the Global South.
asserted
location → move → South
Could we offer Melbourne?
uncertain
we → offer → Melbourne
It may not have an opera house – a requirement for any city that takes itself seriously – but it would inject some tourists and cosmopolitan life to the nation’s biggest metropolis.
uncertain
it → have → metropolis
The UN would be safe with a federal government and a people who support its values – in ways that the American government certainly does not.
asserted
government → support → ways
Get a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own.
asserted
that → get → own
The Aporia
