About two years ago, education entrepreneur Boris But had what he calls a “penny-drop moment” – that, like countless others in China, his company needed to embrace AI before it was made obsolete by it.
asserted
it → have → it
His clients, well-off parents looking to send their children to study overseas, had begun arriving in his office reeling off information and opinions gleaned not from rival firms, but from chatbots.
asserted
clients → look → chatbots
In response, he started developing his own AI study tool, concluding: “If you can’t beat them, join them.”
asserted
you → start → them
The pace and quality of AI development in China is second only to the United States, with the two superpowers locked in an intensifying rivalry as the stakes rise with each new model’s capabilities.
asserted
stakes → lock → capabilities
Analysts generally agree that frontier, or cutting-edge, US models are still some way ahead of their Chinese counterparts.
asserted
models → agree → counterparts
But over the last few weeks the mood music from Silicon Valley has been decidedly sombre, as insider after insider has warned of the potential catastrophes that could result from “loss of control” of the most advanced AIs.
uncertain
that → warn → AIs
And last Saturday Anthropic chief executive Dario Amodei pitched a “worldwide pacing of the frontier” – something he said would “require cooperation with China”.
asserted
he → pitch → China
“China is definitely not receptive” to a slowdown on US firms’ terms, though, said Lian Jye Su from technology research group Omdia.
asserted
Su → say → Omdia
For the government, AI is a “core sovereignty capability”, and Beijing will not want to jeopardise the progress made in closing the gap with US frontier models.
asserted
Beijing → want → models
“It sees these calls [for a slowdown] as a bid to lock in US advantage,” said Su.
asserted
Su → see → advantage
Amodei made this explicit, mentioning China specifically when arguing it was key “to keep democracies’ AI lead over autocracies as large as possible”.
asserted
it → make → autocracies
He advocated for measures including continued export controls to China on advanced chips and machinery – the existence of which some argue already amounts to a forced unilateral “pacing”.
asserted
some → advocate → pacing
China’s foreign ministry responded to Amodei’s piece by saying “fearmongering, confrontation and vicious competition will only disrupt the process of global AI governance”.
asserted
fearmongering → respond → governance
However, several analysts told the Guardian it would be a mistake to assume this suggested a rejection of the broader concerns raised by the essay.
uncertain
this → tell → essay
This week China released the third iteration of its AI safety governance framework – a document that functions as a “mapping of the AI risk landscape and roughly what one should do about it”, said Gabriel Wagner, a researcher at Concordia, a Beijing-based AI safety consultancy.
asserted
Wagner → release → Concordia
Included in the updates are the risks posed by agents, the cybersecurity threats from frontier models and the issue of recursive self-improvement – an as-yet hypothetical scenario where AI becomes advanced enough to improve itself.
asserted
AI → include → itself
“In many ways, I think there is more common ground than people might assume between what Amodei is saying and what the Chinese government is saying,” said Wagner.
uncertain
Wagner → think → what
That contrasts with US president Donald Trump, who this week called fears AI could wipe out humanity a “hoax”.
uncertain
AI → contrast → humanity
Trump is set to meet counterpart Xi Jinping in Washington next week, with AI expected to make the agenda, though analysts are sceptical a major breakthrough will happen.
asserted
breakthrough → set → agenda
The ruling Communist party, finely attuned to risks to its political control, has been proactive in ensuring the new technology has developed within boundaries set by the state.
asserted
technology → rule → state
Centralised authority over critical infrastructure and commercial activity means China is generally better placed than the United States “to address any AI disaster”, said Omdia’s Su.
asserted
Su → mean → disaster
However, Chinese companies do less voluntary monitoring and evaluation work than US ones, said Leia Wang from the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace (CEIP).
asserted
Wang → do → Peace
Neither government seems prepared for a loss-of-control incident like those outlined over the last few weeks, she said.
asserted
she → seem → weeks
China’s regulation, though, is “iterative … they are quick to adapt and release new measures”, she added.
asserted
she → adapt → measures
China has had an algorithm registry since 2022, but warnings on agents released this year suggest a switch in focus “from controlling what AI says to controlling what it does”, per Concordia AI.
asserted
it → have → AI
Beijing also issued national regulations this year aimed at curbing emotional dependency on companion AIs.
asserted
Beijing → issue → AIs
At the same time, AI is being actively encouraged across the economy to promote growth, enshrining this goal in its latest Five Year Plan.
asserted
AI → encourage → Plan
Local governments are offering funding and low rents to companies to help achieve this – entrepreneur But was recently invited to pitch his company, Hampshire Education, to a small city three hours from Shanghai set on establishing a reputation as a tech hub.
asserted
But → offer → hub
Factories across the country’s huge manufacturing base are being encouraged to convert their processes into the AI era.
asserted
Factories → encourage → era
“Safety and controllability are certainly major concerns, and they are actively discussed,” said a spokesperson for Black Lake Technologies, an industrial agent platform that says it has worked with 40,000 factories globally.
asserted
it → discuss → factories
“But in manufacturing, these concerns tend to be much more concrete and operational … what companies care most about is whether the AI is reliable.”
asserted
AI → tend → what
Daily life in China is already highly digitised, with traditionally less discourse around data privacy helping with widespread adoption.
asserted
discourse → digitise → adoption
For example, digital health service A-fu, which features AI chatbot versions of prominent doctors trained on real clinical studies, recently hit 150 million users.
asserted
which → feature → users
“Most people treat AI as an already-useful everyday tool, not an abstract threat, so the practical attitude is to live with it,” said Ni Tao, founding editor of tech website yangtzeer.com.
asserted
Tao → treat → yangtzeer.com
“There is real anxiety about jobs and misinformation, but it coexists with a strong belief that China must master AI rather than slow down.”
asserted
China → be → AI
The Aporia
