Schools are being pushed to curb classroom screen time amid increasing student anxiety and declining test scores, but experts warn that hasty bans could undo the benefits of teaching with tech.
uncertain
bans → push → tech
NSW has announced plans to follow Victoria’s lead in capping students’ screen time, after federal Education Minister Jason Clare called for a digital detox in response to declining maths scores and literacy comprehension.
St Catherine’s School in Toorak kept year 7 students off laptops for the first six weeks of term one, a trial that principal Natalie Charles said had “extraordinary” results.
“We know that students flourish when they’re in relationship with each other, and they’re in relationships with the teacher,” Charles said.
asserted
Charles → announce → teacher
Australian year 9 students recorded their lowest maths and reading scores since testing began more than 20 years ago in the recent Program for International Student Assessment (PISA).
asserted
testing → record → Assessment
Their results, which ranked them about two years behind Australian students from two decades ago, echoed a global decline, especially among Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development countries.
asserted
which → rank → countries
As academic results have declined, reports of mental health issues among Australian students have risen – a trend policymakers have linked to increased time online.
asserted
policymakers → decline → time
The delayed laptop rollout at St Catherine’s will extend to year 8 next year.
asserted
rollout → delay → year
The initiative was informed by a partnership with the University of Queensland, which warned of heightened anxiety during the transition to secondary school, rather than declining academic results.
asserted
which → inform → results
Charles said she would consider extending the trial beyond six weeks if it weren’t for online NAPLAN testing in March, which Clare has signalled could return to pen and paper.
uncertain
Clare → say → pen
The St Catherine’s principal said she believed society would have “deep regret” over the decision to put devices in children’s hands over a decade ago “with very little thought for the impact that it might have”.
uncertain
it → say → that
“Now the work of schools, and of families, is holding the line in many respects and saying … ‘Is this tool at this particular time in the child’s life the best thing to see them flourish?’” she said.
St Catherine’s is not alone: boys’ school Sydney Grammar, Toorak College, Castlemaine Secondary College and Traralgon College have all reportedly taken steps to curb device use.
uncertain
school → hold → use
While private schools set their own policies, state primary schools in Victoria will be barred from asking parents to buy their own devices from next year, scrapping a previous policy that let schools decide.
asserted
schools → set → policy
State school pupils in years 3 to 6 will also be restricted to 90 minutes of screen time a day from next year, while pupils in prep to year 2 will have minimal exposure to devices.
asserted
pupils → restrict → devices
Teachers at state secondary schools will be required to plan device-free learning, although time limits won’t be enforced.
asserted
limits → require → learning
Dr Jared Cooney Horvath, a neuroscientist and author of the book The Digital Delusion, about the impact of digital tools on learning, said secondary schools should also scrap personal devices and reintroduce computer labs to make tech use more “deliberate”.
asserted
use → say → labs
Horvath, a prominent critic of digital devices in schools, met with the federal education minister during a visit from his home in the United States this week.
asserted
Horvath → meet → States
In Victoria, his visit took in state schools to discuss the revised education framework and Melbourne Archdiocese Catholic Schools to discuss AI and “why digital technology doesn’t align well with human learning”.
asserted
technology → take → learning
Speaking to this masthead, Horvath said humans were built to learn from other humans, partly because we resonate with others.
asserted
we → speak → others
“I can watch somebody do something and learn as though I was doing that thing.
asserted
I → watch → thing
I can have somebody explain something to me, and I can learn as though I were performing it.
asserted
I → have → it
You cannot, unfortunately, resonate with tech,” he said.
asserted
he → resonate → tech
Horvath said learning from tech was often more surface-level, and we “tap out” as soon as it gets difficult.
asserted
it → say → tech
“And to make matters worse, screens will also cut that synchrony between people,” he said.
asserted
he → make → people
“In a classroom, even if a teacher and student are resonating, as soon as the kid pulls out a screen to take notes or to access a reading, that resonance is now gone, and learning is going to go down.”
asserted
learning → resonate → reading
Horvath said memory worked best when words were static on paper, rather than moving as they do when students scroll on a screen.
asserted
students → say → screen
“This is why in schools where you do nothing different but print out your readings again, go back to a hard-copy textbook versus a screen, learning will go up because now you’re playing kind of a memory game,” he said.
asserted
he → do → game
In 2020, Victoria was the first state to ban mobile phones in public school classrooms.
asserted
Victoria → ban → classrooms
The same year, the Andrews government signed a deal with Microsoft to give government students access to a broad range of software, including Minecraft: Education Edition.
asserted
government → sign → Minecraft
The computer game, in which players are immersed in Minecraft worlds, has been used in classrooms ever since.
asserted
players → immerse → classrooms
Horvath said research showed that when learning is “gamified”, children focus on the game, not the lesson.
asserted
children → say → game
“The content of the game is basically secondary,” he said.
asserted
he → say → game
“They don’t learn a lot.”
asserted
They → learn → lot
Victoria’s mobile phone ban will be extended to include smartwatches and wireless earphones from next year.
asserted
ban → extend → year
Private schools will also ban the devices from next year.
asserted
schools → ban → year
Victorian Education Minister Gabrielle Williams said digital learning had its place in schools but classrooms “should be run by our teachers – not screens”.
asserted
classrooms → say → teachers
Since last December, when Horvath published The Digital Delusion, a book often referenced by advocates of limiting students’ tech use in Australia, the US states with proposed bills to limit classroom screen time have grown from three to 31.
asserted
states → publish → 31
In June, Norway announced it was diverting state school funding from personal devices to textbooks, following a similar move in Sweden, and phone bans are becoming more widespread worldwide.
asserted
bans → announce → Sweden
Professor Therese Hopfenbeck, the head of the University of Melbourne’s School of Learning Science, said policymakers in Norway, where the debate is heated, are looking at the restrictions being introduced in Australia.
asserted
debate → say → Australia
Hopfenbeck, the international chair of PISA 2025 and part of the expert group that develops the assessment program’s questions about teenagers’ use of devices in the classroom, said it was not as simple as throwing out the devices and watching the results improve.
asserted
results → develop → devices
She said there wasn’t enough evidence to conclude that banning devices in classrooms would improve learning.
asserted
banning → say → learning
“There are results also suggesting that if you’re able to use the device in a very productive way, at the right time, students can actually learn from them,” Hopfenbeck said.
asserted
Hopfenbeck → be → them
…and 18 more, not listed.
The Aporia
