Freshman Rep. Bob Bresnahan (R-PA) touted President Donald Trump’s executive order aimed at ending a controversial “rain tax” on his constituents as a major win in his key swing district.
asserted
Bresnahan → tout → district
He said in an interview with the Washington Examiner that his 8th District will see tax relief thanks to the order, signed this week, which reversed an Obama-era executive order that pressured states and local governments to fund restoration and protection projects for the Chesapeake Bay — funding requirements that ultimately trickled down to homeowners.
asserted
that → say → homeowners
Since 2019, residents in Luzerne and Lackawanna counties have been paying an additional tax each quarter on rainwater that collects on their sidewalks, driveways, rooftops, stone pathways, and other surfaces on their property deemed impervious.
asserted
that → pay → property
The larger those surfaces are, the higher that quarterly fee floats for each taxpayer.
asserted
fee → float → taxpayer
Trump issued an executive order rescinding the rules on Wednesday, paving the way for such “rain taxes” to be lifted.
asserted
taxes → issue → way
Bresnahan has been working throughout his first term in Congress to reverse the tax, which he says has been unfairly imposed on his constituents for nearly 10 years, as the funds were dedicated to restoring the Chesapeake Bay, over 200 miles from his district.
asserted
funds → work → district
He told the Washington Examiner that most of his constituents don’t understand why they have been taxed for a project that is far removed from life in Northeastern Pennsylvania.
asserted
that → tell → Pennsylvania
“Instead of those dollars going to fix our roads or support local police or fire departments, all that money goes to meet pollution requirements aimed at cleaning up the Chesapeake Bay, which is more than 200 miles away from Pennsylvania’s Eighth Congressional District,” the congressman said.
asserted
congressman → go → District
All of this goes back to 2009, when then-President Barack Obama signed an executive order setting the so-called “rain tax” in motion.
asserted
Obama → go → motion
Bresnahan said that the order essentially told federal agencies to ramp up enforcement “dramatically,” putting pressure on states located within the Chesapeake Bay watershed, which stretches from Virginia to New York.
asserted
which → say → York
“With the enforcement came pressure down to our local municipalities, small towns, boroughs, and we’re suddenly on the hook for the strict new requirements,” he said.
asserted
he → come → requirements
Bresnahan, who is up for reelection in a tightly contested congressional district, said that, because the federal mandate was unfunded, watershed localities were forced to increase taxes on homeowners to meet new pollution standards.
asserted
localities → contest → standards
“Those towns had no good options — most were left with only one, and that was passing the bill on to the property owners,” he said.
asserted
he → have → owners
Bresnahan said that one local official he spoke with said that the fines for noncompliance would have been as high as $10,000 per day.
asserted
fines → say → day
And property owners in his district have been facing a rain tax bill ranging from $65 to $2,000 per year.
asserted
owners → face → year
Bresnahan described the effort to get the executive order signed as a “crawl, walk, run” approach.
asserted
order → describe → approach
“I mean, in order to get such a niche executive order that only relates to a very small portion of a congressional district, it was something that when we started working with the Office of Legislative Affairs on day one, this was one of our top priorities,” he said.
asserted
he → mean → priorities
The repeal at the federal level gives control back to the commonwealth and localities, he said.
asserted
he → give → commonwealth
“Instead of having an unfunded mandate coming out of Washington, they can now decide the best way to go about approaching it,” Bresnahan said.
asserted
Bresnahan → have → it
The congressman said that he has fought to secure millions of dollars in federal funding for water, stormwater, and sewer projects across the commonwealth, as well as legislation to modernize those systems.
asserted
he → say → systems
“What I am against is unfunded mandates from Washington and Harrisburg for a program that keeps year after year missing its target,” Bresnahan said.
asserted
Bresnahan → keep → target
Trump’s order has gotten pushback from lawmakers in Virginia and Maryland, which immediately border the Chesapeake Bay.
asserted
which → get → Bay
The full Maryland congressional delegation — which includes conservative House Freedom Caucus Chairman Andy Harris (R-MD) — released a statement on Thursday opposing the move.
asserted
which → include → move
The lawmakers said the Chesapeake Bay is “vital to lives and livelihoods” in Maryland.
asserted
Bay → say → Maryland
They said that Obama’s 2009 executive order provided “vital federal resources” to support the bay and surrounding areas.
asserted
order → say → bay
“Removing the coordinated federal backing that advances the watershed protection and restoration goals of the Chesapeake Bay Watershed Agreement risks undermining the future health of the Bay along with the businesses and communities that depend on it,” the delegation said.
asserted
delegation → remove → it
Make no mistake: the Chesapeake Bay is a national treasure.
asserted
Bay → make → mistake
And we will continue to fight for it.”
asserted
we → continue → it
Both Democratic senators from Virginia, Tim Kaine and Mark Warner, also pushed back on the move.
asserted
senators → push → move
They said the new executive order “dismantles a longstanding framework for coordinating” the effort to restore the Chesapeake Bay.
asserted
order → say → Bay
“Restoring the Chesapeake Bay is critical to the Commonwealth’s seafood and tourism industries, thousands of good-paying jobs, educational opportunities, and Virginians’ recreation,” the two said.
asserted
two → restore → jobs
“Rolling back efforts to clean up the Bay is dangerous not just for our environment but for our economy.
asserted
Rolling → roll → economy
We should be building on the progress we’ve made instead of walking away from a framework that has guided restoration efforts for more than 15 years.”
asserted
that → build → years
Bresnahan said that reversing the 2009 executive order will not eliminate states’ and localities’ abilities to impose similar fees in their regions.
asserted
reversing → say → regions
It also does not immediately end the “rain tax” in Northeastern Pennsylvania.
asserted
It → end → Pennsylvania
Instead, Trump’s new order removes the federal pressure on his constituents who live so far upstream from the Chesapeake Bay.
asserted
who → remove → Bay
“If those fees were going directly to improve the aging infrastructure systems, it would be a different conversation,” the congressman said.
asserted
it → go → systems
“But the reality is, those dollars are being used to clean something up that is 200 miles away.”
asserted
that → use → something
And while most people around the country have never heard of a “rain tax,” Bresnahan said that he hears about it every day on the campaign trail.
asserted
he → hear → trail
He said it all ties back to the “kitchen table issues” that voters care about, especially given concerns about affordability and the cost of living.
asserted
voters → say → living
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia
