Thanks to a settlement with several property owners, a wrecking ball is about to hit one California county's cannabis code-enforcement scheme—a system that piled ruinous fines on people for violations they say they did not actually commit.
asserted
they → hit → violations
Corrine and Doug Thomas, two of the plaintiffs, were staring down more than $1 million in civil penalties.
asserted
Corrine → star → penalties
That came with a twist.
asserted
That → come → twist
Humboldt County, California, said their property's previous owner, Summerville Creek LLC, had been in "violation of the commercial cannabis land use ordinance," had constructed "a building or structure in violation of building, plumbing, and electrical codes," and had "facilities or activities in violation of the commercial cannabis land use ordinance."
asserted
owner → say → ordinance
The Thomases did not understand why that was their problem, having purchased the property once their home in Los Angeles County was destroyed by a wildfire.
asserted
home → understand → wildfire
Nevertheless, they were greeted with the news six days after moving in.
asserted
they → greet → news
Per county policy, fines accrued at $12,000 per day, for up to 90 days—and that included while people waited for the opportunity to have a hearing, which could take years.
uncertain
which → accrue → years
In the couple's case, they had the option to demolish the structure the government had deemed problematic, though that also would have cost them about $180,000, plus fines and fees.
asserted
that → have → 180,000
How was the government getting this information?
asserted
government → get → information
"Code-enforcement officers scour [satellite] images for what looks like unpermitted development on a property (e.g., a greenhouse, a building, a graded flat of land, or trees removed without a permit on record)," attorneys for the Institute for Justice (I.J.) wrote in a petition to the U.S. Supreme Court.
asserted
attorneys → scour → Court
"The County then presumes, without any evidence or further investigation, that the landowner must have developed their property without a permit because they were growing cannabis.
asserted
they → presume → cannabis
In Humboldt's view, there's just no other reason that someone might not buy a permit before building a shed, a barn, or a greenhouse in the rural countryside."
uncertain
someone → be → countryside
I.J. represented several other plaintiffs in the case.
asserted
I.J. → represent → case
One is Blu Graham, who waited four and a half years for a hearing to show he was growing vegetables (as opposed to cannabis) in his greenhouse.
asserted
he → wait → greenhouse
Another is Rhonda Olson, who faced $7.4 million in fines that were addressed to the previous owner on a property she purchased for $60,000.
asserted
she → face → 60,000
The Court declined to hear the petition, which argued the plaintiffs had a Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial in such cases.
asserted
plaintiffs → decline → cases
(They instead had to fight the fines in administrative hearings conducted by the government, where their chances of success were predictably bleak.)
asserted
chances → have → success
But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit kept the suit alive, on the grounds that the plaintiffs plausibly alleged the code enforcement scheme ran afoul of the Eighth Amendment's proscription against excessive fines.
asserted
scheme → keep → fines
After that, the county agreed to settle.
asserted
county → agree → that
Among the conditions of the agreement: In the future, the government must send a warning letter prior to imposing penalties, and provide due process—to include delaying fines until a hearing's conclusion and holding that hearing within 60 days.
asserted
government → send → days
The plaintiffs' fines and fees were also wiped out.
asserted
fines → wipe → ?
The system was likely put in place, at least in part, to allow the county to cash in on cannabis after it was legalized.
asserted
it → put → cannabis
It is part of a broader pattern of local governments leveraging code enforcement to raise revenue.
asserted
governments → leverage → revenue
Sandy Martinez of Lantana, Florida, for example, owes the government over $165,000, plus interest, for such minor code violations as parking on her own grass.
asserted
Martinez → owe → grass
According to the state of Florida, that is not excessive.
uncertain
that → accord → Florida
The Aporia
