The province gave SMU $25M to transform health care.
asserted
province → give → care
Then it quietly killed the plan
Saint Mary's has 'not been able to demonstrate a concrete plan and adequate progress,' province says
It was March 2023 when Nova Scotia's then-advanced education minister appeared at Saint Mary's University, announcing $25 million in funding for the university to revolutionize the province's health-care system.
asserted
minister → kill → system
The money was intended to create health-care data analytics and management programs at the Halifax school, but Brian Wong offered few details on how that funding would lead to better health care.
asserted
funding → intend → care
"We need to come into the modern era as far as data and health care," Wong said at the time.
asserted
Wong → need → time
"We've done it in other sectors many years ago, and it's time that we do it."
asserted
we → do → it
Over the last few years, Saint Mary's created and launched professional development courses, certificates in leadership, management and data analytics, and a master's in applied health sciences.
asserted
Mary → create → sciences
While those programs remain active, provincial officials viewed progress as slow and unsatisfactory, according to documents obtained through freedom of information requests to the university and the province.
uncertain
officials → remain → university
Less than three years after the funding announcement, the province quietly decided early this year that the remaining $11 million of unused funding would not be used to continue the initiative.
asserted
million → decide → initiative
Why the province shut the initiative down
A government document points to two primary reasons — the province's own fiscal constraints and "the fact that [Saint Mary's has] not been able to demonstrate a concrete plan and adequate progress against that plan."
asserted
Mary → shut → plan
Questions about whether the funding was a good use of public money emerged from the start.
asserted
funding → emerge → start
The $25-million grant originated from a university pitch less than a page long that began by highlighting SMU's financial troubles, CBC News revealed in 2024.
asserted
News → originate → 2024
Unlike nearby rival Dalhousie University, Saint Mary's does not have a school of medicine or nursing.
asserted
Mary → have → medicine
In 2024, Wong defended the initiative.
asserted
Wong → defend → initiative
"I'm not focused on a proposal," he said.
asserted
he → focus → proposal
And I know that they're working on it.
asserted
they → know → it
And I'm confident that this will be an important program that will help direct health-care initiatives going forward.
asserted
that → help → initiatives
The province has since changed course.
asserted
province → change → course
"It's the department's role to ensure appropriate oversight and accountability over public funding flowing to our post-secondary institutions.
asserted
It → ensure → institutions
This is an example of where that oversight determined a need to change course," a government document notes.
asserted
document → determine → course
What the university promised
In its pitch for the funding, Saint Mary's committed to several key initiatives, including:
- Developing and offering health-care analytics programming to help workers make data-informed decisions.
- Developing business administration, management and leadership courses for health-care administrators, staff, office directors, family doctors and practitioners.
- Expanding articulation agreements to give Nova Scotia Community College (NSCC) health-care students more options to pursue degrees at Saint Mary's.
asserted
workers → promise → Mary
In provincial evaluations tracking these goals, the word "unsatisfactory" appears eight times on one page of the heavily-redacted documents.
asserted
word → track → documents
"All three of the plans and their progress reports have been found to be unsatisfactory mainly due to the fact that there is still no plan in place to complete the initiative, spend the entirety of the $25M, and progress has been slow overall," a government document states.
asserted
document → find → M
'This is going sideways fast': How Dalhousie scrapped a program's 63% tuition hike
Inside a Halifax university's battle to save face after spending nearly $500K on a football game
Focusing specially on the plan to have new articulation agreements with NSCC, the document states the Department of Advanced Education "does not see any value" in continuing to pursue this.
asserted
Department → go → this
"Given SMU does not offer health education, there is limited if any opportunities for 2+2 offerings with the NSCC," it said.
asserted
it → give → NSCC
"The only real opportunity that may exist is with Health Information Management."
uncertain
that → exist → Management
What SMU is saying
Saint Mary's stands by the initiative.
asserted
Mary → say → initiative
In a statement, Margaret Murphy, the university's associate vice-president of external affairs, said the university worked collaboratively with government and sector partners to support health-sector workforce development in the province.
asserted
university → say → province
"While the Province ultimately concluded that the initiative would not continue in its original form, the university believes important groundwork, program development and partnership activities were undertaken during the period of the agreement," she wrote.
asserted
she → conclude → agreement
"Saint Mary's remains committed to supporting workforce development and responding to the evolving needs of the province through its teaching, research and community partnerships.
asserted
Mary → remain → teaching
"
Saint Mary's, like many Nova Scotia universities, faces financial strain driven by declining international enrolment and stagnant provincial operating grants.
asserted
Mary → face → enrolment
2 N.S. universities say international student permit changes will cost them millions
But the way the deal between the province and Saint Mary's was structured indirectly helped the university with its financial woes.
asserted
deal → say → woes
Saint Mary's received the $25 million upfront and had to place the money in an externally restricted fund, separating it from general revenues so it could only be spent on the designated health-care programs.
uncertain
it → receive → programs
However, the unused money was placed in an interest-bearing account, and that interest could be used for other expenses.
uncertain
interest → place → expenses
Murphy confirmed the interest over the life of the initiative worked out to about $3.5 million and was used for student financial aid.
asserted
interest → confirm → aid
By early this year, roughly $11 million remained unspent.
asserted
million → remain → year
Around budget time, the province proposed allowing Saint Mary's to keep the unspent funds on the condition that this year's operating grant be reduced by an equivalent amount — a deal the university accepted.
asserted
university → propose → amount
"While some work has been completed, SMU has been unable to provide a satisfactory plan to the department for the remaining unspent funding," a government document notes.
asserted
document → complete → funding
The Aporia
