Most Indians know the parable of several blind men trying to describe an elephant.
asserted
Indians → know → elephant
One touches its trunk and believes it is a snake.
asserted
it → touch → trunk
Another feels its leg and insists it is a pillar.
asserted
it → feel → leg
None is entirely wrong, yet none sees the whole animal.
asserted
none → see → animal
India’s strategy for advancing its cutting-edge technologies, aimed at becoming a global manufacturing leader, carries the risk of making a similar mistake.
asserted
strategy → advance → mistake
From EV motors and semiconductor fabrication facilities to precision manufacturing machineries, at the heart of each lies an unassuming component: the high-performance permanent magnet.
asserted
component → lie → each
They serve as the silent operating system of industrial acceleration.
asserted
They → serve → acceleration
Ferrite, Alnico and Samarium-Cobalt magnets continue to serve important industrial applications.
asserted
magnets → continue → applications
Yet Neodymium-Iron-Boron (NdFeB) magnets have become the backbone of energy transition and advanced manufacturing because no other commercially available permanent magnet combines comparable magnetic strength with such a high power-to-weight ratio.
asserted
magnet → become → ratio
Recognising its importance, India has begun strengthening its critical minerals and rare earth element strategy through initiatives such as the National Critical Mineral Mission, overseas mineral acquisitions, expanded geological exploration, and PLI schemes.
asserted
India → recognise → Mission
However, China’s tight export controls on rare-earth magnets and materials in April 2025 not only revealed the deep-seated vulnerabilities in global industrial value chains, but also the limits of our understanding.
asserted
controls → reveal → understanding
For India, the primary vulnerability does not stem from a shortage of critical minerals; rather, it lies in the absence of a comprehensive framework to pinpoint where strategic technological dependence is cultivated, accumulated and propagated throughout the permanent magnet value chain.
asserted
dependence → stem → chain
The journey of a magnet
Consider a simple example.
asserted
journey → consider → example
India’s Annual Survey of Industries estimates the domestic permanent magnet market at around ₹750 crore.
asserted
Survey → estimate → crore
Yet international trade statistics indicate import values several times larger than that entire reported market.
asserted
statistics → indicate → market
The gap may reflect differences in statistical coverage, industrial classification or supply-chain accounting.
uncertain
gap → reflect → coverage
Whatever the explanation, policymakers face a troubling reality: they cannot confidently explain where all these magnets enter the economy or how they move through it.
asserted
they → face → it
In other words, parts of India’s permanent magnet economy appear to exist without being fully visible in statistics.
asserted
parts → appear → statistics
Also read: Reliance, Vedanta, Adani join India’s drive to cut China rare earth dependence
Unlike other products, permanent magnets pass through a long technological journey.
asserted
magnets → read → journey
Geological exploration leads to mining.
asserted
exploration → lead → mining
Mining feeds mineral processing.
asserted
Mining → feed → processing
Processing enables chemical separation.
asserted
Processing → enable → separation
Separation produces oxides, which are refined into metals, transformed into alloys, engineered into magnetic materials, and finally manufactured into finished magnets.
asserted
which → produce → magnets
Each stage demands different scientific knowledge, industrial capability and technological maturity.
asserted
stage → demand → knowledge
This is why discussions on critical minerals frequently miss the real point.
asserted
discussions → miss → point
The strategic question is not simply whether India possesses rare-earth resources or whether imports from China can be reduced.
asserted
imports → possess → China
The real policy challenge is understanding what happens in between.
asserted
what → understand → ?
Although India has developed capabilities across several stages of permanent magnet manufacturing, the country still lacks a systematic way of identifying where those capabilities are globally competitive, where critical gaps persist, and how dependence accumulates across production stages.
asserted
dependence → develop → stages
India’s statistical system provides only a partial picture of what is mined, imported, and manufactured.
asserted
what → provide → picture
One way to bridge this gap is through an Integrated Techno-Economic Mapping (ITEM) framework, which presently is a missing piece in India’s industrial policy toolkit.
asserted
which → bridge → toolkit
Such a framework brings together information on engineering and economic measurement to show how a permanent magnet is built, from minerals in the ground to the finished products that power advanced manufacturing.
asserted
that → bring → manufacturing
More importantly, it would identify where industrial capability should be built, where technological partnerships become essential, and where domestic investment would yield the greatest strategic return.
asserted
investment → identify → return
A country may secure mineral resources yet remain dependent if it lacks processing and manufacturing capabilities.
uncertain
it → secure → capabilities
Bridging this measurement gap is not an academic exercise; it is an industrial imperative.
asserted
it → bridge → gap
The Aporia
