Shoppers of ultra-fast fashion companies, such as Shein and Temu, say despite being aware of environmental and ethical concerns other factors such as price, convenience and not feeling personally responsible keep them coming back.
asserted
factors → say → them
A new study published in the Journal of Global Fashion Marketing this week found millennials, who frequently expressed concern about ethical and sustainability issues, often did not translate this concern into purchasing behaviour.
asserted
who → publish → behaviour
The study surveyed 20 Australian millennials who shopped on ultra-fast fashion sites about what informed their purchasing behaviours.
asserted
what → survey → behaviours
It found affordability, convenience, promotions, social media trends, novelty, variety and social validation were the biggest purchase drivers.
asserted
affordability → find → ?
For some, affordability meant they were likely to purchase styles they may not usually try and make riskier choices.
uncertain
they → mean → choices
❝
You can get five things for the price of one at other places.
asserted
You → get → places
— Study participant
❝
I can redo my wardrobe every season without hurting my bank account.
asserted
I → redo → account
It's perfect when I need something quick and cheap for an event.
asserted
I → need → event
The study also found the purchases were usually not spontaneous, with many shoppers saying they saved carts and waited for a sale before purchasing.
asserted
they → find → sale
❝
When I see a 70 per cent off notification, it's almost impossible not to look.
asserted
it → see → notification
It feels like I'm losing money if I don't buy it.
asserted
I → feel → it
— Study participant
❝
Sales get me every time.
asserted
Sales → get → ?
I've bought outfits I didn't even wear just because they were on sale.
asserted
they → buy → sale
— Study participant
❝
I add things to my cart and wait for payday or a discount notification.
asserted
I → add → payday
— Study participant
Associate Professor in the School of Fashion and Textiles at RMIT University and study co-author Carol Tan said this behaviour was known as "strategic spontaneity".
asserted
behaviour → say → spontaneity
"You think it's impulsive, but it's actually planned," she said.
"
asserted
she → think → ?
So what people do is they save the items, they have a wish list, and then they monitor their sales and wait for payday.
asserted
they → save → payday
"It could be sitting in their cart for a week or a month, and then a spur-of-the-moment decision is when they actually make the purchase and it happens in minutes."
uncertain
it → sit → minutes
While fast fashion has been around for some time, platforms such as Shein and Temu differ in their production and distribution methods.
asserted
platforms → differ → methods
Traditional fast-fashion brands release a new collection every two to four weeks that can range from hundreds to thousands of styles and sell primarily through physical stores.
asserted
that → release → stores
Ultra-fast fashion stores produce 2,000 to 10,000 new styles daily and use digital-only, mobile app-dominant sales models.
asserted
stores → produce → models
Dr Tan said the rise of ultra-fast fashion has pushed some fast-fashion brands to change their strategy.
asserted
rise → say → strategy
"They are trying to not compete with the Sheins of the world and they are trying to go a bit more upmarket.
asserted
they → try → world
So they sell better-quality stuff and they have like $400 jackets," she said.
asserted
she → sell → jackets
Outside of the growing price gap between fast fashion and ultra-fashion fashion, Dr Tan said these sites often sold items you could not buy in brick-and-mortar stores.
uncertain
you → grow → stores
Despite participants expressing concerns about the environmental and ethical impacts of ultra-fast fashion brands, many still continued to purchase on Shein or Temu.
asserted
many → express → Shein
According to the latest figures from the Australia Institute, on average Australians purchase 56 items of clothing a year.
uncertain
Australians → accord → clothing
It also reports more than 200,000 tonnes of clothing end up in Australian landfills each year.
asserted
tonnes → report → landfills
The study found participants were more influenced by social and economic drivers than long-term ethical concerns.
asserted
participants → find → concerns
❝
I know it's bad for the planet, but when I'm on a budget and need an outfit for Saturday, I just block that out.
asserted
I → know → that
— Study participant
❝
I try to buy sustainable brands, but they are so expensive.
asserted
they → try → brands
— Study participant
❝
If the big brands are allowed to sell it, then it can't be all my fault for buying it.
asserted
it → allow → it
— Study participant
❝
I feel bad sometimes, but one small top isn't going to destroy the ocean.
asserted
top → feel → ocean
— Study participant
The study also found buyers would draw on explanations such as reduced feelings of personal responsibility, affordability constraints, limited access to sustainable alternatives and the belief that the individual purchases had little impact.
asserted
purchases → find → impact
In some countries, different taxes have been introduced to deter buyers from ultra-fast fashion brands.
asserted
taxes → introduce → brands
France has banned advertising from ultra-fast fashion businesses and introduced a fee that will rise to €10 ($16) per item by 2030.
asserted
that → ban → 2030
New Zealand has a levy of NZ$2.21 ($1.80) per package.
asserted
Zealand → have → package
Australia has a scheme called Seamless that businesses can voluntary opt into, where they pay a 4 per cent per garment levy to promote clothing repair, rental and recycling.
asserted
they → have → repair
However, the scheme does not cover overseas retailers such as Shein.
asserted
scheme → cover → Shein
Dr Tan said she believed focusing on cost per wear would be more influential in changing consumer behaviour.
asserted
focusing → say → behaviour
…and 4 more, not listed.
The Aporia