A short excerpt from Prof. Mchangama's Sept. 3 post (though the whole thing is much worth reading):
Frederick Douglass was a frequent target of vilification and smears—not to mention hostile mobs, stones and rotten eggs.
asserted
Douglass → read → mobs
His enemies—and sometimes even erstwhile allies—used press and pulpit to counter the growing influence of his oratorical genius and editorial prowess.
asserted
enemies → use → genius
Douglass' primary weapon consisted of words—but what to do when opponents turned this weapon against him?
asserted
opponents → consist → him
What rules—legal or moral—should guide newspaper editors with power to shape public opinion?
asserted
rules → guide → opinion
And as Douglass became an influential speaker, editor and publisher himself, did he practice what he preached?
asserted
he → become → what
Douglass the Defamed
"Nigger" and other racial epithets were routinely hurled at Douglass.
asserted
Douglass → hurl → Douglass
But far more damaging than crude racist attacks were various allegations of sexual depravity, of lying about his life story, of being a paid anti-American agitator and of being a cowardly co-conspirator in the attack on Harper's Ferry…
asserted
allegations → lie → Ferry
Ideally the venue of attack would provide the target equal access to respond.
asserted
venue → provide → access
When reciprocity was denied, press freedom provided a corrective mechanism.
asserted
freedom → deny → mechanism
Media pluralism increased the chances that a fair-minded newspaper would give voice to those denied a right of reply elsewhere….
asserted
newspaper → increase → reply
Two things underwrote Douglass' conviction that the law should protect the pen rather than restrain it: an extraordinary confidence in counterspeech, and a demanding conception of what press freedom required.
asserted
freedom → underwrite → what
A newspaper worthy of being called the "palladium of liberty" did not protect readers from controversy.
asserted
newspaper → call → controversy
It enabled accusations to be answered, exposed its own claims to adversarial testing and gave truth a chance to prevail over falsehood.
uncertain
It → enable → falsehood
Douglass did not merely preach that ideal.
asserted
Douglass → preach → ideal
Across more than half a century of vilification, he practiced it with a record that—if not unblemished—was impressively consistent.
asserted
that → practice → record
from his Sept. 11 post, which I likewise highly recommend:
asserted
I → recommend → which
As in the previous installments, the harder test is whether Douglass extended his principles to his enemies.
asserted
Douglass → extend → enemies
Did an antislavery crowd get a pass when it silenced a defender of human bondage?
asserted
it → get → bondage
Douglass's defense of free speech extended to one of slavery's most powerful political allies.
asserted
defense → extend → allies
In an October 1854 speech in Chicago, he addressed the recent shouting down of Senator Stephen A. Douglas (no relation and no ally), the architect of the Kansas–Nebraska Act.
asserted
he → address → Act
But before considering the senator's grievances, Douglass described the people excluded from his promises of "Popular Sovereignty":
asserted
Douglass → consider → Sovereignty
Every right of human nature, as such, is denied them—they are dumb in their chains!
asserted
they → deny → chains
To utter one groan, or scream, for freedom in the presence of the Southern advocate of Popular Sovereignty, is to bring down the frightful lash upon their quivering flesh.
asserted
utter → utter → flesh
I know this suffering people; I am acquainted with their sorrows; I am one with them in experience; I have felt the lash of the slave driver, and stand up here with all the bitter recollections of its horrors vividly upon me.
asserted
I → know → me
This experience gave Douglass a particular obligation to exercise the freedom denied to those still enslaved:
There are special reasons, therefore, why I should speak and speak freely.
asserted
I → give → those
The right of speech is a very precious one, especially to the oppressed.
asserted
right → oppress → oppressed
He then turned to the senator's wounded feelings:
asserted
He → turn → feelings
"I understand that Mr. Douglas regards himself as the most abused man in the United States, and that the greatest outrage ever committed upon him, was in the case in which your indignation raised your voices so high that his could not be heard.
uncertain
his → understand → voices
No personal violence, as I understand, was offered him.
asserted
I → understand → him
It seems to have been a trial of vocal powers between the individual and the multitude; as might have been expected, the voice of one man was not equal in volume to the voice of five hundred."
uncertain
voice → seem → hundred
The mockery came with an explicit reaffirmation of principle:
I do not approve it; I am for free speech as well as for freemen and free soil.
Douglass recognized the senator's right to speak while putting the interference he had suffered in perspective.
asserted
he → come → perspective
Being drowned out by non-violent political opponents scarcely compared with the enforced silence of millions living under the lash.
asserted
drowned → drown → lash
Yet the senator had no problem with systematic suppression when slavery was decided in elections where those wielding the whip cast ballots but those being whipped did not.
asserted
those → have → ballots
Douglass could condemn the crowd's conduct and ridicule the senator's self-pity in the same breath.
uncertain
Douglass → condemn → breath
Indeed, he hoped the experience might teach the senator to respect the rights of those whose oppression he defended….
uncertain
he → hop → oppression
And you can also read Prof. Mchangama's Aug. 21 post, which I had briefly excerpted as well.
asserted
I → read → which
The Aporia