A Nova Scotia seafood processor is arguing that a commercial fishing group suing it over claims it bought illegal lobster needs to name names and provide more detailed allegations before the case can continue.
uncertain
case → argue → allegations
Independent Fisheries Ltd. and its president, Xiaoming (Mark) Mao, argue in court papers that they’re being asked to prepare a defence to the $10-million lawsuit “with no understanding of the (alleged) facts.”
asserted
they → argue → facts
The Unified Fisheries Conservation Alliance, a group representing thousands of independent, multi-species commercial fishers and associations across the Maritimes, filed a lawsuit against Mao and Independent Fisheries Ltd. in November 2024.
asserted
Alliance → represent → November
The suit also names the owners and operators of Fisher Direct Ltd. and Seawell Holdings Ltd., both based in Shag Harbour, N.S., as defendants.
asserted
suit → name → defendants
The alliance alleges it conducted an investigation revealing the defendants participated in a conspiracy to transport, process and sell illegally caught lobster.
asserted
defendants → allege → lobster
It claimed the alleged scheme has diminished lobster stocks in St. Mary’s Bay, a rich fishing ground in southwestern Nova Scotia which its members rely on, and caused them $10 million in damages.
asserted
members → claim → damages
Independent Fisheries and Mao argued the alliance’s claims were too vague and asked the court to compel it to disclose the identities of all lobster harvesters who were allegedly harmed, as well as the names of all alleged conspirators, dates and times of their alleged acts and facts supporting Mao’s liability.
uncertain
who → argue → liability
They argued they needed the information to properly prepare their defence.
asserted
they → argue → defence
A judge dismissed the motion in January saying Mao and his company would have opportunities for disclosure and discovery examinations as the case moved ahead.
asserted
case → dismiss → examinations
The judge said it would be unreasonable to “straitjacket” the alliance by insisting it includes material facts “which are likely to be exclusively with the knowledge of the defendants.”
asserted
which → say → defendants
Mao and Independent Fisheries are now appealing that decision, claiming the judge erred in law and principle and “inflicted a patent injustice.”
asserted
judge → appeal → injustice
A court hearing was held on the matter last week but there hasn’t been a ruling yet.
asserted
hearing → hold → matter
In an email, Mao said Independent Fisheries employs more than 80 people, is regularly inspected and is in full compliance with all provincial and federal regulations.
asserted
Fisheries → say → regulations
“In a province that has welcomed newcomers for generations, it is deeply disappointing that our Chinese Canadian ownership structure has been called into question,” Mao said in an email to The Canadian Press.
asserted
Mao → welcome → Press
“We are optimistic that the Court of Appeal will agree that the claims made against us do not comply with legal requirements for lawsuits.
uncertain
claims → agree → lawsuits
We vehemently deny any allegations of wrongdoing and look forward to being vindicated through the legal process.”
asserted
We → deny → process
The alliance argues in court submissions that Mao and International Fisheries are trying to delay litigation with repeated demands for more information.
asserted
Mao → argue → information
It notes no defence has been filed as the case approaches its two-year anniversary.
asserted
case → note → anniversary
The alliance says the details Mao is seeking aren’t necessary at this point, and says it appears likely that Mao and Independent Fisheries are trying to determine the extent of the evidence before submitting a defence.
Michel Samson, a lawyer representing the alliance, called on Mao and Independent Fisheries to file a defence so it could present its evidence to the court.
uncertain
it → say → court
“We filed the action in November, 2024 and have faced delay tactics from Independent and Mao ever since,” he wrote.
asserted
he → file → Independent
A representative for Fisher Direct and Seawell did not respond to a request for comment.
asserted
representative → respond → comment
It’s not the only case the alliance is pursuing involving St. Mary’s Bay lobster.
asserted
alliance → ’ → lobster
In 2024 the group asked the Nova Scotia Supreme Court to rule that members of the Sipekne’katik First Nation do not have a treaty right to fish lobster in the area out of season without commercial licenses.
asserted
members → ask → licenses
Sipekne’katik first announced plans to launch its own self-regulated fishery in 2020.
asserted
Sipekne’katik → announce → 2020
The alliance claimed in court documents that Sipekne’katik’s commercial fishery was unauthorized and unlawful.
asserted
fishery → claim → documents
It alleged the fishery had a detrimental effect on lobster stocks, claiming some fishers were forced to sell their licenses or fish in other areas.
asserted
fishers → allege → areas
It wanted the judge to declare that the federal Fisheries Act and regulations are constitutionally valid and do not violate any treaty rights held by Sipekne’katik.
asserted
Act → want → Sipekne’katik
The case was dismissed last month with the court ruling the alliance did not have standing to pursue a case involving Indigenous fishing rights.
asserted
alliance → dismiss → rights
The group said it plans to appeal that decision.
asserted
it → say → decision
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Sept. 21, 2026.
asserted
report → publish → Press
The Aporia
