- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
An anatomy lecturer has sparked an ethics debate over a Sydney exhibition displaying real human bodies, including some posed having sex, questioning whether donors fully understood how their remains might be presented after death.
UNSW senior lecturer in anatomy and histology Dr Joyce El-Haddad questioned whether donors gave informed consent for the specific ways their bodies could eventually be displayed.
The exhibition, Body Worlds: The Anatomy of Happiness, features real human bodies preserved through a process known as plastination and has attracted millions of visitors around the world over the past two decades.
uncertain
exhibition → see → decades
'The organisers claim that the bodies have been donated,' she said.
uncertain
she → claim → ?
The bodies are displayed in many different ways - some riding a horse, some in penetrative sexual positions, some with a basketball...and the list goes on.
asserted
list → display → basketball
However, informed consent is not a tick box exercise and we need to think about: who donated these bodies? What did they understand they were consenting to?
asserted
they → need → understand
'Respect, dignity, transparency, and context do not disappear simply because somebody signed a form.'
asserted
somebody → disappear → form
Organisers say the exhibition's body donation program, founded in 1982, has registered more than 21,000 donors globally and forms the 'ethical cornerstone' of Body Worlds.
asserted
program → say → Worlds
UNSW anatomy and histology lecturer Dr Joyce El-Haddad said she wanted to help the public make an 'informed decision' about whether to visit Body Worlds
The exhibition, which opened in Sydney on Monday, has attracted millions of visitors worldwide since launching more than two decades ago
The exhibition has sparked debate after dead bodies were displayed in sexualised poses
The donation program has been managed by the Institute for Plastination in Germany since 1993, although it is no longer accepting new donor applications because it has reached capacity.
asserted
it → say → capacity
A review of the Institute for Plastination's donor consent documents shows donors agree their remains may be used to create 'anatomical works of art' for the 'medical enlightenment of laypeople' in museums and exhibitions.
uncertain
remains → show → museums
The consent forms state donors acknowledge their bodies may be provided to organisations operating on a commercial basis.
uncertain
bodies → state → basis
Donors can also express preferences about how their bodies are used, including requesting special poses, although the institute says it 'cannot guarantee' those wishes will be fulfilled.
asserted
wishes → express → poses
The agreement further states photographs and other images of plastinated bodies may be used indefinitely for educational, scientific and public information purposes.
uncertain
photographs → state → purposes
Body Worlds is marketed as an educational experience designed to increase public understanding of anatomy, health and disease.
asserted
Worlds → market → anatomy
However, Dr El-Haddad questioned how much visitors could learn about health, disease, ageing and wellbeing without understanding the life experiences of the people whose bodies are on display.
uncertain
bodies → question → display
How much do you assume about someone before you've had a conversation with them?
asserted
you → assume → them
Before you've listened to their experiences, challenges, choices, and circumstances?
asserted
you → listen → experiences
Organisers say its body donation program founded in 1982 has registered more than 21,000 donors globally
Public displays of human remains have a long and often controversial history
'
asserted
displays → say → history
The exhibition claims that it is educational....
uncertain
it → claim → ?
okay, but: Education requires more than information.
asserted
Education → require → information
'We often assume that simply looking at something means we are learning from it.
asserted
we → assume → it
A diseased lung can show us what happened.
asserted
what → show → us
It cannot tell us about addiction, socioeconomic disadvantage, environmental exposures, access to healthcare, culture, or the lived experience of disease.
asserted
It → tell → disease
Without that context, visitors are left to construct their own narratives and make their own assumptions.
asserted
visitors → leave → assumptions
'And if the exhibition is also open to children, what assumptions are they taking away?'
asserted
they → take → assumptions
Dr El-Haddad said her concerns also stemmed from the long and often controversial history of displaying human remains to the public.
asserted
concerns → say → public
Human bodies and remains have previously been exhibited in cabinets of curiosity, travelling fairs, medical museums, carnival sideshows and so-called 'human zoos'.
asserted
bodies → exhibit → curiosity
She noted such displays have at times been linked to racism, ableism, colonialism, sexism, classism and exploitation, and questioned what distinguished modern body exhibitions from those historical practices.
'So my question is - what shields modern day human body exhibitions from the same condemnation?'
asserted
what → note → condemnation
Despite her concerns, Dr El-Haddad said attending the exhibition was ultimately a matter of personal choice.
asserted
attending → say → choice
Well, ultimately that is up to you and I hope this post helps you make a better informed decision that aligns with your values.'
asserted
that → hope → values
The organisers of the exhibition have been contacted for comment.
asserted
organisers → contact → comment
The Aporia
