A couple browsing an oversized Topps baseball-card coffee-table book at a local garage sale made an unexpected discovery when they found a rare photograph of a young Mickey Mantle tucked inside.
asserted
they → browse → Mantle
The photograph, later authenticated by PSA/DNA as a Type 2 print, captured Mantle during spring training early in his rookie season and became the source image for his iconic 1951 Bowman rookie card.
asserted
photograph → authenticate → card
The couple also found an image of Joe DiMaggio inside the same book, according to Heritage Auctions, which later offered the Mantle photograph for sale.
uncertain
which → find → sale
The photograph was sold on December 20, 2025, during Heritage's Winter Sports Catalogue Auction, fetching $20,740.
asserted
photograph → sell → 20,740
Its value was not simply tied to Mantle's fame.
asserted
value → tie → fame
Details in the photograph, including his No. 6 uniform and the bat belonging to teammate Joe Collins, help place the image at a specific point in the young player's career.
asserted
Details → include → career
The photograph captured Mantle as an untested rookie
Heritage's description places the photograph at Arizona spring training, when Mantle was still an untested rookie.
asserted
Mantle → capture → training
One clue is his rolled-up sleeve.
asserted
clue → roll → ?
The auction house notes that Mantle would later have enough standing to dictate tailoring changes to his uniform, but was not yet in that position at the time the photograph was taken.
asserted
photograph → note → time
Another detail is the bat resting over Mantle's right shoulder.
asserted
detail → rest → shoulder
Heritage identifies it as a bat belonging to Yankees first baseman Joe Collins.
asserted
Heritage → identify → Collins
The auction description says Mantle had not yet signed a deal with Hillerich & Bradsby for his own bat, explaining why he was pictured with Collins' equipment instead.
asserted
he → say → equipment
The back of Mantle's uniform provides another clue.
asserted
back → provide → clue
The visible number is a 6 rather than the No. 7 that became permanently associated with him.
asserted
that → associate → him
Heritage notes that Mantle wore No. 6 only during the unsettled beginning of his rookie campaign before switching to No. 7.
asserted
Mantle → note → .
The image became the basis for Mantle's rookie card
The photograph is particularly significant because it became the source for Mantle's 1951 Bowman rookie card.
asserted
it → become → card
Heritage describes the image as one of the most recognisable photographs of Mantle, although the baseball card altered some of its visual details.
asserted
card → describe → details
The 1951 Bowman version has a distinctive posterised appearance, while Mantle's 1953 Topps card used the same photograph but cropped more tightly around his youthful face.
asserted
card → have → face
The same image was also used for Mantle's 1952 Berk Ross card.
asserted
image → use → card
Heritage's records for a separate Type 1 example from the Jack Kramer Collection identify the photograph as the source for the 1951 Bowman and 1953 Topps cards and show Mantle wearing No. 6 with Collins' bat over his shoulder.
asserted
Mantle → identify → shoulder
The garage-sale photograph was classified as Type 2 by PSA/DNA.
asserted
photograph → classify → DNA
That distinction matters because it was not one of the rare first-generation prints.
asserted
it → matter → prints
Heritage's 2024 records describe the much rarer Type 1 version as an original photograph made from the original negative during the period close to when the picture was taken.
asserted
picture → describe → period
PSA's Type 1 classification is based on that first-generation status.
asserted
classification → base → status
The photograph's reverse carried a matching inscription
The photograph found in the garage-sale book had handwritten words identifying the subject as "Mickey Mantle" on its reverse.
asserted
photograph → carry → reverse
Heritage said the handwriting perfectly matched the handwriting on a Type 1 example of the same photograph that it had sold for $71,700 in 2015.
asserted
it → say → 2015
The auction house also noted that it had since sold another Type 1 example for more than $800,000.
asserted
it → note → 800,000
Heritage noted surface wear on the front, numerous light horizontal cracks in the glossy finish, several small areas of paper loss along the white border and a slight tear on the middle-right side.
asserted
Heritage → note → side
It had no other markings or stamps and was encapsulated by PSA/DNA as a Type 2 photograph.
asserted
It → have → photograph
Despite those imperfections, the photograph retained a direct connection to one of the most recognisable images from Mantle's early career.
asserted
photograph → retain → career
The combination of its provenance, its use as the source for the 1951 Bowman rookie card and its unusual garage-sale discovery helped make it a notable auction find.
asserted
it → help → card
A different Type 1 Mantle photograph sold for $843,750
The huge difference in value between different generations of the image can be seen in another Heritage sale.
asserted
difference → sell → sale
On April 7, 2024, the auction house sold a Type 1 print of the same Mantle action photograph for $843,750.
asserted
house → sell → 843,750
The photograph came from the collection of Jack Kramer, a former major-league pitcher who had been Mantle's Yankees teammate.
asserted
who → come → Kramer
It was an original 8-by-10-inch photograph taken by Yankees team photographer Bob Olen and had remained among Kramer's possessions for decades.
asserted
It → take → decades
Heritage said only four known original prints of the image existed, meaning the $843,750 photograph was one of the rare Type 1 examples.
asserted
photograph → say → examples
The auction house described the sale as a record for a Type 1 sports photograph, surpassing the previous $516,000 record set by a Ty Cobb photograph.
asserted
house → describe → photograph
The same 2024 auction also included a different Mantle photograph from the Kramer Collection, a 1951 rookie headshot, which sold for $20,625.
asserted
which → include → 20,625
That was a separate item from the garage-sale photograph that later sold for $20,740.
asserted
that → sell → 20,740
The distinction explains why the two prices, although strikingly similar, should not be confused.
asserted
prices → explain → ?
…and 3 more, not listed.
The Aporia
