In short:
A food charity has requested the use of Broken Hill City Council land as a site to provide homelessness services, including a transitional camp.
asserted
charity → request → camp
The Broken Hill mayor said no land was available, and if it were, planning approvals and extensive public consultation would be needed to proceed with a homeless encampment.
asserted
approvals → say → encampment
A senior lecturer in law said the case highlighted the lack of a legal framework around homelessness in New South Wales.
asserted
case → say → Wales
The head of a food charity in far-west New South Wales has been left frustrated after being told there was no council land available to build a homeless camp.
asserted
head → leave → camp
Feeding Friends had asked Broken Hill City Council for a block of council land or an unused building to establish a base for homelessness services, including a food outlet, laundry facilities and a transitional camp.
asserted
Friends → ask → outlet
The charity said it was responding to an "urgent need for secure, stable spaces" in the mining city, where those experiencing homelessness could set up temporary and safe shelters.
uncertain
those → say → shelters
While the council voted to investigate whether any land was available, Mayor Tom Kennedy made it clear there was not.
asserted
it → vote → ?
"Initial findings is there is no land," Mr Kennedy said.
asserted
Kennedy → be → ?
"So for Feeding Friends to go any further, they're going to have to acquire land themselves.
"
asserted
they → go → land
[But] what's been proposed before council requires significant planning … [and] vast public consultation."
asserted
proposed → propose → planning
Prior to the meeting to discuss the request, some locals raised concerns over the encampment's impact on neighbouring residents and businesses.
asserted
locals → discuss → residents
Demand is increasing
asserted
Demand → increase → ?
After five years serving hot meals to those experiencing homelessness in Broken Hill, Feeding Friends president Don Barron said demand for its services were growing amid the cost-of-living crisis.
asserted
demand → serve → crisis
He said the charity now needed a permanent location for its food services.
asserted
charity → say → services
"I was very disappointed [land wasn't available]," Mr Barron said.
asserted
Barron → disappoint → ?
"[The need] has certainly grown in the way of young families.
"
asserted
need → grow → families
We have homeless people in Broken Hill that do have children, they still go to school but they're living in cars.
"
asserted
they → have → cars
It's probably a lack of housing which is the main reason why people are living in cars … [also] affordability, the cost of living is just gone out of control.
asserted
cost → live → control
"
No 'legal framework' to address homelessness
Derwent Coshott, a senior lecturer in law at Sydney University, said legally establishing a transitional campsite would require planning approvals.
asserted
establishing → address → approvals
But he said there was another pathway through a policy of non-enforcement, referring to the state government's protocol for homeless people in public places.
"The policies that have been adopted have been permissive, in so far as you kind of just let people camp there and you don't enforce the law to move them on," Dr Coshott said.
asserted
Coshott → say → them
Feeding Friends could ask the council to not enforce the law against them, he said.
uncertain
he → feed → them
"The risk is, of course, that none of this means that the law might not be enforced against them later on."
uncertain
law → mean → them
However, Dr Coshott said the issue raised broader questions about regulating homelessness in NSW.
asserted
issue → say → NSW
"We have a NSW administrative protocol that's effectively saying, 'Look, we don't actually have a law that properly deals with this, so the way we're going to deal with this is by not enforcing the law'," Dr Coshott said.
asserted
Coshott → have → law
"That basically tells you where the problem is, in the sense that there is no real proper legal framework to address homelessness in these circumstances."
asserted
problem → tell → circumstances
For Mr Barron, who knows what it's like to sleep rough, it is about confronting homelessness head-on.
asserted
it → know → homelessness
"It's not just local council's problem, it's a three-tier problem — local council, which doesn't have funds to do it, the state government, which does, and the federal government, which does," Mr Barron said.
asserted
Barron → have → it
"We all need to sit down as a three-tier society, and involve the public, of how we can address this issue."
asserted
we → need → issue
The Aporia