The countries trying to broker an end to the Iran conflict — Oman, Pakistan, and Qatar — are themselves facing military attacks and economic strain from the war, an unusual dynamic that factors into the incentives and urgency behind their mediation.
asserted
that → try → mediation
Strait of Hormuz disruptions have hammered Qatar’s liquefied natural gas exports and cut off much of Pakistan’s supply, and the broader economic slowdown is straining remittances from Pakistanis working in the Gulf.
asserted
slowdown → hammer → Gulf
Qatar and Oman have also been attacked by Iranian drones and missiles.
asserted
Qatar → attack → drones
With the continued risk of Tehran targeting Gulf energy infrastructure and economic livelihoods, efforts by the three countries to de-escalate are heightened “from a long-term goal to an immediate necessity,” said Talal Abdulla Al-Emadi, an energy law professor at Qatar University.
asserted
Emadi → continue → University
All three have the advantage of leveraging their strong ties with both Iran and the US to serve as more effective mediators.
asserted
three → have → mediators
Oman has long played a quiet role in US-Iran diplomacy, while Qatar has facilitated backchannel negotiations and prisoner exchanges.
asserted
Qatar → play → negotiations
Pakistan is relatively newer to such mediation, but has a history of serving as an intermediary, including between the US and China in the 1970s.
asserted
Pakistan → have → 1970s
The countries are all pushing to resume talks during the United Nations General Assembly this week.
asserted
countries → push → Assembly
Qatar is conveying messages between the parties, Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani said on Sunday in New York.
asserted
Thani → convey → York
But daily developments are “changing the course of the negotiations,” he said.
asserted
he → change → negotiations
“There is no clear master strategy that we are following in order to put an end to this.
asserted
we → be → this
And that’s basically what we are missing today.
asserted
we → ’ → what
In past crises, these mediators had little of their own physical infrastructure or revenue on the line.
asserted
mediators → have → line
Know More
Qatar’s trapped LNG
The war has put the foundation of Doha’s economy — energy sales — directly at risk.
asserted
war → know → risk
Before the conflict, Qatar exported almost one-fifth of the world’s LNG, all of it through the Strait of Hormuz.
asserted
Qatar → export → Hormuz
Very few shipments have made the trip since March, when Iran in effect shut the waterway.
asserted
Iran → make → waterway
Some oil tankers have made their way through the strait, but LNG tankers are a more troublesome target, according to Robin Mills, a non-resident fellow at Columbia University’s Center on Global Energy Policy and CEO of Qamar Energy.
uncertain
tankers → make → Energy
They are more flammable, expensive, and difficult to repair, making Qatar reluctant to risk sending them through the strait at all.
asserted
Qatar → repair → strait
While there has been discussion of pipelines to eventually replace the strait, that won’t work for LNG or Qatar’s other exports: The government has decided not pursue alternate routes.
asserted
government → replace → routes
That gives Qatar a powerful reason to keep talks moving between Tehran and Washington.
asserted
talks → give → Tehran
“In the case of Qatar, so much is at stake for them,” said Alex Vatanka, a senior fellow at the Middle East Institute.
asserted
Vatanka → say → Institute
“Their wealth, their future, everything is tied to the physical location where they’re located.
asserted
they → tie → location
The Qataris want to continue being mediators not because they like the Iranians, not because they give the Iranians a pass or forgive them — it’s because they don’t have an option.”
asserted
they → want → option
Pakistan has a different set of vulnerabilities, but a similar incentive to push for an end to the conflict.
asserted
Pakistan → have → conflict
The loss of LNG supplies from Qatar has forced the country to consider buying more expensive fuel or extend rolling blackouts in the evening.
asserted
loss → force → evening
Islamabad is engaged due to “the cost of staying on the sidelines,” said Rabia Akhtar, dean faculty of social sciences at the University of Lahore.
asserted
Akhtar → engage → Lahore
“Pakistan had relationships it could draw on, and this conflict created an urgent reason to use them.
uncertain
conflict → have → them
While Pakistan is the rare neighbor of Iran that hasn’t been attacked, Islamabad recognizes the risks of a prolonged war in the region, she added: “‘It’s not my war’ offers very little protection.
asserted
’s → attack → protection
Pakistan does not have to enter the fighting to experience its consequences.”
asserted
Pakistan → have → consequences
Its oil and gas exports are flowing, and its economy has emerged as one of the region’s most resilient.
asserted
economy → flow → region
The country was a hit a few times by Iran, and US President Donald Trump threatened Oman directly over its mediating role role, saying, “If Oman gets in the way, we’ll bomb the sh*t out of them.”
asserted
we → threaten → them
Muscat is “engaged in a balancing act of their own.
asserted
Muscat → engage → own
They’ve been hit.
asserted
They → hit → ?
They’ve been called names by the American president.
asserted
They → call → president
So it’s a thankless job at times,” the Middle East Institute’s Vatanka said.
asserted
Vatanka → ’ → times
As the Trump administration wages its economic warfare against Iran, it has pressed Oman to cut financial ties with the regime.
asserted
it → wag → regime
Those efforts have included dispatching a senior envoy to discuss ending Iranian airline Mahan Air’s flights to Oman, according to a Treasury Department spokesperson.
uncertain
efforts → include → spokesperson
For Oman, Qatar, and Pakistan, these economic and security costs may add urgency in their push to press all sides to a resolution.
uncertain
costs → add → resolution
Qatar’s economic interests don’t “complicate its neutrality” but “they are precisely what enables it,” Al-Emadi, the Qatar University professor, said.
asserted
Emadi → complicate → it
“Neutrality in mediation does not require having zero stake in the outcome; it requires remaining unaligned with either side’s partisan ambitions.”
asserted
it → require → ambitions
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
