Journalist Motaz Azaiza’s new revelations exposing “SMART,” a Hamas-controlled group of reporters used to manage the media narrative about Gaza, reveal uncomfortable but important truths about nearly two decades of journalism.
asserted
revelations → expose → journalism
The world has relied on a media ecosystem that forced journalists to operate within red lines set by Hamas — under threat of punishment if their coverage ever crossed the terror group.
asserted
coverage → rely → group
That reality was too often lost by the time Gaza’s stories reached Western TV screens and newspaper pages — and it drove college-campus protests and breathless claims by so-called activists, as false allegations emerging from the coastal enclave were repeated as unquestioned facts.
uncertain
allegations → lose → facts
But Azaiza’s revelation should come as no surprise: Ever since its violent takeover after Gaza’s 2007 civil war, Hamas has tightly controlled the narrative to influence the story that reaches the outside world.
asserted
that → come → world
Its goal has been to shape positive coverage of its iron-fisted rule and to legitimize its narrative of “resistance” — that is, violence against Israel.
asserted
that → shape → Israel
In 2013, Hamas’ Interior Ministry brought Gazan journalists and social-media activists together for a workshop, coaching them on how to report news in Gaza.
asserted
Ministry → bring → Gaza
Among the attendees was Abu Ubayda, Hamas’ infamous military spokesman and one of its most prominent propagandists, who was eliminated by Israel in 2025.
asserted
who → eliminate → 2025
Hamas made it clear during the session that the press’ role is “no less important than that of the resistance on the ground.”
asserted
is → make → ground
But the message was not only one of encouragement: The terror group made it clear that reporters would pay a steep price if they did not adhere to the Hamas line.
asserted
they → make → line
In 2016, Hamas arrested Mohammed Othman, a journalist working for al-Monitor, for exposing medical errors occurring in Gaza’s hospitals.
asserted
Hamas → arrest → hospitals
Hamas later barred him from entering those facilities.
asserted
Hamas → bar → facilities
In 2019, Hamas detained 12 journalists for covering protests against Hamas’ rule and the economic situation in Gaza.
asserted
Hamas → detain → Gaza
The repression of reporters hasn’t eased after Oct. 7, 2023, or during the war that followed.
asserted
that → ease → war
In at least three cases during the war, Gazan journalists said Hamas fighters beat them or threatened them after they reported on locals who blamed the terror group for bringing destruction to Gaza.
asserted
who → say → Gaza
The journalists said Hamas explicitly ordered them to stop reporting on local discontent.
asserted
Hamas → say → discontent
It was intended to keep those voices from reaching international audiences, to preserve Hamas’ narrative that Israel alone was to blame for all Gaza’s problems, and to silence any Gazan saying otherwise.
asserted
Israel → intend → Gazan
That is what makes Azaiza’s account significant.
asserted
account → make → ?
Beyond shaping the media reality in Gaza, reporters’ self-censorship distorted the picture the outside world saw.
asserted
world → shape → picture
Western media outlets relied heavily on local journalists for on-the-ground reporting, while often missing a crucial reality: Any criticism of Hamas was unlikely to make it on camera, and who feared crossing the terror group meant basic facts became hard to document.
asserted
facts → rely → group
By the time their material reached international newsrooms, the intimidation and coercion that shaped the information-gathering the information had all but vanished.
And the self-censorship hasn’t been limited to Gazan journalists: Regional Arabic outlets have done the same.
asserted
outlets → reach → same
Al Jazeera has repeatedly cut off Gazans who criticized Hamas on air — hardly a surprise, given that Qatar, a financial sponsor of Hamas, owns Al Jazeera.
asserted
Qatar → cut → Jazeera
Israel has since revealed that several Al-Jazeera employees in Gaza were Hamas fighters masquerading as journalists.
asserted
employees → reveal → journalists
The Qatari-funded network has long taken guidance from Hamas on how to cover Gaza.
asserted
network → fund → Gaza
A 2022 document showed how Hamas instructed Al Jazeera to lie about a failed rocket launch that killed Palestinian civilians, telling the network to avoid the word “massacre” and steer clear of criticism of Hamas.
asserted
that → show → Hamas
A 2023 document further showed that Hamas moved to create a secure line for classified communications between the network and the terror group.
asserted
Hamas → show → network
For nearly two decades, Hamas has operated a media ecosystem based on fear.
asserted
Hamas → operate → fear
Journalists learned what they could say and what they could film.
uncertain
they → learn → what
Western audiences rarely saw those constraints, and some ended up absorbing Hamas’ preferred narrative.
asserted
some → see → narrative
That should force a reckoning among the activists and celebrities who swallowed claims out of Gaza whole, without asking who controlled what could be reported.
uncertain
what → force → Gaza
And a looming question remains: How many US and international media outlets rely on SMART “fixers” — locals who arrange for meetings and translate Arabic to English — in their reporting?
asserted
who → loom → reporting
The Aporia
