Long-running rumors that Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) married her biological brother to help him obtain immigration relief have returned to national attention after senior Trump administration officials indicated that federal authorities are mounting an immigration fraud case against the congresswoman.
asserted
authorities → run → congresswoman
The controversy took a new turn earlier this month when Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin suggested the agency has actionable evidence to believe that Omar, a naturalized U.S. citizen since 2000, married her own brother as part of an immigration scheme.
uncertain
Omar → take → scheme
“We know that she married her brother to try to bring him into the United States,” Mullin said, while speaking with conservative podcaster Benny Johnson at the Republican National Committee’s midterm convention.
asserted
Mullin → know → convention
Mullin said lying on an immigration application to secure admission into the country can warrant deportation, and that there is no statute of limitations for launching removal proceedings on those grounds.
asserted
lying → say → grounds
Marriage fraud is a felony punishable by up to five years in federal prison, plus a $250,000 fine, for any individual who knowingly enters a marriage for the purpose of evading any provision of U.S. immigration laws.
asserted
who → enter → laws
It is both a deportable offense and due cause to strip someone of their American citizenship.
asserted
It → strip → citizenship
Mullin also alluded to federal investigators examining Omar’s broader family immigration history.
asserted
Mullin → allude → history
The congresswoman’s family entered the U.S. in 1995 as refugees who were fleeing war-torn Somalia, before resettling in Minneapolis.
asserted
who → enter → Minneapolis
“There may be more to this, the whole family migration and possibly some illegal activity for them to come to the United States to begin with,” Mullin said.
uncertain
Mullin → come → States
“All of this we are investigating…
asserted
we → investigate → this
If we can prove it, that you shouldn’t have been here in the first place
asserted
you → prove → place
, we will deport you.”
asserted
we → deport → you
Days later, White House border czar Tom Homan confirmed in a Fox News interview that there is an “ongoing criminal investigation” into Omar.
asserted
Homan → confirm → Omar
Homan declined to disclose the exact evidence underlying the probe, saying only, “I know things are going on, but I can’t give specifics of what’s happening.”
asserted
what → decline → specifics
Vice President JD Vance previously said that the Justice Department, which would be the prosecutorial authority to bring criminal fraud charges, was investigating the allegations involving Omar.
asserted
which → say → Omar
“We think Ilhan Omar definitely committed immigration fraud against the United States of America,” said Vance, head of the White House’s anti-fraud task force, in March.
asserted
Vance → think → March
Omar, however, told reporters on Friday that she has not been formally contacted about any investigation and categorically dismissed the accusations as a longstanding line of attack against her.
asserted
she → tell → her
“The right wing has always had this s*** going, so I don’t really worry about it,” Omar said.
asserted
Omar → have → it
She has repeatedly denied marrying her brother, calling the claims “bigoted lies.”
uncertain
She → deny → claims
The controversy centers on Omar’s 2009 marriage to her first legally recognized husband, Ahmed Nur Said Elmi, a British national currently living in London.
asserted
controversy → center → London
Accusations that Omar and Elmi are brother and sister originated a decade ago on a Somali discussion forum called SomaliSpot, but the 2016 thread containing those claims has since been deleted.
uncertain
thread → originate → claims
Comments on the original SomaliSpot post, titled “Ilhan Omar Marriage Fraud Exposure,” suggested that the sibling-marriage suspicions were something of an open secret in the Somali community.
uncertain
suspicions → title → community
The suspicions were renewed when Minneapolis-based Somali blogger Abdihakim Osman, a self-described old friend of the couple, came forward to claim that Omar had introduced Elmi as her brother to Somali community members back in the late 2000s.
uncertain
Omar → renew → 2000s
Osman alleged that Omar admitted to devising a way to help Elmi obtain immigration benefits, such as wedding each other in a sham marriage.
asserted
Elmi → allege → marriage
“She said she needed to get papers for her brother to go to school,” Osman told the Daily Mail in 2020.
asserted
Osman → say → 2020
“We all thought she was just getting papers together to allow him to stay in this country.
asserted
him → think → country
Once she had the papers, they could apply for student loans.”
uncertain
they → have → loans
Around the time that Omar married Elmi, they started attending the same college, North Dakota State University.
asserted
they → marry → college
Definitive proof of a sibling relationship between Omar and Elmi has not been established in public records, but publicly accessible documents do show irregularities surrounding Omar’s two previous marriages and her household tax filings.
asserted
documents → establish → marriages
Omar, the youngest of seven siblings, has been married to three different men at various points over the past 24 years, including periods of overlap in their relationships.
asserted
Omar → marry → relationships
In 2002, Omar married Ahmed Abdisalan Hirsi in a Muslim ceremony.
asserted
Omar → marry → ceremony
However, they did not file a marriage license with the state of Minnesota, so their marriage was not legitimate in the eyes of the law.
asserted
marriage → file → law
Hirsi is the father of Omar’s three children, including a daughter he fathered with the congresswoman in 2012, when she was still married to Elmi, according to a judge’s factual findings in the dissolution of Omar’s marriage to Elmi.
uncertain
she → include → Elmi
Omar and Elmi supposedly separated through Islamic tradition in 2011, during which she reconciled with Hirsi, but the pair did not marry for seven more years.
asserted
pair → separate → years
Omar officially terminated her marriage with Elmi in December 2017 and then legally married Hirsi one month later in January 2018, according to a Washington Examiner review of their Hennepin County marriage certificate.
uncertain
Omar → terminate → certificate
The two-time divorcee, now the wife of venture capitalist Tim Mynett, ended her legal union with Hirsi in 2019.
asserted
divorcee → end → 2019
The unusual sequence of Omar’s relationships has led internet sleuths to try to reconstruct the congresswoman’s family tree by piecing together old social media posts, and to suspect that Omar only married Hirsi to hide her alleged blood relation to Elmi as she prepared a run for Congress.
asserted
she → lead → Congress
Elmi reportedly posted a picture to Instagram of Omar’s newborn daughter in 2012 and referred to the baby as his “niece.”
uncertain
Elmi → post → niece
In another post, dated 2013, he allegedly captioned a photo of Omar’s other two daughters, “#nieces” and “#uncle.”
uncertain
he → date → #
Only screenshots, published by local conservative outlet Alpha News, exist of the alleged posts.
asserted
screenshots → publish → posts
…and 12 more, not listed.
The Aporia
