Claims extracted
28
sentences that state something as happening or true
Uncertain
7%
2 of 28 hedged
("reportedly", "may", "according to")
Leaning
withheld
no quote in the article backed the model's score
Publisher signals
61/100
The Sydney Morning Herald's corrections and
hedging, across everything collected from it. Not a measure of accuracy.
Outlets on this story
1
Politics
Same framing elsewhere
1
articles that frame the event the way this one does
One Nation MP Barnaby Joyce has angrily denied holding a meeting with prominent neo-Nazis in Canberra earlier this month, after news outlet Crikey sent him an email alleging he spent two hours talking with the extremists at the local casino one evening.
asserted
he → deny → casino
Joyce’s denial of the interaction comes just weeks after Australia’s neo-Nazi movement declared it would back One Nation’s path to government if the High Court overturns a ban on its new political party.
asserted
Court → come → party
Speaking to radio station 2GB on Wednesday, Joyce said he attended the Canberra Casino a fortnight ago for a social visit with a “good mate”, and was later approached by a group “unbeknownst” to him.
asserted
he → speak → him
“After a while, I start to get a little bit worried about them because they start talking about Anglo-Celtic and immigration and stuff like that.
asserted
they → start → that
So I quietly make my way away.
asserted
I → make → way
They go back to their table.
asserted
They → go → table
Apparently, they are the … National Socialists,” Joyce said.
asserted
Joyce → say → ?
“Now, the story that they’re running around is that I arrived with them.
asserted
I → run → them
That’s a lie.
asserted
That → ’ → ?
That’s a lie.
asserted
That → ’ → ?
I left with them.
asserted
I → leave → them
That’s a lie.
asserted
That → ’ → ?
Did I actually even know who they were when they came up?
asserted
they → know → ?
No, I didn’t.
asserted
I → do → ?
“I don’t follow the Nazi Party, but they seemed like weird dudes, and I made sure we stopped the conversation.
asserted
we → follow → conversation
And I went back and talked to some tradies from the Central Coast.
asserted
I → go → Coast
An email from a Crikey journalist to Joyce seen by this masthead reads: “We understand Mr Joyce entered and left the casino with a group of National Socialist Network members including Hugo Lennon and Thomas Sewell, staying for approximately two hours sitting and talking together, and at a point discussed the group’s ongoing legal matter before the High Court.”
asserted
Joyce → see → Court
The email requested comment and informed Joyce an article would be published at midday on Wednesday.
asserted
article → request → Wednesday
In a second media appearance on Wednesday morning, Joyce said he found neo-Nazis to be “disgraceful” and that he “can’t stand them”.
“My family fought against the fascists, I don’t want anything to do with them at all,” he told News24, formerly Sky News.
asserted
he → say → News24
The National Socialist Network, an openly neo-Nazi group, is petitioning the High Court to overturn laws passed after the Bondi massacre that outlawed neo-Nazi and Islamist groups.
asserted
that → petition → groups
Thomas Sewell – a notorious neo-Nazi who has called for a “race war” – and a team of lawyers are arguing the federal ban on the NSN’s successor, the White Australia Party, should be struck down because the Commonwealth was acting outside its power and was breaching the implied freedom of political communication and the separation of powers.
asserted
Commonwealth → call → powers
A court decision to strike down the laws would be a serious defeat for Prime Minister Anthony Albanese’s post-Bondi crackdown on hate groups and, according to Sewell, it would “assist the creation of a Pauline Hanson prime ministership”.
“Our purpose would be to support One Nation in forming government,” Sewell said outside the High Court on Thursday in a video posted on social media.
uncertain
Sewell → strike → media
“I believe that a factor in why the Labor government has decided to pass this legislation was not only because of the hysteria of the Israeli lobby, but also because they know that we can assist One Nation in forming government.
asserted
we → believe → government
“If this legislation is not overturned by the High Court, it could mean the difference between Pauline Hanson winning the election or not.”
uncertain
Hanson → overturn → election
Crikey editor Alisha Rouse said Joyce was contacted for comment as a matter of standard practice.
asserted
Joyce → say → practice
“A typical journalistic enquiry,” she said.
asserted
she → say → enquiry
“We still haven’t heard back!”
asserted
We → hear → ?
Subscribers can sign up to our weekly Inside Politics newsletter.
asserted
Subscribers → sign → newsletter
The Aporia
