The New South Wales government's plans for the country's largest dedicated koala national park have passed a key hurdle, but the plan to fund it has sparked debate over who should pay for conservation.
asserted
who → pass → conservation
The Great Koala National Park (GKNP) is planned to span 476,000 hectares running inland of Coffs Harbour, south to Kempsey and as far north as Grafton, and was a key promise from Labor during the 2023 state election.
asserted
Park → plan → election
The state government plans to help pay for its costs by selling carbon credits generated from ending logging, and earlier this month the Senate rejected a bid to block the scheme, keeping the park on track for delivery by the March 2027 election.
asserted
Senate → plan → election
Supporters say the park may never have happened without the credits, but critics argue governments should not need a financial incentive to create national parks.
uncertain
governments → say → parks
Carbon credits are generated by ending intensive farming practices, reforestation and other activities that take out more carbon dioxide from the atmosphere than they create.
asserted
they → generate → atmosphere
Through the Australian Clean Energy Regulator, projects are certified and the resulting carbon credit units can be sold on the market like shares on the exchange.
asserted
units → certify → exchange
Companies who either voluntarily want to lower their carbon footprint or are required to by law to do so have the opportunity to buy the credits.
asserted
Companies → want → credits
The NSW government plans on generating carbon credits by ending logging in 176,000ha of state forests set to become part of the GKNP.
asserted
government → generate → GKNP
Professor at the Crawford School of Public Policy at the Australian National University Frank Jotzo said many conservationists take issue with carbon credits because they do not encourage polluters to change their practices.
asserted
they → say → practices
"There's all manner of industrial companies as well as resource companies … who cover part of their emissions reduction obligation by paying for credits," he said.
asserted
he → be → credits
"You could take the opposing view and say these industrial and resource companies should be reducing their own emissions; that's where the fault line lies in the debate."
Who's paying?
Last year the NSW government finalised the boundaries of the GKNP and issued a moratorium on native logging in the proposed area.
uncertain
government → take → area
Instead of running the park at a cost to taxpayers, the upkeep would be covered by selling carbon credits, which would be prioritised to manufacturing industries and banned from fossil fuel companies.
asserted
which → run → companies
The plans needed the support of the federal government who runs the Clean Energy Regulator and decides on which projects are eligible to earn carbon credits.
asserted
projects → need → credits
Conservationists who oppose carbon credits disapproved of the GKNP project, and three federal Greens senators crossed the floor to vote with the Coalition to unsuccessfully block it.
asserted
senators → oppose → it
Should national parks pay for themselves?
asserted
parks → pay → themselves
While carbon credit schemes are not new, Professor Jotzo said Australia and China were both pioneering strategies to use them to encourage the preservation of forests.
"
asserted
Australia → say → forests
There is nothing that incentivises or compels state governments to create national parks; there is really no push factor in that regard," he said.
asserted
he → be → regard
"I think there's probably a bona-fide argument here that, without the carbon credits, the park might not have gone ahead.
uncertain
park → think → credits
"From that point of view, going ahead with [the GKNP] is unambiguously a good thing because we will see substantial carbon benefits and biodiversity benefits that flow from this."
asserted
that → go → this
University of New South Wales senior lecturer in public sector management Megan Evans said having to cover the costs of creating a national park sets a dangerous precedent.
"
asserted
having → say → precedent
I just find it extraordinary that we are having a discussion about how do we actually incentivise government [into] doing something that is actually their job," Dr Evans said.
asserted
Evans → find → something
"The idea that a state government is poor or unable to find the resources to create a national park is just an absolute lie.
asserted
government → find → park
It's a lie that has been manufactured and socialised and normalised by these discussions around how do we make national parks pay for themselves."
asserted
parks → manufacture → themselves
Dr Evans said the plans still have unresolved problems which are core to the ongoing debate about the efficacy of carbon credits offsetting polluting industries.
asserted
which → say → industries
"Offsets should only be a very last resort and they should be very expensive in order to incentivise that behaviour," she said.
asserted
she → incentivise → behaviour
"Spending tens or hundreds of millions of dollars on credits to ensure compliance is just spare change at the back of the couch [for many companies].
asserted
tens → spend → companies
We have a carbon credit regime that is in operation, but it's not actually facilitating the decarbonisation of Australia's economy."
asserted
it → have → economy
For and against
Despite her disapproval of carbon credits, New South Wales Greens MP Sue Higginson said the scheme was the best way to set up the GKNP.
asserted
scheme → say → GKNP
"This is the good method that actually sees the end of logging," she said.
asserted
she → see → logging
"The next method, the industry method, is nearly ready [and] would have seen carbon credits generated and logging continued."
asserted
logging → see → ?
National Parks Association NSW Coffs Coast branch chair Grahame Douglas described carbon offsets as "very inappropriate" but argued the GKNP plans have integrity.
"
asserted
plans → describe → integrity
It's not perfect, but it does provide a very real way forward for the management of these areas for conservation," Dr Douglas said.
asserted
Douglas → provide → conservation
Timber New South Wales president Andrew Hurford argued ending logging in the GKNP will have more harm on the environment than the predictions made by the carbon credits system.
asserted
ending → argue → system
"We know that when we don't produce timber here in Australia, we import it to make up the difference," he said.
asserted
he → know → difference
"We replace things like timber power poles … with fibreglass produced with resins out of petrochemicals or steel produced out of coal and iron ore, much higher emissions than anything the timber industry would produce.
asserted
industry → replace → anything
NSW Environment Minister Penny Sharpe welcomed the approval by the Senate and said future parks, including the Great Southern Forest National Park currently being advocated for, were also on her radar.
asserted
parks → welcome → radar
"Methods like [this] would create a framework that could make it easier to create projects like this," she said.
uncertain
she → create → this
The scheme still needs to be passed in the House of Representatives and approved by the Clean Energy Regulator before legislation for the GKNP will be introduced in the NSW Parliament.
asserted
legislation → need → Parliament
The Aporia