Twenty-seven years before Massachusetts proposed to dramatically expand a taxpayer-funded program sending nurses into the homes of families with newborns, legendary conservative firebrand and grassroots women’s leader Phyllis Schlafly posed a question that her daughter says now sounds remarkably familiar.
asserted
daughter → propose → question
"Are the American people willing to allow government agents to come into their homes to ‘advise’ them how to care for their babies?" Schlafly wrote in a March 1999 column titled, "Watch out for ‘Big Sister’ as Well as ‘Big Brother.’"
The warning has resurfaced as Massachusetts Gov. Maura Healey seeks $2 million to expand the state’s Welcome Family program, which offers nurse visits following childbirth.
asserted
which → allow → childbirth
The program currently serves approximately 3,000 births annually, with the expansion intended to make visits available following roughly 68,000 births statewide per year.
asserted
visits → serve → year
The push comes in the aftermath of the Lindsay Clancy case, which put a searing spotlight on maternal mental illness.
asserted
which → come → illness
Clancy does not dispute that she killed her three young children: Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months, inside their Duxbury home in 2023.
asserted
she → dispute → 2023
Clancy's defense argued she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and was not criminally responsible, while prosecutors argued she knew her actions were wrong.
asserted
actions → argue → psychosis
The jury deadlocked, resulting in a mistrial.
asserted
jury → deadlocke → mistrial
For Anne Schlafly, chairman of Eagle Forum and Phyllis Schlafly’s daughter, her mother’s warning has now taken on new resonance.
asserted
warning → take → resonance
"My mother was very prescient about the things that could happen if we let government intrude into our family lives," Schlafly told Fox News Digital.
uncertain
Schlafly → happen → Digital
"Her point was a government agent or an agent of the government has no business in your home, in your castle, snooping around and determining whether or not you’re raising the children the way the government wants you to raise the children," she said.
asserted
she → have → children
"
Phyllis Schlafly’s 1999 column focused on Healthy Families America and similar home-visiting initiatives, warning about programs that screened families for risk factors, connected parents with health and social services and offered parenting guidance inside the home.
asserted
that → focus → home
She also questioned whether programs officially described as "voluntary" would always operate that way in practice.
asserted
programs → question → practice
Massachusetts today describes Welcome Family as voluntary.
asserted
Massachusetts → describe → Family
Nurses assess the health of the "parents and caregivers" and newborn, answer questions about newborn care, screen for postpartum mental health concerns and connect families with additional services.
asserted
Nurses → assess → services
Notably, Massachusetts lists "ensuring that your home is safe" among the subjects Welcome Family nurses may advise parents about, though the program’s family information page does not specify particular home safety criteria.
uncertain
page → list → criteria
The state has called Welcome Family an "entry point into the system of care" for families with newborns.
asserted
state → call → newborns
Healthy Families America, the program at the center of Schlafly’s 1999 column, is also among the models Massachusetts lists within its broader Home Visiting Initiative, though it is separate from Welcome Family.
asserted
it → list → Family
Healey described her vision for the expansion in broader terms during an interview on Boston Public Radio.
asserted
Healey → describe → Radio
"Everybody in the state, when you have a baby, you’re going to have a home visit within days, weeks and that will be an opportunity for a healthcare provider to make an assessment to see if you need some additional support and resources," Healey said.
asserted
Healey → have → support
Anne Schlafly questioned what meaningful consent looks like shortly after childbirth.
asserted
consent → question → childbirth
"Is it really voluntary if you don’t have true informed consent?" Schlafly said.
asserted
Schlafly → have → consent
"If you have just given birth, you’ve been in labor, you’ve been under sedation, can you really recognize what you were signing up for supposedly on a voluntary basis?
asserted
you → give → basis
"
"I think mothers need to have the full disclosure that this would be a government agent in the home," she added.
asserted
she → think → home
The scale of the proposed expansion also concerns Schlafly.
asserted
scale → propose → Schlafly
"If government is going to expand their reach and hire a whole bunch of more people and use taxpayer money to send out all these agents to the families, I mean, that’s quite an expansion," she said.
asserted
she → go → families
"This idea of coming in to inspect and see what’s going on in your home smacks of Big Sister and Big Brother both."
asserted
what → come → Sister
Massachusetts does not characterize the visits as inspections, but as voluntary health and support services.
asserted
Massachusetts → characterize → services
State officials point to results from the existing program.
asserted
officials → point → program
In 2025, Welcome Family offered 1,620 postpartum depression screenings, with 208 screening positive.
asserted
208 → offer → screenings
The state says every person who screened positive received a referral for services.
asserted
who → say → services
Schlafly said she does not object to families choosing to accept that help.
asserted
families → say → help
"If people want to have this help from Governor Healey, then they can avail themselves of it," she said.
asserted
she → want → it
Her dividing line, she said, is whether parents retain the ability to refuse.
asserted
parents → divide → ability
"I think any time you make it compulsory, the line has been crossed," Schlafly said.
asserted
Schlafly → think → ?
"I would say the only way that this Massachusetts program could be acceptable is if the parents could opt out at any time."
uncertain
parents → say → time
Massachusetts’ published materials describe participation as voluntary.
asserted
materials → publish → participation
Fox News Digital reached out to Healey’s office for comment and clarification about parents’ ability to decline visits, information collected during visits and whether information may be shared with other state agencies.
uncertain
information → reach → agencies
Nearly three decades after her mother warned about "Big Sister" entering the family home, Schlafly said she believes she knows what her mother would tell Massachusetts parents today.
asserted
mother → warn → parents
"There’s no doubt that Phyllis Schlafly would advise parents to reject busybodies who want to inspect their home," she said.
asserted
she → ’ → home
"The home is a sacred and private area, and Governor Healey has no business in the homes of Massachusetts parents."
asserted
Healey → have → parents
…and 1 more, not listed.
The Aporia
