- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
An Alabama man who allegedly killed his wife and spent more than four decades in prison for the slaying will be getting a new trial in court.
uncertain
who → see → court
Charles McCrory was convicted and sentenced to life for slaying his wife, Julie Bonds McCrory, in May 1985, but could soon be free after a federal judge ordered that he get a re-trial for the murder or be released from prison.
uncertain
he → convict → prison
The case rested predominantly on two small marks on Julie's arm which the state and its expert said were bite marks that Charles made in a rageful, brutal murder.
asserted
Charles → rest → murder
Today, the technique of matching bite marks to a person's teeth is considered junk science.
asserted
technique → match → teeth
And the dentist who long ago testified against him has recanted, saying he can't even be sure the mark was made by teeth at all.
asserted
mark → testify → teeth
Chief US District Judge Austin Huffaker Jr wrote in a Monday order: 'The bitemark evidence clearly prejudiced the outcome of McCrory's trial, especially in light of the other evidence presented at trial.
'
asserted
evidence → write → trial
The non-bitemark evidence from which the jury could convict McCrory was thin.'
uncertain
jury → convict → McCrory
Huffaker's order said the Alabama Attorney General's Office has 180 days to begin a new trial for McCrory or release him from prison.
asserted
Office → say → prison
McCrory worked for 26 years as a tech worker and volunteer paramedic.
asserted
McCrory → work → worker
Despite no DNA, confessions or clear motive suggesting his guilt, he was always the main suspect in his wife's killing.
asserted
he → suggest → killing
Julie and Charles McCrory were in the middle of a divorce when Julie was found dead in her apartment in 1985
Charles McCrory spent nearly 40 decades in prison after being sentenced for life for the killing of his wife
Two bite marks were found on Julie's upper right arm as well as five 'chop' wounds to her head, 11 puncture wounds to her chest, fractured jaw bones, bruises
There was also no blood found on his clothes or in his apartment.
Dr Richard Souviron, a forensic dentist in Florida who previously matched a victim's wounds to Ted Bundy's teeth in his 1979 trial, testified at McCrory's trial that the two marks on Julie's arm matched her husband's teeth.
asserted
marks → find → teeth
The court ruled on Souviron's testimony as the sole physical evidence - a move which Huffaker criticized to have 'resulted in a fundamentally unfair trial.'
asserted
Huffaker → rule → trial
Huffaker added that the state court's decision in 2022 to deny Charles's request for a new trial was 'both an unreasonable application of clearly established federal law and was based on an unreasonable determination of the facts.'
Charles lived in a small apartment down the street from his wife and toddler son in Andalusia, Covington County, when the two were going through a divorce.
The two went to couple's therapy, spent time with their son, and had sex before Charles went back to his apartment on the night of May 30, 1985, he said.
uncertain
he → add → May
The two were often together and Julie's date book showed the possibility of her husband moving back in, AL.com reported.
asserted
AL.com → show → possibility
The method of bite mark matching that was the basis for McCrory's conviction is considered junk science today
Charles and Julie McCrory's son, Chad, lives in Alabama today.
asserted
son → consider → Alabama
The Daily Mail contacted him for comment
asserted
Mail → contact → comment
Six years ago, the state court offered Charles McCrory to walk out of prison if he admitted killing his wife.
asserted
he → offer → wife
He declined
Charles said he heard about the murder the next morning, when his paramedic radio signaled a call for help at his wife's home.
asserted
radio → decline → home
Julie was found lying in the front doorway of her home - severely beaten with five 'chop' wounds to her head, 11 puncture wounds to her chest, fractured jaw bones, bruises and two small marks on her upper right arm.
asserted
Julie → find → arm
The cause of the puncture marks was never confirmed.
asserted
cause → confirm → marks
At trial in October 1985, the case hinged on circumstantial evidence like McCrory's behavior and disputed witness statements as to cars at the family home.
asserted
case → hinge → home
The two small marks that Souviron said were made by McCrory's upper teeth were the only physical evidence.
asserted
Souviron → say → teeth
McCrory was convicted and sent to prison for the rest of his life, despite the lack of evidence.
asserted
McCrory → convict → evidence
In recent years, the technique of bite mark evidence was questioned and considered 'junk science' by national groups saying that this type of analysis lacks data.
asserted
type → question → data
Souviron took back his testimony in a 2019 affidavit: 'I no longer believe the individualized teeth marks comparison testimony I offered in his case was reliable or proper.'
asserted
I → take → case
He said he 'would not' give the same testimony today in Charles McCrory's case, adding that he never actually examined Julie's body and relied on photos instead.
asserted
he → say → photos
Despite the dentist's new statements, Alabama state courts denied a request from Charles's team of lawyers for a new trial.
asserted
courts → deny → trial
Prosecutors from the Alabama Attorney General's Office argued in 2021 that jurors could have simply looked at pictures of Julie's body and matched the markings themselves - to which the Alabama Criminal Court of Appeals agreed.
uncertain
Court → argue → Appeals
Huffaker commented on the suggestion: 'This finding blinks reality in light of the evidence.
asserted
finding → comment → evidence
'If an expert could not testify about bitemark identification because it is junk science, a jury should not have been allowed to consider it either.'
uncertain
jury → testify → it
'It makes little sense that a lay jury could permissibly form a conclusion that no forensic expert could.'
uncertain
expert → make → conclusion
Charles McCrory's lawyers cited 39 known wrongful convictions and indictments made on the basis of bite mark forensics - two of which were made on testimonies by Souviron.
asserted
two → cite → Souviron
Six years ago, the state offered McCrory to walk out of prison if he admitted to killing his wife - which he declined: 'What am I going to do, make up a story?
'
asserted
I → offer → story
I kind of chuckled...
asserted
I → chuckle → ?
I'm not going to plead guilty to something I didn't do,' he told AL.com.
asserted
he → go → AL.com
The Daily Mail contacted the Alabama Attorney General's Office and McCrory for comment.
asserted
Mail → contact → comment
The Aporia
